f ■ -r .- Th. /5 A^. Mysteries of Mithra By FRANZ^fcuMONT PROFESSOR IN THE UNIVERSITY OF GHENT, BELGIUM Translated from the Second Revised French Editiofi BY THOMAS J. McCORMACK PRINCIPAL OF THE LA SALLE AND PERU TOWNSHIP HIGH SCHOOL With a Frontispiece, Map, and Fifty Cuts and Illustrations CHICAGO The OPEN COURT PUBLISHING COMPANY LONDON KEGAN PAUL, TRENCH, TRUBNER & CO.. Ltd. 1903 TRANSLATION COPYRIGHTED BY THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING COMPANY CHICAGO 1903 PREFACE TO THE FRENCH EDITION THE present work, in which we purpose to treat of the origin and history of the Mithraic religion, does not pretend to offer a picture of the downfall of paganism. We shall not attempt, even in a general way, to seek for the causes which explain the establishment of the Oriental religions in Italy; nor shall we endeavor to show how their doctrines, which were far more active as fermenting agents than the theories of the philosophers, decom- posed the national beliefs on which the Roman state and the entire life of antiquity rested, and how the destruction of the edifice which they had disintegrated was ultimately accomplished by Chris- tianity. We shall not undertake to trace here the various phases of the battle waged between idol- atry and the growing Church; this vast subject, which we hope some day to approach, lies beyond the scope of the present work. We are concerned here with one epoch only of this decisive revolu- tion, it being our purpose to show with all the distinctness in our power how and why a certain Mazdean sect failed under the Caesars to become the dominant religion of the empire. The civilization of the Greeks had never suc- ceeded in establishing itself among the Persians, and the Romans were no more successful in subjecting the Parthians to their sway. The significant fact which dominates the entire history of Hither Asia is that the Iranian world and the Graeco-Latin world III IV PREFACE TO THE FRENCH EDITION remained forever unamenable to reciprocal assimi- lation, forever sundered as much by a mutual repul- sion, deep and instinctive, as by their hereditary hostility. Nevertheless, the religion of the Magi, which was the highest blossom of the genius of Iran, exercised a deep influence on Occidental culture at three different periods. In the first place, Parsee- ism had made a very distinct impression on Judaism in its formative stage, and several of its cardinal doctrines were disseminated by Jewish colonists throughout the entire basin of the Mediterranean, and subsequently even forced themselves on ortho- dox Catholicism. The influence of Mazdaism on European thought was still more direct, when Asia Minor was con- quered by the Romans. Here, from time imme- morial, colonies of Magi who had migrated from Babylon lived in obscurity, and, welding together their traditional beliefs and the doctrines of the Grecian thinkers, had elaborated little by little in these barbaric regions a religion original despite its complexity. At the beginning of our era, we see this religion suddenly emerging from the darkness, and pressing forward, rapidly and simultaneously, into the valleys of the Danube and the Rhine, and even into the heart of Italy. The nations of the Occident felt vividly the superiority of the Mazdean faith over their ancient national creeds, and the populace thronged to the altars of the exotic god. But the progress of the conquering religion was checked when it came in contact with Christianity. The two adversaries discovered with amazement, but with no inkling of their origin, the similarities PREFACE TO THE FRENCH EDITION V which united them; and they severally accused the Spirit of Deception of having endeavored to carica- ture the sacredness of their religious rites. The conflict between the two was inevitable, — a ferocious and implacable duel: for the stake was the dominion of the worldj No one has told the tale of its chang- ing fortunes, and our imagination alone is left to picture the forgotten dramas that agitated the souls of the multitudes when they were called upon to choose between Ormadz and the Trinity. We know the result of the battle only: Mithraism was van- quished, as without doubt it should have been. The defeat which it suffered was not due entirely to the superiority of the evangelical ethics, nor to that of the apostolic doctrine regarding the teaching of the Mysteries; it perished, not only because it was encumbered with the onerous heritage of a superan- nuated past, but also because 2ts__HUirgy and its theology had retained too mu^h^of its Asiatic coLpr- ing to be arr:ppf-fjj__h\^ ■th£_L,a<-in t;nirif \YJfhniit — s : — -"""tT repugnance. Tor a converse reason, the same battle, waged in the same epoch in Persia between these same two rivals, was without success, if not without honor, for the Christians; and in the realms of the Sassanids, Zoroastrianism never once was in serious danger of being overthrown^ The defeat of Mithraism did not, however, utterly annihilate its power. It had prepared the minds of the Occident for the reception of a new faith, which, like itself, came also from the banks of the Euphrates, and which resumed hostilities with entirely different tactics, Manichaeism appeared as its successor and continuator. This was the final assault made by Persia on the Occident, — an assault VI PREFACE TO THE FRENCH EDITION more sanguinary than the preceding, but one which was ultimately destined to be repulsed by the pow- erful resistance offered to it by the Christian empire. * * * * * The foregoing rapid sketch will, I hope, give some idea of the great importance which the his- tory of Mithraism possesses. A branch torn from the ancient Mazdean trunk, it has preserved in many respects the characteristics of the ancient worship of the Iranian tribes; and it will enable us by comparison to understand the extent, so much disputed, of the Avestan reformation. Again, if it has not inspired, it has at least contributed to give precise form to, certain doctrines of the Church, as the ideas relative to the powers of hell and to the end of the world. And thus both its rise and its decadence combine in explaining to us the formation of two great religions. In the heyday of its vigor, it exercised no less remarkable an influ- ence on the society and government of Rome. Never, perhaps, not even in the epoch of the Mus- sulman invasion, was Europe in greater danger of being Asiaticized than in the third century of our era, and there was a moment in this period when Caesarism was apparently on the point of being transformed into a Caliphate. The resemblances which the court of Diocletian bore to that of Chos- roes have been frequently emphasized. ^It was the worship of the sun, and in particular the Mazdean theories, that disseminated the ideas upon which the deified sovereigns of the West endeavored to rear their monarchical absolutismj The rapid spread of the Persian Mysteries among all classes of the population served admirably the political ambitions PREFACE TO THE FRENCH EDITION VII of the emperors. A sudden inundation of Iranian and Semitic conceptions swept over the Occident, threatening to submerge everything that the genius of Greece and Rome had so laboriously erected, and when the flood subsided it left behind in the conscience of the people a deep sediment of Ori- ental beliefs, which have never been completely obliterated. I believe I have said sufficient to show that the subject of which I am about to treat is deserving of exhaustive and profound study. Although my investigations have carried me, on many sides, much farther than I had at the outset intended to go, I still do not regret the years of labor and of travel which they have caused me. The work which I have undertaken could not have been other than difficult. On the one hand, we do not know to what precise degree the Avesta and the other sacred books , of the Parsees represent the ideas of the Mazdeans of the Occident; on the other, these books constitute the sole material in our possession for interpreting the great mass of figured monu- ments which have gradually been collected. The inscriptions by themselves are always a sure guide, but their contents are upon the whole very meager. Our predicament is somewhat similar to that in which we should find ourselves if we were called upon to write the history of the Church of the Middle Ages with no other sources at our command than the Hebrew Bible and the sculptured debi'is of Roman and Gothic portals. (For this reason, our explanations of the Mithraic imagery will frequently possess nothing more than a greater or less degree of probabilityJ I make no pretension to having VIII PREFACE TO THE FRENCH EDITION reached in all cases a rigorously exact decipherment of these hieroglyphics, and I am anxious to ascribe to my opinions nothing but the value of the argu- ments which support them. I hope nevertheless to have established with certainty the general signifi- cation of the sacred images which adorned the Mithraic crypts. On the details of their recondite symbolism it is difficult to throw much light. We are frequently forced to take refuge here in the ars nesciejidi. The following pages reproduce the "Conclusions" printed at the end of the first volume of my large work, Tcxtes ct 7nomimc7its figures rclatifs aux 7nystcrcs de Mithra (Brussels: H. Lamertin).* Stripped of the notes and references which there served to establish them, they are confined to epitomizing and co-ordinating the sum-total of the knowledge we possess concerning the origin and the characteristic features of the Mithraic religion. They will fur- nish, in fact, all the material necessary for read- ers desirous of general information on this subject. To impart the same solidity to all the various por- tions of the edifice we have been reconstructing has been impossible. The uncertainties and discontinu- ity of the tradition do not permit this. Persons desirous of examining the stability of the founda- tions upon which my expositions rest, should consult the critical discussions of the "Introduction" to my larger work, the purpose of which is to ascertain * Large octavo, 931 pages, 507 illustratious and g photo- gravure plates. This work, which is a monument of scholarship and industry, is a complete descriptive and critical collection of all the Mithraic texts, inscriptions, references, and monu- ments that have been recovered from antiquity. — T. J. McC. PREFACE TO THE FRENCH EDITION IX the meaning and value of the written documents, and especially of the figured monuments, there described. During the long period in which this work has been in preparation I have been frequently obliged to resort to that community of interest and sentiment which unites men of science throughout the world, and I may say I have rarely appealed to it in vain. The courtesy of devoted friends, several of whom are now no more, has often anticipated the expression of my wishes, and has spontaneously placed at my disposal things which I could scarcely have dared to request. I have endeavored in my large work to make due acknowledgment to each one of them. It would not be fitting to give in this place a mere mechanical list of the names of my collaborators, and by bestowing upon them commonplace thanks to appear in the light of cancelling the indebtedness which I owe them. But it is with a feeling of pro- found gratitude that I recall to mind the services which have been lavished upon me, and that, having now reached the end of my task, after more than ten years, I still think of all who have aided me in completing it. The first edition of the present work appeared in igoo, and a second was called for not long after- wards. Few changes have been made. We have added a few notes, made a few references to recent articles, and adorned the pages with a considerable number of illustrations.* The most important addi- tion is the chapter on Mithraic sculpture, which, * The illustrations of the French edition numbered twenty- two. The present English edition contains more than double that number.— T. J. McC. X PREFACE TO THE FRENCH EDITION in view of the extensive researches now being made as to the Oriental origins of Roman art, can- not fail to be of interest. We have also to thank the many critics who have so kindly reviewed our Mysteries of Mithra^ and have generously acknowledged that our reconstruction of this vanished creed rests upon an objective and complete interpretation of the sources. In a matter which is still so obscure, it was inevitable that certain divergences of opinion should have come to light, and our conclusions, at times bold, may, in certain points, have appeared to some erroneous. We have had regard for these expressions of doubt in our revision. If we have not always felt obliged to modify our opinion, it is not because we have not weighed the arguments of our critics, but because in so small a volume as the present, from which all discussions mustbe excluded, we had not the space to substantiate our conclusions. It is a delicate matter, we grant, to publish a text without the notes which support, explain, and modify it; but we trust that the reader will not feel too keenly this inevitable omission. Franz Cumont. Ghent, May ist, igo2. Table of Contents PAGE Preface to the French Edition . . . iii The Origins of Mithraism .... i The Dissemination of Mithraism in the Roman Empire .....•• 33 mithra and the imperial power of rome . 86 The Doctrine of the Mithraic Mysteries . 104 \ The Mithraic Liturgy, Clergy and Devotees 150 / Mithraism and the Religions of the Empire 175 ^ Mithraic Art 209 Index 229 List 6y^ Illustrations Ft-ontispiccc. Bas-relief of Aquileia. FIGURE 1. King Antiochus and Mithra. Bas-relief of Nemrood Dagh 2. Imperial Coins of Trapezus (Trebizond) . . . . 3. Bactrian Coins ........ 4. Tauroctonous, or Bull-slaying, Mithra. Typical Repre- sentation. (Borghesi Bas-relief from the Capitol. Now in the Louvre) ....... 5. Tauroctonous INIithra. Artistic Type. (St. Petersburg) 6. Tauroctonous Mithra. Artistic Type. (Vatican) 7. Tauroctonous Mithra. Early Artistic Type. (Boston) 8. King Antiochus and Ahura-Mazda. Bas-relief of Nem- rood Dagh ....... 9. Mithraic Medallion from Tarsus, Cilicia 10. Tauroctonous Mithra. (British Museum) - 11. Sun-God. Fragment of the Bas-relief of Virunum 12. Bas-relief of Osterburken 13. Plan of the Mithrseum of Heddernheim 14. Reverse of the Bas-relief of Heddernheim 15. Bas-relief of Neuenheim 16. Plan of a Mithrgeum in Ostia 17. Silvanus 18. Statues of Torch-bearers. (Lateran) 19. Pedestal Found at Carnuntum 20. Mithraic Kronos Found in Ostia 21. Mithraic Kronos of Florence . 22. Mithraic Kronos of Rome .... 23. Mithraic Kronos Found in Ostia 24. Fragment of a Bas-relief Found in Virunum 25. Bas-relief of Heddernheim 26. Bas-relief of London .... 27. Mithraic Cameo ..... 28. Mithraic Cameo, Showing Mithra and the Dioscuri 29. Statues of Torch-bearers. (Palermo) 30. Mithra Born from the Rock ... xiii ( Klagenf uit) 14 18 19 21 22 23 24 27 32 39 50 51 53 54 55 65 66 68 88 105 106 108 no "3 117 122 123 124 1 23 130 XIV LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS FIGURE PAGE 31. Mithra Born from the Rock 131 32. Fragment of Bas-relief of Virunum ..... 133 33. Tauroctonous and Taurophorous (Bull-bearing) Mithra. Clay Cup of Lanuvium . . . . . . 134 34. Two Bronze Mithraic Plaques. (Vatican) . . . 136 35. Bas-relief of Apulum i3g 36. Inscription to Mithra Nabarze. (Sarmizegetusa) . . 142 37. Tauroctonous Mithra. Bas-relief of Bologna . . 151 38. Mithraic Communion. Bas-relief of Konjica . . . 159 39. Restoration of a M it hrseum at Carnuntum . . . 163 40. Tauroctonous Mithra of Toronto 176 41. Mithraic Gems. (Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York City) 183 42. Mithraic Cameo 185 43. Sol, the Sun-God 186 44. The Passion of the God. Head of the So-called Dying Alexander of the Uffizi Gallery ..... 192 45. Bas-relief of Mayence. Mithra Drawing His Bow . 196 46. Chained Skeleton Discovered at Saarebourg . . . 204 47. Mithraic Dadophorus. Wrongly Restored as Paris . 212 48. Counterpart of the Preceding ... . . 213 49. Mithraic Kronos of Modena 222 50. Birth of Erichthonios. Greek Vase 225 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA THE ORIGINS OF MITHRAISM IN THAT unknown epoch when the ances- tors of the Persians were still united with those of the Hindus, they were already wor- shippers of Mithra. The hymns of the Vedas celebrated his name, as did those of the Avesta, and despite the differences obtaining between the two theological systems of which these books were the expression, tli^Vedic Mitra and the Iranian Mithra have preserved i/so many traits of resemblance that it is impos- sible to entertain any doubt concerning their common origin. Both religions saw in him a Vgod of light, invoked togetHer'with Heaven, bearing in the one case the name of Varuna and in the other that of Ahura; in ethics he was recognized _as^e^ protector of truth, the 'antagonist of falsehood and error. But the sacred poetry of India has preserved of him an s/ obscured memory only. A single fragment, and even that partially effaced, is all that has been specially dedicated to him. He appears mainly in incidental allusions, — the silent witnesses of his ancient grandeur. Still, though his physiognomy is not so distinctly 2 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA limned in the Sanskrit literature as it is in the Zend writings, the faintness of its outlines is not sufficient to disguise the primitive identity of his character. According to a recent theory, this god, with whom the peoples of Europe were unac- quainted, was not a member of the ancient Aryan pantheon. Mitra-Varuna, and the five other Adityas celebrated by the Vedas, like- wise Mithra-Ahura and the Amshaspands, who, according to the Avestan conception surround the Creator, are on this theory nothing but the sun, the moon, and the planets, the worship of which was adopted by the Indo-Iranians "from a neighboring people, their superiors in the knowledge of the starry firmament," who could be none other than the Accadian or Semitic inhabitants of Babylonia.* But this hypothetical adoption, if it really took place, must have occurred in a i)rehistoric epoch, and, without attempting to dissipate the ob- scurity of these primitive times, it will be sufficient for us to state that The tribes of Iran never ceased to worship Mithra from their first assumption of worldly power till the day of their conversion to Islamj In the Avesta, Mithra is the genius of the celestial light. He appears before sunrise on the rocky summits of the mountains; during the day he traverses the wide firmament in his chariot drawn by four white horses, and when ♦Oldenberg, Die Religion des Veda, 1894, p. 185. THE ORIGINS OF MITHRAISM 3 night falls he still illumines with flickering glow the surface of the earth, "ever waking, ever watchful." He is neither sun, nor moon, nor stars, but with "his hundred ears and his hundred eyes" watches constantly the world. Mithra hears all, sees all, knows all: none can 'deceive him. By^a^^jiatural transiTion~he be- came for ethics the god of truth and integ- rity, the one that was invoked in solemn oaths, "that pledged the fulfilment of contracts, that punished perjurers! The light that dissipates darkness restores happiness and life on earth; the heat that accompanies it fecundates nature. Mithra is "the lord of wide pastures," the one that ren- ders them fertile. "He giveTTT increase, he giveth abundance, he gfveth cattle, he giveth progeny and life." He scatters the waters of the heavens and causes the plants to spring forth from the ground; on them that honor him, he bestows health of body, abundance of riches, and talented posterity. For he is the dispenser not only of material blessings but of spiritual advantages as well. His is the beneficent genius that accords peace of con- science, wisdom, and honor along with pros- perity, and causes harmony to reign among all his votaries. The devas, who inhabit the places of darkness, disseminate on earth along with barrenness and suffering all manner of vice and impurity. Mithra, "wakeful and sleep- less, protects the creation of Mazda" against ^^ 4 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA their machinations. He combats unceasingly the spirits of evil; an^ the iniquitous that serve them feel also the terrible visitations of his wrath. From his celestial eyrie he spies out his enemies; armed in fullest panoply he swoops down upon them, scatters and slaugh- ters them. He desolates and lays waste the homes of the wicked, he annihilates the tribes and the nations that are hostile to him. On the other hand he is the puissant ally of the faithful in their warlike expeditions. The blows of their enemies "miss their mark, for Mithra, sore incensed, receives them"; and he assures victory unto them that "have had fit instruction in the Good, that honor him and offer him the sacrificial libations."* This character of god of hosts, which has been the predominating trait of Mithra from the days of the Achaemenides, undoubtedly became accentuated in the period of confusion during which the Iranian tribes were still at war with one another; but it is after all only the development of the ancient conception of struggle between day and night. In general, the picture that the Avesta offers us of the old Aryan deity, is, as we have already said, similar to that which the Vedas have drawn in less marked outlines, and it hence follows that Mazdaism left its main primitive founda- tion unaltered. Still, though the Avestan hymns furnish the *^ Zend-Avesta, Yasht, 'K., passz'tn. THE ORIGINS OF MITHRAISM 5 distinctest glimpses of the true physiognomy of the ancient god of light, the Zoroastrian system, in adopting his worship, has singularly lessened his importance. As the price of his admission to the Avestan Heaven, he was compelled to submit to its laws. Theology had placed Ahura-Mazda on the pinnacle of the celestial hierarchy, and thenceforward it could recognize none as his peer. Mithra was not even made one of the six Amshaspands that aided the Supreme Deity in governing the universe. He was relegated, with the majority of the ancient divinities of nature, to the host of lesser genii or yazatas created by Mazda. He was associated with some of the deified abstractions which the Persians had learned to worship. As protector of warriors, he received for his companion, Verethraghna, or Victory; as the defender of the truth, he was associated with the pious Sraosha, or Obedience to divine law, with Rashnu, Justice, with Arshtat, Rectitude. As the tutelar gen- ius of prosperity, he is invoked with Ashi- Vafiuhi, Riches, and wnth Pareildi, Abundance. In company with Sraosha and Rashnu, he protects the soul of the just against the demons that seek to drag it down to Hell, and under their guardianship it soars aloft to Par- adise. This Iranian belief gave birth to the doctrine of redemption by Mithra, which we find developed in the Oeeident. At the same time, his cult was subjected to O THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA a rigorous ceremonial, conforming to the Mazdean liturgy. Sacrificial offerings were made to him of "small cattle and large, and of flying birds." These immolations were pre- ceded or accompanied with the usual libations of the juice of Haoma, and with the recitation of ritual prayers, — the bundle of sacred twigs {barcsman^ always in the hand. But before daring to approach the altar, the votary was obliged to purify himself by repeated ablutions and fiagellations. These rigorous prescrip- tions recall the rite of baptism and the cor- poreal tests imposed on the Roman neophytes before initiation. Mithra, thus, was adopted in the theological system of Zoroastrianism; a convenient place was assigned to him in the divine hierarchy; he was associated with companions of unim- peachable orthodoxy; homage was rendered to him on the same footing with the other genii. But his puissant personality had not bent lightly to the rigorous restrictions that had been imposed upon him, and there are to be found in the sacred text vestiges of a more ancient conception, according to which he occupied in the Iranian pantheon a much more elevated position. Several times he is invoked in company with Ahura: the two gods form a pair, for the light of Heaven and Heaven itself are in their nature inseparable. Furthermore, if it is said that Ahura created Mithra as he did all things, it is likewise said THE ORIGINS OF MITHRAISM 7 that he made him just as great and worthy as himself. Mithra is indeed a yazata, but he is also the most potent and most glorious of the yazatas. "Ahura-Mazda established him to maintain and watch over all this moving world." * It is through the agency of this ever-victorious warrior that the Supreme Being destroys the demons and causes even the Spirit of Evil, Ahriman himself, to tremble. Compare these texts w^ith the celebrated passage in which Plutarchf expounds the dual- istic doctrine of the Persians: Oromazes dwells in the domain of eternal light "as far above the sun as the sun is distant from the v/ earth" 5 Ahriman reigns in the realm of dark- (^ ness, and Mithra occupies an intermediary place between them. The beginning of the Bundahisht expounds a quite similar theory, save that in place of Mithra it is the air {Vayii) that is placed between Ormazd and Ahriman. The contradiction is only one of terms, for according to Iranian ideas the air is indissokibly conjoined with the light, which it is thought to support. In fine, a supreme^, god, enthroned in the empyrean above the! stars, where a perpetual serenity exists; below him an active deity, his emissary and chief of the celestial armies in their ceaseless combat *Yasht, X., 103. f Plutarch, Dc Iside et Osiridc, 46-47 ; Textes ct ni07iU7ncnis, Vol. II., p. 33. :I;West, Pahlavi^ T,- rf <• , I. (also, Sacred Books of the East, v.), 1S80, p. 3, et seq?^^ 8 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA ^with the Spirit of Darkness, who from the bowels of Hell sends forth his devas to the surface of the earth,— this is the religious con- \ caption, far simpler than that of Zoroastrianism, ' which appears to have been generally accepted among the subjects of the Achgemenides^ The coiispicuous role that the religion of the ancient Persians accorded to MJthra is attested by a multitude of proofs. JI'5£R'VlI.O.^O].-AA'V'n:J Fig. 10. TAUROCTONOUS MITHRA. (Marble group of the second century, British Museum.) The remarkable feature of this group is that not blood, but three spikes of wheat, issue from the wound of the bull. According to the Mithraic theory, wheat and the vine sprang from the spinal cord and the blood of the sacrificed animal (see the Chapter on "The Doctrine of the Mithraic Mysteries"). T. el J/., p. 22S. the local history of Mithraism. It is impos- sible for us to follow the detailed steps in its advancement, to distinguish the concurrent influences exercised by the different churches. 40 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA to draw up a picture of the work of conver- sion, pursuing its course from city to city and province to province. All that we can do is to indicate in large outlines in what countries the new faith was propagated and who were in general the champions that advocated it. fl I The principal agent of its diffusion was p^jndoubtedly the army. The Mithraic religion^ is predominantly a religion of soldiers, and it ' was not without good reason that the name of milites was given to a certain grade of initiates. The influence of the army may appear less capable of affording an explana- tion when one reflects that under the emper- ors the legions were quartered in stationary encampments, and from the time of Hadrian at least (i 17-138 A.D.) they were severally recruited from the provinces in which they were stationed. But this general rule was subject to numerous exceptions. Thus, for example, the Asiatics contributed for a long time the bulk of the effective troops in Dal- matia and Moesia, and for a certain period in Africa also. Furthermore, the soldier who after several years of service in his native country had been promoted to the rank of centurion was as a rule transferred to, some foreign station; and after he had passed through the different stages of his second charge he was often assigned to a new garri- son, so that the entire body of centurions of any one legion constituted "a sort of micro- MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 4I cosm of the empire."* These officers were a potent source of influence, for their very posi-|^ tfon insured to them a considerable moral influence over the conscripts whom it was their vocation to instruct. In addition to this individual propaganda, which is almost totally withdrawn from our ken, the temporary or permanent transfers of single detachments, and sometimes of entire regiments, to remotely situated fortresses or camps brought together people of all races and beliefs. Finally, there were to be found side by side with the legion- aries who were Roman citizens, an equal, if not a greater, number of foreign atixzlia, who did not, like their comrades, enjoy the privi- lege of serving in their native country. Indeed, in order to forestall local uprisings, it was a set part of the imperial policy to remove these foreign troops as far as possible from the country of their origin. Thus, under the Flavians, the indigenous aiai or cohorts formed but a minimal fraction of the auxil- iaries that guarded the frontiers of the Rhine and the Danube. Among the recruits summoned from abroad to take the place of the national troops sent to distant "parts were numerous Asiatics, and ^perhaps no country of the Orient furnished, relatively to the extent of its territory, a greater number of Roman soldiers than Com- magene, where Mithraism had struck deepest *Jung, Fas i en der Provinz Dacien, 1894, p. xiv. 42 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA root. In addition to horsemen and legion- aries, there were levied in this country, prob- ably at the time of its union with the empire, at least six cohorts of allies {auxilici). Numer- ous also were the native soldiers of Cappa- docia, Pontus, and Cilicia, not to speak of Syrians of all classes; and the Caesars did not scruple even to enroll those agile squadrons of Parthian cavalry with whose warlike quali- ties they had, to their own cost, but too often been made acquainted. The Roman soldier was, as a rule, pious and even superstitious. The many perils to which he was exposed caused him to seek unremit- tingly the protection of Heaven, and an incal- culable number of dedicatory inscriptions bears witness both to the vivacity of his faith and to the variety of his beliefs. The Orien- tals especially, transported for twenty years and more into countries which were totally strange to them, piously preserved the mem- ories of their national divinities, and when- ever the opportunity offered, they did not fail to assemble for the purpose of rendering them devotion. They had experienced the need of conciliating the great lord {Baal), whose anger as little children they had learned to fear. Their worship also offered an occasion for reunion, and for recalling to memory under the gloomy climates of the North their distant country. But their brotherhoods were not exclusive; they gladly admitted to their rites MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 43 those of their companions in arms, of what- ever origin, whose aspirations the official re- ligion of the army failed to satisfy, and who hoped to obtain from the foreign god more efficacious succor in their combats, or, in case of death, a happier lot in the life to come. Afterwards, these neophytes, transferred to other garrisons according to the exigencies of the service or the necessities of war, from converts became converters, and formed about them a new nucleus of proselytes. In this manner, the Mysteries of Mithra, first brought to Europe by semi-barbarian recruits from Xappadocia or Commagene^ were rapidly dis-^ seminated to the utmost confines of the an- "cient world. "From the banks of the Black Sea to the mountains of Scotland and to the borders of "the great Sahara Desert, along the entire length of the Roman frontier, Mithraic mon- 'uments abound. Lower Moesia, which was- "Tiot explored until very recently, has already furnished a number of them,— a circumstance which will not excite our astonishment when it is remembered that Oriental contingents supplied in this province the deficiency of native conscripts. To say nothing of the port of Tomi, legionaries practised the Per- sian cult at Troesmis, at Durostorum, and at CEscus, as well as at the Tropccuui Traiani, which the discovery of the monuments of Adam-Klissi has recently rendered celebrated. 44 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA In the interior of the country, this cult pene- trated to Montana and to Nicopolis; and it is doubtless from these northern cities that ii crossed the Balkans and spread into the north- ern parts of Thrace, notably above Serdica ^Sofia) ?.nd as far as the environs of Philippop- olis in the valley of the Hebrus. Ascending the Danube, it gained a footing at Vimina- cium, the capital of Upper Mcesia; but we are ignorant of the extent to which it spread in this country, which is still imperfectly explored. The naval flotilla that patrolled the waters of this mighty river was manned and even com- manded by foreigners, and the fleet undoubt- edly disseminated the Asiatic religion in all the ports it touched. We are better informed regarding the cir- cumstances of the introduction of Mithra- ism into Dacia. When in 107 A.D. Trajan annexed this barbarous kingdom to the Ro- man empire, the country, exhausted by six years of obstinate warfare, was little more than a desert. To repopulate it, the emperor transported to it, as Eutropius* tells us, mul- titudes of colonists "ex toto orbe Romano',' from all the territories of Rome. The population of this country was even more mixed in the second century than it is to-day, where all the races of Europe are still bickering and battling with one another. Besides the remnants of the ancient Dacians, were found here Illyrians *Eutropius, VIII, 6. MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 45 and Pannonians, Galatians, Carians, and Asic^tics, people from Edessa and Palmyra, and "^itill others besides, all of whom contin- ued to practise the religions of their native countries. But none of these cults prospered more than the Mysteries of Mithra, and one is astounded at the prodigious development that this religion took during the 150 years that the Roman domination lasted in this region. It flourished not only in the capital of the province, Sarmizegetusa, and in the cities that sprang up near the Roman camps, like Potaissa and notably Apulum, but along the entire extent of the territory occupied by the Romans. Whereas one cannot find in Dacia, so far as I know, the slightest vestige of a Christian community, from the fortress Szamos Ujvar to the northern frontier and as far as Romula in Wallachia, multitudes of inscriptions, of sculptures, and of altars which have escaped the destruction of mithrgeums have been found. These ddbris especially abound in the central portions of the country, along the great causeway that followed the course of the valley of the Maros, the princi- pal artery by which the civilization of Rome spread into the mountains of the surround- ing country. The single colony of Apulum counted certainly four temples of the Persian deity, and the spelceiiui of Sarmizegetusa, recently excavated, still contains the frag- ments of a round fifty of bas-reliefs and other 46 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA votive tablets which the piety of the faithful had there consecrated to their god. Likewise in Pannonia, the Iranian rehgion implanted itself in the fortified cities that formed the chain of Roman defences along the Danube, in Cusum, Intercisa, Aquincum, Brigetio, Carnuntnm, Vindobona, and even in the hamlets of the interior. It was especially powerful in the two principal places of this double province, in Aquincum and in Carnun- tum; and in both of these cities the causes of its greatness are easily discovered. The first-named city, where in the third century the Mysteries were celebrated in at least five temples scattered over its entire area, was the headquarters of the legio II adjiitrix* which had been formed in the year 70 A.D. by Vespasian from sailors of the fleet sta- tioned at Ravenna. Among the freedmen thus admitted into the regular army, the pro- portion of Asiatics was considerable, and it is probable that from the very beginning Mithra- ism counted a number of adepts in this irreg- ular legion. When towards the year 120 A.D. it was established by Hadrian in Lower Pan- nonia, it undoubtedly brought with it to this place the Oriental cult to which it appears to have remained loyal to the day of its dissolu- tion. The Icg'io I adjiiti'ix, which had a similar *One of the legions raised by the proconsuls in the Roman provinces for the purpose of strengthening the veteran army. — Trans. MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 4/ origin, probably sowed the fertile seeds of Mithraism in like manner in Brigetio, when under Trajan its camp was transferred to that place. We can determine with even greater pre- cision the manner in which the Persian god arrived at Carnuntum. In 71 or 72 A.D., Ves- pasian caused this important strategic posi- tion to be occupied by the Icgio XV Apol- linaris, which for the preceding eight or nine years had been warring in the Orient. Sent in 63 A.D. to the Euphrates to reinforce the army which Corbulo was leading against the Parthians, it had taken part during the years 67 to 70 A.D. in suppressing the upri- sings of the Jews, and had subsequently accom- panied Titus to Alexandria. The losses which this veteran legion had suffered in these san- guinary campaigns were doubtless made good with recruits levied in Asia. These conscripts were for the most part probably natives of Cappadocia, and it was they that, after their transportation to the Danube with the old rank and file of the legion, there first offered sacrifices to the Iranian god whose name had been hitherto unknown in the region north of the Alps. There has been found at Car- nuntum a votive Mithraic inscription due to a soldier of the Apollinarian legion bearing the characteristic name of Barbarus. The first worshippers of the Sol hivictus conse- crated to him on the banks of the river a 48 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA semicircular grotto, which had to be restored from its ruins in the third century by a Roman knight, and whose high antiquity is evidenced in all its details. When, some forty years after its arrival in the Occident, Trajan again transported the fifteenth legion to the Euphrates, the Persian cult had already struck deep roots in the capital of Upper Pannonia. Not only the fourteenth legion, gemma Alartia, which replaced that which had returned to Asia, but also the sixteenth and the thirteenth gcDiince, certain detachments of which were, as it appears, connected with the first-mentioned legion, succumbed to the allurements of the Mys- teries and counted initiates in their own ranks. Soon the first temple was no longer adequate, and a second was built, which — and this is an important fact — immediately adjoined the temple of Jupiter Dolichenus of Commagene. A municipality having developed alongside the camp and the conversions continuing to multiply, a third mithrgcum was erected, prob- ably towards the beginning of the second cen- tury, and its dimensions surpass those of all similar structures hitherto discovered. It was enlarged by Diocletian and the princes asso- ciated with him in 307 A.D., when they held their conference at Carnuntum. Thus these princes sought to give public testimony of their devotion to Mithra in this holy city, which of all those in the North probably contained the MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 49 most ancient sanctuaries of the Mazdean sect. This warlike post, the most important in the entire region, seems also to have been the religious center from which the foreign cult radiated into the smaller towns of the sur- rounding country. Stix-Neusiedl, where it was certainly practised from the middle of the second century, was only a dependent village of this powerful city. But farther to the south the temple of Scarbantia was enriched by a decurio colonics Carnuntt. Towards the east the territory of yEquinoctium has furnished a vo- tive inscription to the Petrcc Geneti'ici, and still farther off at Vindobona (Vienna) the soldiers of the tenth legion had likewise learned, doubtless from the neighboring camp, to cele- brate the Mysteries, Even in Africa, traces are found of the influence which the great Pannonian city exercised on the development of Mithraism. Several leagues from Vienna, passing across the frontier of Noricum, we come upon the hamlet of CommagencE, the name of which is doubtless due to the fact that a squadron of Commageneans (an ala Coinmagenoruni) was there quartered. One is not surprised, there- fore, to learn that a bas-relief of the tauroc- tonous god has been discovered here. Never- theless, in this province, as in Rhaetia, the army does not seem to have taken, as it did in Pan- nonia, an active part in the propagation of the 50 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA Asiatic religion. A belated inscription of a spccidaior Icgiouis I Xoricoriini is the only one in these countries that mentions a soldier; and generally the monuments of the Mysteries are very sparsely scattered in the valley of the Upper Danube, where the Roman troops were concentrated. They are not found in increased numbers until the other slope of the Alps is reached, and the epigraphy of this last-named region forbids us to assign to them a military origin. Fig. II. SUN-GOD. (Fragment from the grand bas-relief of Virunum, in Noricum. T. ct M., p. 336.) On the other hand, the marvellous extension that Mithraism took in the two Germanies is undoubtedly due to the powerful army corps that defended that perpetually menaced terri- tory. We find here an inscription dedicated by a centurion to the Soli Invicto Mithra: about the year 148 A.D., and it is probable that in MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 51 the middle of the second century this god had already obtained a goodly number of converts in the Roman garrisons. All the regiments appear to have been seized with the contagion: the legions VIII Augusta, XII Priuiigaiia, and XXX Ulpia, the cohorts and auxiliary ahr, as well as the picked troops of citizen volun- Fig. 12. MITHRAIC BAS-RELIEF OF OSTERBURKEN. (Discovered in 1S61 near the ruins of a Roman fort, in the Odenwald, Hesse. T. et J/., Plate VI.) teers. So general a diffusion prevents us from telling exactly from what side the foreign religion entered this country, but it may be assumed without fear of error that, save pos- sibly at a certain few points, it was not imported directly from the Orient, but was transmitted through the agency of the garri- sons on the Danube; and if we wish to assign 52 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA absolutely the circumstances of its origin we may take it for granted, with every likelihood of truth, that the eighth legion, which was transferred from Moesia to Upper Germany in the year 70 A.D., first practised there the religion which was soon destined to become the preponderating one of this country. Of all countries Germany is that in which the greatest number of mithrceums, or places of Mithraic worship, has been discovered. Germany has given us the bas-reliefs having the greatest dimensions and furnishing the most complete representations; and certainly no god of paganism ever found in this nation as many enthusiastic devotees as Mithra. The Agi'i Dccuniatcs, a strip of land lying on the right bank of the Rhine and forming the military confines of the empire, together with the advance posts of the Roman military sys- tem between the river Main and the fortified walls of the limes, have been marvellously fertile in discoveries. North of Frankfort, near the village of Heddernheim, the ancient civiias Tajinensiuin, three important temples have been successively exhumed (Figs. 13, 14); three others existed in Friedberg in Hesse and three more have been dug out in the sur- rounding country. On the other side, along the entire course of the Rhine, from Augst (Raurica) near Basel as far as Xanten (Vetera), passing through Strassburg, Mayence, Neu- wied, Bonn, Cologne, and Dormagen, a series MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 53 1^ Ir- tfl bo 'a 'c1 1 o o ,, — ^ c^. 0) 6 Ph _d < fcH o 1 s 1 1— 1 Ph wj w a. ffi 3^ :z; I-. U3 ^ ^ Q 'C Q OJ t-. W o K d 'O < 1 t 0) Q tn w S-4 .fc! o c^ > 'rt rt M O Oi . u tfl C/2 bjO (/2 o £ Q +-> D O PI 1 s o a 'S5 5 P^ 1 bo . ^ 9 f^ di o . < rt '^• C ra "^ fci a JJ -^ o ^ bo "So 2 2 ^ < ^ — J w Ph ■fe ,n <^ '^ § q bo Sort O . •'-' pu. (U ■^^-•^kXi;^^-;^^ 54 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA of monuments have been found which show clearly the manner in which the new faith spread like an epidemic, and was disseminated '■IP -dx. -^mwn Fig. 14. REVERSE OF THE GRAND MITHRAIC BAS-RELIEF OF HEDDERNHEIM, GERMANY. into the very heart of the barbarous tribes of the Ubians and Batavians. The influence of Mithraism among the troops massed along the Rhenish frontier MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 55 Fig. 15. BAS-RELIEF OF NEUENHEIM, NEAR HEIDELBERG, GERMANY. This monument, which escaped mutilation at the hands of the early fanatics, was discovered in 1838 in a cave near Neuenheim, a village on the southern slope of the Heiligenberg, near Heidelberg, by work- men who were laying the foundation of a farmhouse. It is interesting as distinctly showing in a series of small bas-reliefs twelve important scenes from the life of Mithra, including the following: His birth from the rocks (top of left border), his capture of the bull, which he carries to the cave (right hand border), his ascent to Ahura- Mazda (top border). The second scene from the top of the left border is likewise interesting; it represents Kronos (Zervan) handing to Zeus (Ahura- Mazda) the scepter of the government of the world. is also proved by the extension of this rehg- ion into the interior of Gaul. A soldier of the eighth legion dedicated an altar to the Deo 56 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA Invicto at Geneva, which lay on the mihtary road from Germany to the Mediterranean; and other traces of the Oriental cult have been found in modern Switzerland and the French Jura. In Sarrebourg {^Pons Saravi) at the mouth of the pass leading from the Vosges Mountains, by which Strassburg com- municated and still communicates with the basins of the Mosel and the Seine, a spekeum has recently been exhumed that dates from the third century; another, of which the principal bas-relief, carved from the living rock, still subsists to our day, existed at Schwarzerden, between Metz and Mayence. It would be surprising that the great city of Treves, the regular residence of the Roman military commanders, has preserved only some dd^ris of inscriptions and statues, did not the important role which this city played under the successors of Constantine explain the almost total disappearance of the monu- ments of paganism. Finally, in the valley of the Meuse, not far from the route that joins Cologne with Bavay {Bagacuni), some curious remains of the Mysteries have been discov- ered. From Bavay, this route leads to Boulogne {Gesoriacum), the naval base of the classis Britannica or Britannic fleet. The statues of the two dadophors, or torch-bearers, which have been found here and w^ere certainly chiselled on the spot, were doubtless offered MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 5/ to the god by some foreign mariner or officer of the fleet. It was the object of this impor- tant naval station to keep in daily touch with the great island that lay opposite, and espe- cially with London, which even at this epoch was visited by numerous merchants. The existence of a mithrgeum in this principal commercial and military depot of Britain should not surprise us. Generally speaking, the Iranian cult was in no country so com- pletely restricted to fortified places as in Britain. Outside of York {Eburacum), where the headquarters of the troops of the prov- ince were situated, it was disseminated only in the west of the country, at Caerleon {Isca) and at Chester {Deva), where camps had been established to repel the inroads of the Gallic tribes of the Silures and the Ordovices; and finally in the northern outskirts of the country along the wall of Hadrian, which protected the territory of the empire from the incur- sions of the Picts and the Caledonians. All the stations of this line of ramparts appear to have had their Mithraic temple, where the commander of the place {pvirfcctiis) furnished an example of devotion for his subordinates. It is evident, therefore, that the Asiatic god had penetrated in the train of the army to these northern regions, but it is impossible to determine precisely the period at which he reached this place or the troops by whom he was carried there. But there is reason for 58 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA believing that Mithra was worshipped in these countries from the middle of the second cen- tury, and that Germany* served as the inter- mediary agent between the far Orient ^'Et penitus toto divisos orbe Britannos." j\t the other extremity of the Roman world the Mysteries were likewise celebrated by s"oldiers. They had their adepts in the third legion encamped at Lamb?cse and in the posts that guarded the defiles of the Aurasian Mountains or that dotted the frontiers of the Sahara Desert. Nevertheless, they do not appear to have been as popular to the south of the Mediterranean as in the countries to the north, and their propagation has assumed here a special character. Their monuments, nearly all of which date from later epochs, are due to the officers, or at least to the cen- turions, many of whom were of foreign origin, rather than to the simple soldiers, nearly all of whom were levied in the country which they were charged to defend. The legionaries of Numidia remained faithful to their indigenous gods, who were either Punic or Berber in ori- gin, and only rarely adopted the beliefs of the companions with whom their vocation of arms had thrown them in contact. Apparently, therefore, the Persian religion was practised in Africa almost exclusively by those whom military service had called to these countries ♦See supra, p. i. MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 59 from abroad; and the bands of the faithful were composed for the most part, if not of Asiatics, at least of recruits drawn from the Danubian provinces. Finally, in Spain, the country of the Occi- dent which is poorest in Mithraic monuments, the connection of their presence with that of the garrisons is no less manifest. Through- out the entire extent of this vast peninsula, in which so many populous cities were crowded together, they are almost totally lacking, even in the largest centers of urban popula- tion. Scarcely the faintest vestige of an inscription is found in Emerita and Tarraco, the capitals of Lusitania and Tarraconensis. But in the uncivilized valleys of Asturias and Gallgecia the Iranian god had an organized cult. This fact will be immediately connected with the prolonged sojourn of a Roman le- gion in this country, which remained so long unsubjugated. Perhaps the conventicles of the initiated also included veterans of the Spanish cohorts who, after having served as auxiliaries on the Rhine and the Danube, returned to their native hearths converted to the Mazdean faith. f The army thus united in the same fold citi- zens and emigrants from all parts of the world; kept up an incessant interchange of officers and centurions and even of entire I army-corps from one province to another, according to the varying needs of the day; in I 60 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA ' fine, threw out to the remotest frontiers of the Roman world a net of perpetual commu- nications. Yet this was not the only way in which the military system contributed to the dissemination of Oriental religions. ^After. the expiration of their term of service, the soldiers continued in their places of retire- ment the practices to which they had become accustomed under the standards of the army; and they soon evoked in their new environ- ment numerous imitators. Frequently they settled in the neighborhood of their latest station, in the little towns which had grad- ually replaced in the neighborhood of the military camps the shops of the sutlers. At times, too, they would choose their homes in some large city of the country where they had served, to pass there with their old com- rades in arms the remainder of their days. Lyons always sheltered within its walls a large number of these veteran legionaries of the German army, and the only Mithraic inscrip- tion that London has furnished us was written by a soldier emeritus of the troops of Britain. It was customary also for the emperor to send discharged soldiers to some region where a colony was to be founded; Elusa in Aquitania was probably made acquainted with the Asiatic cult by Rhenish veterans whom Sep- timius Severus (193-21 1 A.D.) established in this region. Frequently, the conscripts whom the military authorities transported to the MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 6l confines of the empire retained at heart their love for their native country, with which they never ceased to sustain relations; but when, after twenty or twenty-five years of struggle and combat, they returned to their native country, they preferred to the gods of their own city or tribe, the foreign deity whose mys- terious worship some military comrade had taught them in distant lands. Nevertheless, the propagation of Mithraism) in the towns and country districts of the provf inces in which no armies were stationed was ; due in great measure to other agencies. By her continued conquests in Asia, Rome had subjected to her domination numerous Semitic provinces. After the founding of the empire had assured peace to the entire Roman world and permanently insured the safety of com- merce, these new subjects, profiting by the special aptitudes of their race, could be seen gradually concentrating in their hands the entire traffic of the Levant. As the Phoeni- cians and Carthaginians formerly, so now the Syrians populated with their colonies all the shores of the Mediterranean. In the Hellenic epoch they had established them- selves in the commercial centers of Greece, and notably at Delos, A number of these mer- chants now flocked to the vicinity of Rome, settling at Pozzuoli and at Ostia. They appear to have carried on business in all the mari- time cities of the Occident. They are found 62 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA in Italy at Ravenna, Aquileia, and Tergeste; at Salonai in Dalmatia, and as far distant as Malaga in Spain. Their mercantile activity even led them into the distant interior of these countries at every point where there was the least prospect of profit. In the valley of the Danube they penetrated as far as Sarmizegetusa and Apulum in Dacia, and as far as Sirmium in Pannonia. In Gaul, this Oriental population was particularly dense. They reached Bordeaux by the Gironde and ascended the Rhone as far as Lyons. After occupying the banks of this river, they flocked into the interior of the province, and Treves, the great capital of the north, attracted them in hordes. They literally filled the Roman world. Even the later invasions of the bar- barians were impotent to dampen their spirit of enterprise. Under the Merovingians they still spoke their Semitic idiom at Orleans. Their emigration was only checked when the Saracens destroyed the navigation of the Med- iterranean. The Syrians were distinguished in all epochs by their ardent zeal. No people, not even the Egyptians, defended their idols with such great pertinacity against the Christians. So, when they founded a colony, their first care was to organize their national cults, and the mother country frequently allowed them gen- erous subsidies towards the performance of this pious duty. It was in this manner that MITHRAISIM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 63 the deities of Heliopolis, of Damascus, and Palmyra first penetrated to Italy. The word Syrian had in popular usage a very vague significance. This word, which was an abbreviation of Assyrian, was frequently confounded with it, and served to designate generally all the Semitic populations anciently subject to the kings of Nineveh, as far east as, and even beyond, the Euphrates. It embraced, therefore, the sectaries of Mithra established in the valley of this river; and as Rome extended her conquests in this quarter, the worshippers of the Persian god necessarily became more and more numerous among the_ "Syrians" who dwelt in the Latin cities. Nevertheless, the majority of the merchants that founded the commercial houses of the Occident were servitors of the Semitic Baals, and those who invoked Mithra were generally Asiatics in humbler conditions of life. The first temples which this god possessed in the west of the empire were without doubt mainly frequented by slaves. The niangoncs, or slave- mongers, procured their human merchandise preferably from the provinces of the Orient. From the depths of Asia Minor they drove to Rome hordes of slaves purchased from the great landed proprietors of Cappadocia and of Pontus; and this imported population, as one ancient writer has put it, ultimately came to form distinct towns or quarters in the great capital. But the supply did not suffice for the 64 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA increasing consumption of depopulated Italy. War also was a mighty purveyor of human chattels. When we remember that Titus, in a single campaign in Judaea (70 A.D.), reduced to slavery 90,000 Jews, our imagination be- comes appalled at the multitudes of captives that the incessant struggles with the Par- thians, and particularly the conquests of Tra- jan, must have thrown on the markets of the Occident. But whether taken eii masse after some great victory, or acquired singly by the profes- sional traffickers in human flesh, these slaves were particularly numerous in the maritime towns, to which their transportation was cheap and easy. They introduced here, concurrently with the Syrian merchants, the Oriental cults and particularly that of Mithra. This last- named god has been found established in an entire series of ports on the Mediterranean. We signalize above all his presence at Sidon in Phoenicia and at Alexandria in Egypt. In Italy, if Pozzuoli and its environs, including Naples, have furnished relatively few monu- ments of the Mysteries, the reason is that this city had ceased in the second century to be the great entrepot from which Rome derived its supplies from the Levant. The Tyrian colony of Pozzuoli, at one time wealthy and powerful, complains in the year 172 A.D. of being reduced to a small settlement. After the immense structures of Claudius and Tra- MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 65 jan were erected at Ostia, this latter city inherited the prosperity of its Campanian rival; and the result was that all the Asiatic D G- 1 E 1 1 — 1 K-/'^ M - F 0 9. r- P " ^ _- U4 z -> < 6 0 -o H on 0- > > P^ H 0 ^ < ^ 1 > f B 0 H m " 0 B K C hnil, 0 bo n ■^ « in !-. w ■j;3 .8 oa H 0) W ■4-J c 0 0 d ^ tn K c3 'rt 0 d H C/2 N 0 .1i fc m S W t/5 Q (D H 1 rt < a; b a) S< 0 0 4-1 t/i d - < (1 rt OJ 0 72 a a! cr. b^ a -4-> U ^ -i-> <-> 0 .« Q 03 be rn > 0 u ^ *~^ 6 ^ be u '0 in (1) 0) • m a 0 0 S S 5^ P rt 'O -ol 021 1:3 (0 bo C 2 > M 0 S-i lA OJ -a 0) 3 ■4-' "St ffi 0 S H CD W ^ .&^ S U u < in a ri 0 ^^ tin • 1 0) "«i 0 P-l « •^ ir-' W 0 id ^;S ^ Z h-1 c < 0 s CL, 66 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA religions soon had here their chapels and their congregations of devotees. Yet none enjoyed Fig. 17. SILVANUS. Mosaic in a niche of the vestibule of the mith- raeum of Fig. 16, in Ostia, near the Baths of Antoninus. Silvanus holds in one hand a fir branch, in the other a hatchet. See the Chapter on "The Doctrine of the Mithraic Mysteries." MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 6/ greater favor than that of the Iranian god. In the second century, at least four or five spelcBa had been dedicated to him. One of them^ constructed at the latest in 162 A.D., and communicating with the baths of Anto- ninus, was situated on the very spot where the foreign ships landed (Fig. 16), and another one adjoined the ii/chvou, or sanctuary in which the official cult of the Magna jMatcj^ was cele- brated. To the south the little hamlet of An- tium (Porto d' Anzio) had followed the example of its powerful neighbor; while in Etruria, Rusellae (Grosseto) and Pisee likewise accorded a favorable reception to the Mazdean deity. In the east of Italy, Aquileia is distinguished for the number of its Mithraic inscriptions. As Trieste to-day, so Aquileia in antiquity was the market in which the Danubian provinces exchanged their products for those of the South. Pola, at the extremity of Istria, the islands of Arba and Brattia, and the sea-ports of the coast of Dalmatia, Senia, lader, Salonse, Narona, Epidaurus, including Dyrrachium in Macedonia, have all preserved more or less numerous and indubitable vestiges of the in- fluence of the invincible god, and distinctly mark the path which he followed in his journey to the commercial metropolis of the Adriatic. (See PVontispiece.) His progress may also be followed in the western Mediterranean. In Sicily at Syracuse and Palermo, on the coast of Africa at Car- 68 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA thage, Rusicada, Icosium, Caesarea, on the opposite shores of Spain at Malaga and Tar- CCAE/i/LIVS ERMFROSANT ISTESHVIVS LO CI F ECITSVa p F r A ?fS^ CCAE\il3LlVS ERMEROSANT ISTESHVIVSLO C I FECIT SVa PEC Fig. iS. STATUES OF TORCH-BEARERS (dADOPHORI) From the same mithrseum at Ostia, now in the Lateran. See the Chapter on "The Doctrine of the Mithraic Mysteries." MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 69 raco, Mithraic associations were successively formed in the motley population which the sea had carried to these cities. And farther to the north, on the Gulf of Lyons, the proud Roman colony of Narbonne doffed its exclu- siveness in his favor. In Gaul, especially, the correlation which we have discovered between the spread of the Mysteries and the extension of Oriental traffic is striking. Both were principally concen- trated between the Alps and the Cevennes, or to be more precise, in the basin of the Rhone, the course of which had been the main route of its penetration. Sextantio, near Montpel- lier, has given us the epitaph of a pater sacro- rtun, and Aix in the Provence a presumably Mithraic representation of the sun on his qnadriga. Then, ascending the river, we find at Aries a statue of the leontocephalous Kronos who was worshipped in the Mysteries; at Bourg-Saint-Andeol, near Montelimar, a representation of the tauroctonous god sculp- tured from the living rock near a spring; at Vaison, not far from Orange, a dedicatory inscription made on the occasion of an initia- tion; at Vienne, a spelcBum from which, among other monuments, has been obtained the most unique bas-relief of the lion-headed god hitherto discovered. Finally, at Lyons, which is known from the history of Christianity to have had direct relations with Asia Minor, the success of the Persian religion was cer- 70 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA talnly considerable. F'arther up the river, its presence has been proved at Geneva on the one hand and at Besan9on and Mandeure on the Doubs, a branch of the Saone, on the other. An unbroken series of sanctuaries which were without doubt in constant com- munication witli one another thus bound together the shores of the great inland sea and the camps of Germany. Sallying forth from the flourishing cities of the valley of the Rhone, the foreign cult crept even into the depths of the mountains of Dauphiny, Savoy, and Bugey. Labatie near Gap, Lucey not far from Belley, and Vieu-en- Val Romey have preserved for us inscriptions, temples, and statues dedicated by the faithful. As we have said, the Oriental merchants did not restrict their activity to establishing agen- cies in the maritime and river ports; the pros- pect of more lucrative trade attracted them to the villages of the interior, where competition was less active. The dispersion of the Asiatic slaves was even more complete. Scarcely had they disembarked from their ships, when they were scattered haphazard in every direction by the auctioneers, and we find them in all the different countries discharging the most diverse functions. In Italy, a country of great estates and ancient municipalities, either they went to swell the armies of slaves who were tilling the vast domains of tlic Roman aristocracy, or MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 7I they were afterwards promoted to the rank of superintendents {actor, villiciis) and became the masters of those whose miserable lot they had formerly shared. Sometimes they were acquired by some municipality, and as public servants [scrvi publici) they carried out the orders of the magistrates or entered the bu- reaus of the administrations. It is difficult to realize the rapidity with which the Oriental religions were in this way able to penetrate to regions which it would appear they could never possibly have attained. A double in- scription at Nersa2, in the heart of the Apen- nines, informs us that in the year 172 of our era a slave, the treasurer of the town, had restored a mithraeum that had fallen into ruins. At Venusia, a Greek inscription 'HXiw MtOpa was dedicated by the steward of some wealthy burgher, and his name Sagaris at once proves his servile rank and Asiatic origin. The examples could be multiplied. There is not a shadow of a doubt that these obscure servitors of the foreign god were the most active agents in the propagation of the Mysteries, not only within the limits of the city of Rome itself, and in the other great cities of the country, but throughout the entire extent of Italy, from Calabria to the Alps. We find the Iranian cult practised at Grumentum, in the heart of Lucania; then, as we have already said, at Venusia in Apulia, and at Nersse in the country of the /Equi, also at Aveia in the land of the 72 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA VestinI; then in Umbria, along the Flaminian road, at Interamna, at Spoletuni, where one can visit a spehviini decorated with paintings, and at Sentinum, where there has been dis- covered a list of the patrons of a collcgmui of Mithraists; likewise, in Etruria this religion followed the Cassian way and established itself at Sutriiim, at Bolsena, and perhaps at Arretium and at Florence. Its traces are no less well marked and significant to the north of the Apennines. They appear only spo- radically in Emilia, where the provinces of Bologna and Modena alone have preserved some interesting debris, as they do also in the fertile valley of the Po. Here Milan, which rapidly grew to prosperity under the empire, appears to be the only locality in which the exotic religion enjoyed great favor and official protection. Some fragments of inscriptions exhumed at Tortona, Industria, and Novara are insufficient to prove that it attained in the remainder of the country any wide-spread diffusion. It is certainly remarkable that we have un- earthed far richer booty in the wild defiles of the Alps than in the opulent plains of upper Italy. At Introbbio, in the Yal Sassina, to the east of Lake Como, in the Yal Cam- onica, watered by the river Oglio, altars were dedicated to the invincible god. But the monuments which were consecrated to him es- pecially abound along the river Adigc (Etsch) MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 73 and its tributaries, near the grand causeway which led in antiquity as it does to-day over the Brenner pass and Puster-Thal to the northern slope of the Alps into Rhaetia and Noricum. At Trent, there is a mithrseum built near a cascade; near San-Zeno, bas-reliefs have been found in the rocky gorges; at Cas- tello di Tuenno, fragments of votive tablets carved on both faces have been unearthed; on the banks of the Eisack, there has been found a dedicatory inscription to Mithra and to the Sun; and Mauls finally has given us the celebrated sculptured plaque discovered in the sixteenth century and now in the museum at Vienna. The progress of Mithraism in this moun- tainous district was not checked at the fron- tiers of Italy. If, pursuing our way through the valley of the Drave, we seek for the ves- tiges which it left in this region, we shall immediately discover them at Teurnia and especially at Virunum, the largest city of Noricum, in which in the third century two temples at least had been opened to the ini- tiated. A third one was erected not far from the same place in a grotto in the midst of the forest. The city of Aquileia* was undoubtedly the religious metropolis of this Roman colony, and its important church founded many mis- sions in the surrounding region. The cities *Cf. supra, p. 67. See also Frontispiece. 74 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA that sprang up along the routes leading from this port across Pannonia to the military strongholds on the Danube almost without exception favorably received the foreign god: they were /Emona, the Latobici, Nevio- dunum, and principally Siscia, on the course of the Save; and then toward the north Adrans, Celeia, Poetovio, received him with equal favor. In this manner, his devotees who were journeying from the shores of the Adriatic to Mcesia, on the one hand, or to Carnuntum on the other, could be received at every stage of their journey by co-religionists. In these regions, as in the countries south of the Alps, Oriental slaves acted as the mis- sionaries of Mithra. But the conditions under which their propaganda was conducted were considerably different. These slaves were not employed in this country, as they were in the latifiindia and the cities of Italy, as agricultural laborers, or stewards of wealthy land-owners, or municipal employees. Depopulation had not created such havoc here as in the coun- tries of the old civilization, and people were not obliged to employ foreign hands for the cultivation of their fields or the adminis- tration of their cities. It was not individuals or municipalities, but the state itself, that was here the great iniporter of human beings. The procurators, the officers of the treasury, the officers of the imperial domains, or as in Noricum the governors themselves, had under MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 75 their orders a multitude of collectors of taxes, of treasurers, and clerks of all kinds, scattered over the territory which they administered; and as a rule these subaltern officers were not of free birth. Likewise, the great entre- preneurs who leased the products of the mines and quarries, or the customs returns, employed for the execution of their projects a numerous staff of functionaries, both hired and slave. From people of this class, who were either agents of the emperor or publicans whom he appointed to represent him, are those whose titles recur most frequently in the Mithraic in- scriptions of southern Pannonia and Norlcum. In all the provinces, the lowly employees of the imperial service played a considerable "part in the diffusion of foreign religions. Just '^s these officers of the central power were representatives of the political unity of the empire in contrast with its regional particular- ism, so also they were the apostles of the universal religions as opposed to the local cults. They formed, as it were, a second army under the orders of their prince, and their influence on the evolution of paganism was analogous to that of the army proper. Like the soldiers, they too were recruited in great numbers from the Asiatic countries; like them, they too were perpetually changing their residence as they were promoted in station; and the lists of their bureaus, like those of the legions, com- prised individuals of all nationalities. 76 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA Thus, the imperial administration trans- ferred from one government to another, along with its clerks and quartermasters, a knowledge of the Mithraic Mysteries. In a characteristic discovery made at Caisarea in Cappadocia, a slave, probably of indigenous origin, an arcarius dispciisatoris Augiisti (a clerk of the imperial treasury), dedicates in very good Latin an image of the Sun to Mithra, In the interior of Dalmatia, where the monuments of the Persian god are rather sparsely scattered for the reason that this province was early stripped of its legions, employees of the treasury, the postal and the customs service, left nevertheless their names on some inscriptions. In the frontier prov- inces especially, the financial agents of the Caesars must have been numerous, not only because the import duties on merchandise had to be collected here, but because the heaviest drain on the imperial treasuries was the cost of maintaining the army. It is therefore nat- ural to find cashiers, tax-gatherers, and reve- nue-collectors {dispcnsatorcs, cxactoirs, procura- tor es) , 2.nd o\.h.e.r similar titles mentioned in the Mithraic texts of Dacia and Africa. Here, therefore, is the second way in which the Iranian god penetrated to the towns adjoining the military camps, where, as we have seen, he was worshipped by the Oriental soldiers. The general domestic service, as well as the political functions, of these admin- MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 7/ Jstrators and officers, was the cause of the transportation of pubHc and private slaves to all garrisons; while the constantly renewed needs of the multitudes here assembled attracted to these points merchants and traders from all parts of the world. Then again, as we have pointed out, the veterans themselves afterwards settled in the ports and the large cities, where they were thrown in contact with merchants and slaves. In affirm- ing categorically that Mithra was introduced in this or that manner in a certain region, our generalization manifestly cannot lay claim to absolute exactitude. The concurrent causes of the spread of the Mysteries are so inter- mingled and intertwined, that it would be a futile task to attempt to unravel strand by strand the fibers of this entangled snarl. Hav- ing as our sole guide, as we frequently do, inscriptions of uncertain date, on which by the side of the name of the god appears simply that of an initiate or priest, it is impossible to determine in each single case the circum- stances which have fostered the progress of the new religion. The more fleeting influences are almost absolutely removed from our ken. On the accession of Vespasian (69 A.D.), did the prolonged sojourn in Italy of Syrian troops, who were faithful worshippers of the Sun, have any lasting results? Did the army which Alexander Severus (222-235 A.D.) conducted into Germany, and which, as Lampridius has 78 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA recorded,* was potentissima per Armenios et Osrhoeiios ct PartJws (viz., very largely com- posed of Armenians, Osrhoenians, and Parthi- ans), impart a new impulse to the Mithraic propaganda on the banks of the Rhine ? Did any of the high functionaries that Rome sent annually to the frontier of the Euphrates embrace the beliefs of the people over whom they ruled ? Did priests from Cappadocia or Pontus ever embark for the Occident after the manner of the missionaries of the Syrian goddess, in the expectation of wresting there a livelihood from the credulity of the masses? Even under the republic Chaldaian astrolo- gers roamed the great causeways of Italy, and in the time of Juvenal the soothsayers of Com- magene and Armenia vended their oracles in Rome. These subsidiary methods of propa- gation, which were generally resorted to by the Oriental religions, may also have been put to profitable use by the disseminators of Mith- raism; but the most active agents of its diffu- sion were undoubtedly the soldiers, the slaves, and the merchants. Apart from the detailed proofs already adduced, the presence of Mithraic monuments in places where war and commerce were constantly conducted, and in the countries where the vast current of Asiatic emigration was discharged, is sufficient to establish our hypothesis. The absence of these monuments in other ♦Lamprid., Alex. Sev., c. 6i ; cf. Capitol., Maxiinin., c. ii. MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 79 regions is also clear proof of our position. Why are no vestiges of the Persian Mysteries found in Asia Propria, in Bithynia, in Galatia, in the provinces adjoining those where they were practised for centuries ? Because the production of these countries exceeded their consumption, because their foreign commerce was in the hands of Greek ship-owners, because they exported men instead of importing them, and because from the time of Vespasian at least no legion was charged with the defence or surveillance of their territory. Greece was protected from the invasion of foreign gods by its national pride, by its worship of its glorious past, which is the most characteristic trait of the Grecian spirit under thee mpire. But the absence of foreign soldiers and slaves also deprived it of the least occasion of lapsing from its national religion. Lastly, Mithraic monuments are almost completely missing in the central and western parts of Gaul, in the Spanish peninsula, and in the south of Britain, and they are rare even in the interior of Dal- matia. In these places also no permanent army was stationed; there was consequently no importation of Asiatics; while there was also in these countries no great center of international commerce to attract them. On the other hand, the city of Rome is espe- cially rich in discoveries of all kinds, more so in fact than any of the provinces. In fact Mithra found in no other part of the empire 80 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA conditions so eminently favorable to the suc- cess of his religion. Rome always had a large garrison made up of soldiers drawn from all parts of the empire, and the veterans of the army, after having been honorably discharged, flocked thither in great numbers to spend the remainder of their days. An opulent aristoc- racy resided here, and their palaces, like those of the emperor, were filled with thousands of Oriental slaves. It was the seat of the central imperial administration, the official slaves of which thronged its bureaus. Finally, all whom the spirit of adventure, or disaster, had driven hither in search of fame and fortune flocked to this "caravansary of the universe," and car- ried thither their customs and their religions. Collaterally, the presence in Rome of num- bers of Asiatic princelings, who lived there, either as hostages or fugitives, with their fam- ilies and retinues, also abetted the propagation of the Mazdean faith. Like the majority of the foreign gods, Mithra undoubtedly had his first temples outside of the pomoermm, or religious limits. Many of his monuments have been discovered beyond these boundaries, especially in the vicinity of the praetorian camp; but before the year i8i A.D. he had overleaped the sacred barriers and established himself in the heart of the city. It is unfortunately impossible to follow step by step his progress in the vast metrop- olis. Records of exact date and indubitable MITHRAISM IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE 8l origin are too scarce to justify us in recon- structing the local history of the Persian relig- ion in Rome. We can only determine in a general way the high degree of splendor which it attained there. Its vogue is attested by a hundred or more inscriptions, by more than seventy-five fragments of sculpture, and by a series of temples and chapels situated in all parts of the city and its environs. The most justly celebrated of these spelcra is the one that still existed during the Renaissance in a cave of the Capitol, and from which the grand Borghesi bas-relief now in the Louvre was taken. (See Fig. 4.) To all appearances, this monument dates from the end of the sec- ond century. It was at this period that Mithra emerged from the partial obscurity in which he had hitherto lived, to become one of the favorite gods of the Roman aristocracy and the impe- rial court. We have seen him arrive from the Orient a despised deity of the deported or emigrant Asiatics. It is certain that he achieved his first conquests among the lower ' classes of society, and it is an important fact ? that Mithraism long remained the religion of I the lowly. The most ancient inscriptions are eloquent evidence of the truth of this asser- tion, for they emanated without exception from sl_aves or freedrnen. frorn soldiers active, or retired. But the high destinies to which Treedmen were permitted to aspire under the 82 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA empire are well known; while the sons of vet- erans or of centurions not infrequently became citizens of wealth and influence. Thus, by a natural evolution the religion transplanted to Latin soil was bound to wax great in wealth as well as in influence, and soon to count among its sectaries influential functionaries at the capital, and church and town dignitaries in the municipalities. Under the Antonines 138-180 A.D.), literary men and philosophers began to grow interested in the dogmas and rites of this Oriental cult. The wit Lucian parodied their ceremonies*; and in 177 A.D. Celsus in his True Discourse undoubtedly pits its doctrines against those of Christianity.f At about the same period a certain Pallas devoted to Mithraism a special work, and Por- phyry cites a certain Eubulus who had pub- lished Mithraic RcscarcJiesX in several books. If this literature were not irrevocably lost to us, we should doubtless re-read in its pages the story of entire Roman squadrons, both officers and soldiers, passing over to the faith of the hereditary enemies of the empire, and of great lords converted by the slaves of their own establishments. The monuments fre- quently mention the names of slaves beside *Lucian, Menipp., c. 6 ct seq. Cf. Deo?-, concil., c. g; Jnp. irag.,c. 8. 13 {T. et M., Vol. II, p. 22). fOrigen, Contra. Ci'/s., l. 9 {T. ei M., Vol. IT, p. 30). XPorphyr., De ant?-, nymph., c. 5 ; Dc abstin., II. 56, IV. 16 {cf. T. et A/., Vol. II, p. 39 ys.j Fig. 25. GRAND MITHRAIC BAS-RELIEF OF HEDDERNHEIM, GERMANY. In the center Mithra with the two torch-bearers; immediately above, the signs of the Zodiac ; immedi- ately above these, Mithra aiming his arrow at the rock (page 138); below the bull a group composed of the lion, the cup, and the servant. For the obverse of this bas-relief, see supra, p. 54. {T. ei AT., p. 364.) nally, a still more remarkable phenomenon takes place. The appearance of the quartette Il8 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA is transformed. The steeds interchange na- tures in such wise that the substance of all passes over to the most robust and ardent of the group, just as if a sculptor, after having modelled figures in wax, had borrowed the attributes of one to complete the others, and had ended by merging all into a single form. Then, the conquering steed in this divine struggle, having become by his triumph om- nipotent, is identified with the charioteer him- self. The first horse is the incarnation of fire or ether, the second of air, the third of water, and the fourth of the earth. The accidents which befall the last-mentioned horse, the earth, represent the conflagrations and inun- dations which have desolated and will in the future desolate our world; and the victory of the first horse is the symbolic image of the final conflict that shall destroy the existing order of all things. The cosmic quadriga, which draws the su- prasensible Cause, has not been figured in the sacred iconography. The latter reserved for a visible god this emblematic group. The votaries of Mithra, like the ancient Persians, adored the Sun that traversed each day in its chariot the spaces of the firmament and sank at dusk extinguishing its fires in the ocean. When it appeared again on the horizon, its brilliant light scattered in flight the spirits of darkness, and it purified all creation, to which its radiance restored life. A like worship was DOCTRINE OF THE MITHRAIC MYSTERIES 1 19 accorded to the Moon, which voyaged in the spheres above on a cart drawn by white bulls. The animal of reproduction and of agriculture had been assigned to the goddess that pre- sided over the increase of plants and the generation of living creatures. The elements, accordingly, were not the only natural bodies that were deified in the Mysteries. The two luminaries that fecun- dated nature were worshipped here the same as in primitive Mazdaism, but the conceptions which the Aryas formed of them have been profoundly transformed by the influences of Chald?can theories. As we have already said,* the ancient belief of the Persians had been forcibly subjected in Babylon to the influence of a theology which was based on the science of its day, and the majority of the gods of Iran had been likened to the stars worshipped in the valley of the Euphrates. They acquired thus a new char- acter entirely different from their original one, and the name of the same deity thus assumed and preserved in the Occident a double mean- Tng. The Magi were unsuccessful in harmon- izing these new doctrines with their ancient religion, for the Semitic astrology was as irreconcilable with the naturalism of Iran as it was with the paganism of Greece. But look- ing upon these contradictions as simple differ- ences of degree in the perception of one and *See supra, page 10. 120 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA the same truth, the clergy reserved for the dite exclusively the revelation of the original Mazdean doctrines concerning the origin and destiny of man and the world, whilst the mul- titude were forced to remain content with the brilliant and superficial symbolism inspired by the speculations of the Chaldaians. The astro- nomical allegories concealed from the curiosity of the vulgar the real scope of the hieratic rep- resentations, and the promise of complete illu- mination, long withheld, fed the ardor of faith with the fascinating allurements of mystery. The most potent of these sidereal deities, those which were most often invoked and for which were reserved the richest offerings, were the Planets. Conformably to astrological the- ories, the planets were endowed with virtues and qualities for which it is frequently difficult for us to discover adequate reasons. Each of the planetary bodies presided over a day of the week, to each some one metal was conse- crated, each was associated with some one de- gree in the initiation, and their number has caused a special religious potency to be attrib- uted to the number seven. In descending from the empyrean to the earth, the souls, it was thought, successively received from them their passions and qualities. These planetary bodies were frequently represented on the monuments, now by symbols recalling the elements of which they were formed or the sacrifices which were offered to them, and now DOCTRINE OF THE MITHRAIC MYSTERIES 121 under the aspect of the immortal gods throned on the Greek Olympus: Helios, Selene, Ares, Hermes, Zeus, Aphrodite, Kronos. But these images have here an entirely different signifi- cation from what they possess when they stand for Ahura-Mazda, Zervan, or the other gods of Mazdaism. Then the personifications of the Heavens or of Infinite Time are not seen in them, but only the luminous stars whose wan- dering course can be followed amid the con- stellations. This double system of interpreta- tion was particularly applied to thQ_ Sun, conceived now as identical with Mithra and now as distinct from him. In reality there were two solar divinities in the Mysteries, one Iranian and the heir of the Persian Hvare, the other Semitic, the substitute of the Baby- lonian Shamash, identified with Mithra. By the side of the planetary gods who have still a double character, purely sidereal divini- ties received their tribute of homage. The "twelve signs of the Zodiac, which in their daily revolution subject creatures to their adverse influences, were represented in all of the mithrgeums under their traditional aspect (Fig. 26). Each of them was without doubt the object of particular veneration during the month over which it presided, and they were customarily grouped by threes according to the Seasons to which they conformed and with the worship of which theirs was associated. (See also Fig. 49.) 122 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA But the signs of the Zodiac were not the only constellations that were incorporated by the priests in their theology. The astronom- ical method of interpretation, having been Fig. 26. MARBLE BAS-RELIEF FOUND IN LONDON. In the center the tauroctonous Mithra with the torch-bearers surrounded by the twelve signs of the Zodiac. In the lower corners busts of the Winds ; in the upper corners the Sun on his quadriga and the Moon on a chariot drawn by bulls. The inscription reads: Ulpius Silvaniis emeritus leg{tonis) II At(g{ttstae) votum solvit. Facttis Arausione (that is, honorably discharged at Orange). ( T. et 71/., p. 389.) once adopted in the Mysteries, was freely extended and made to embrace all possible figures. There was scarcely any object or animal that was not in some way conceived as DOCTRINE OF THE MITHRAIC MYSTERIES 123 the symbolic image of a stellar group. Thus the raven, the cup, the dog, and the lion, that ordinarily accompany the group of the tauroc- tonous Mithra, were readily identified with the constellations of the same name. The two celestial hemispheres that alternately pass above and below the earth were personified and likened to the Dioscuri, who, according to Fig. 27. MITHRAIC CAMEO. After Chiflet, reproduced from C. W. King. the Hellenic fable, lived and died by turns. Mythology and erudition were everywhere mingled. The hymns described a hero like the Greek Atlas who bore on his untiring shoulders the globe of Heaven, and who is regarded as the inventor of astronomy. But these demi-gods were relegated to the back- ground; the planets and the signs of the Zodiac never ceased to preserve their incon- testable primacy, for it was they above all others, according to the astrologers, that con- 124 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA trolled the existence of men and guided the course of things. This was the capital doctrine that Babylon introduced into Mazdaism: belief in Fatality^ o 5 o w < u u < H g -^ ^ <^ ^ a -^ c; S -<-' o ^ 0) Si las o c >^ o O <" ^ g Pi *^ «r • a -o o ^ t/5 g s ^ to 0 to 0 3 W i a ffi 1 0 S J^K bJDi 5 -^ ^ '^ o p ^ bo n o 134 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA ingenious fable carries us back to the very be- ginnings of civilization. It could never have risen save among a people of shepherds and Fig- 33- THE TAUROCTONOUS (bULL-SLAYING) MITHRA AND THE TAUROPHOROUS (bULL-BEARING) MITHRA; BETWEEN THEM THE DOG. Clay cup found at Lanuvium. ( T. ft J/., Fig. 80, p. 247.) hunters with whom cattle, the source of all wealth, had become an object of religious DOCTRINE OF THE MITHRAIC MYSTERIES I35 veneration. In the eyes of such a people, the capture of a wild bull was an achievement so highly fraught with honor as to be apparently no derogation even for a god. The redoubtable bull was grazing in a pas- ture on the mountain-side; the hero, resorting to a bold stratagem, seized it by the horns and succeeded in mounting it. The infuriated quadruped, breaking into a gallop, struggled in vain to free itself from its rider; the latter, although unseated by the bull's mad rush, never for a moment relaxed his hold; he suffered himself to be dragged along, sus- pended from the horns of the animal, which, finally exhausted by its efforts, was forced to surrender. Its conqueror then seizing it by its hind hoofs, dragged it backwards over a road strewn with obstacles (Fig. 33) into the cave which served as his home. This painful Journey {Transit us) of Mithra became the synjLbol_oLiiut»afi'-&t^fferings. But the bull, it would appear, succeeded in making its escape from its prison, and roamed again at large over the mountain pastures. The Sun then sent the raven, his messenger, to carry to his ally the command to slay the fugitive. Mithra received this cruel mission much against his will, but submitting to the decree of Heaven he pursued the truant beast with his agile dog, succeeded in overtaking it just at the moment when it was taking refuge in the cave which it had quitted, and seizing it 136 THE MYSTERIES OF MlTHRA by the nostrils with one hand, with the other he plunged deep into its flank his hunting- knife. Then came an extraordinary prodigy to pass. Fig. 34- TWO BRONZE PLAQUES (vATICAN). The one to the left has the head of Jupiter (Sil- vanus?). The right hand holds a pine-cone, the left a branch entwined by a serpent. On the right shoulder is an eagle, and the breast is decorated with Mithraic figures in relief: the tauroctonous Mithra, a cup, the head of a ram, and a five-rayed disc. The right-hand bust is that of a bearded Oriental with Phrygian cap, holding in the right hand a pine-cone and in the left a torch entwined by a serpent — a crude piece of work and probably of Asiatic origin. {T. ct AT., Figs. 97 and 98, p. 260.) From the body of the moribund victim sprang all the useful herbs and plants that cover the earth with their verdure. From the spinal cord of the animal sprang the wheat that gives DOCTRINE OF THE MITHRAIC MYSTERIES I37 US our bread, and from its blood the vine that produces the sacred drink of the Mysteries. In vain did the Evil Spirit launch forth his 1 unclean demons against the anguish-wrung animal, in order to poison in it the very sources of life; the scorpion, the ant, the serpent, strove in vain to consume the genital parts and to drink the blood of the prolific quad- ruped; but they were powerless to impede the miracle that was enacting. The seed of the bull, gathered and purified by the Moon, pro- duced all the different species of useful ani- mals, and its soul, under the protection of the dog, the faithful companion of Mithra, as- cended into the celestial spheres above, where, receiving the honors of divinity, it became under the name of Silvanus the guardian of herds. Thus, through the sacrifice which he had so resignedly undertaken, the taurocto- nous hero became the creator of all the benefi- cent beings on earth; and, from the death which he had caused, was born a new life, more rich and more fecund than the old. Meanwhile, the first human couple had been called into existence, and Mithra was charged with keeping a watchful eye over this priv- ileged race. It was in vain the Spirit of Dark- ness invoked his pestilential scourges to des- troy it; the god always knew how to balk his mortiferous designs. Ahriman first desolated the land by causing a protracted drought, and its inhabitants, tortured by thirst, implored the 138 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA aid of his ever-victorious adversar}^ The di- vine archer discharged his arrows against a precipitous rock, and there gushed forth from it a spring of Hving water to which the sup- pHants thronged to cool their parched palates.* But a still more terrible cataclysm followed, which menaced all nature. A universal del- uge depopulated the earth, which was over- whelmed by the waters of the rivers and the seas. One man alone, secretly advised by the gods, had constructed a boat and had saved himself, together with his cattle, in an ark which floated on the broad expanse of waters. Then a great conflagration ravaged the world and consumed utterly both the habitations of men and of beasts. But the creatures of Ormazd also ultimately escaped this new peril, thanks to celestial protection, and hencefor- ward the human race was permitted to wax great and multiply in peace. The heroic period of history was now closed, and the terrestrial mission of Mithra accom- plished. In a Last Supper, which the initiated commemorated by mystical love feasts, he celebrated with Helios and the other compan- ions of his labors the termination of their com- mon struggles. Then the gods ascended to the Heavens. Borne by the Sun on his radiant quadriga, Mithra crossed the Ocean, which sought in vain to engulf him (Fig. 35), and took up his habitation with the rest of the im- *See supra, p. 117, Fig. 25, and infra, p. 196, Fig. 45. DOCTRINE OF THE MITHRAIC MYSTERIES 139 ***■- 'Tn fi --~-=g^»«-i*i Fig- 35- BAS-RELIEF OF APULUM, DACIA. In the center, the tauroctonous Mithra with the two torch-bearers ; to the left, Mithra mounted on the bull, and Mithra taurophorous; to the right, a lion stretched lengthwise above a cup (symbols of fire and water). Upper border: Bust of Luna; new-born Mithra reclining near the banks of a stream ; shepherd standing, with lambs; bull in a hut and bull in a boat; underneath, the seven altars; Mithra drawing a bow; bust of the Sun. Lower border: Banquet of Mithra and the Sun ; Mithra mounting the quadriga of the Sun; the Ocean surrounded by a serpent. (7! et Jf., p. 309.) V 140 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA mortals. But from the heights of Heaven he never ceased to protect the faithful ones that piously served him. This mythical recital of the origin of the world enables us to understand the importance which the tauroctonous god enjoyed in his religion, and to comprehend better what the pagan theologians endeavored to express by the title "mediator." Mithra is the creator to whom Jupiter-Ormazd committed the task of establishing and of maintaining order in na- ture. He is, to speak in the philosophical lan- guage oitlie tirne£~the Logos that emanated from God and shared His omnipotence; who, after having fashioned the world as demiurge, continued to watch faithfully over it. The primal defeat of Ahriman had not reduced him to absolute impotence; the struggle between the good and the evil was still conducted on earth between the emissaries of the sovereign of Olympus and those of the Prince of Dark- ness; it raged in the celestial spheres in the opposition of propitious and adverse stars, and it reverberated in the hearts of men, — the epit- omes of the universe. Life is a battle, and to issue forth from it victorious the law must be faithfully fulfilled that the divinity himself revealed to the an- cient Magi. What were the obligations that Mithraism imposed upon its followers? What were those "commandments" to which its adepts had to bow in order to be rewarded in DOCTRINE OF THE MITHRAIC MYSTERIES I4I the world to come ? Our incertitude on these points is extreme, for we have not the shadow of a right to identify the precepts revealed in the Mysteries with those formulated in the Avesta. Nevertheless, it would appear certain that the ethics of the Magi of the Occident had made no concession to the license of the Babylonian cults and that it had still preserved the lofty character of the ethics of the ancient Persians. Perfect purity had remained for them the cult toward which the life of the faithful should tend. Their ritual required repeated lustrations and ablutions, which were believed to wash away the stains of the soul. This catharsis or purification both conformed to the Mazdean traditions and was in harmony with the general tendencies of the age. Yield- ing to thes_e tendencies, the Mithraists car- ried their principles even to excess, and their jdeals of perfection verged on asceticism. Ab- stinence from certain foods and absolute con- tinence were regarded as praiseworthy. Resistance to sensuality was one of the as- pects of the combat with the principle of evil. To support untiringly this combat with the followers of Ahriman, who, under multiple forms, disputed with the gods the empire of the world, was the duty of the servitors of Mithra. Their dualistic system was partic- ularly adapted to fostering individual effort and to developing human energy. They did not lose themselves, as did the other sects, in 142 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA contemplative mysticism; for them, the good dwelt in action. They rated strength higher than gentleness, and preferred courage to lenity. From their long association with bar- baric religions, there was perhaps a residue of DEO PROSALAA\PL!An AVG-N-DISP-BT SVA-SVORVMd PtlOTAS-VLhAR EIVS Fig. 36. votive inscription to mithra nabarze (victorious). Found at Sarmizegetusa. (7^ et A/., p. 2S1.) cruelty in their ethics. Aj^eligion of^soldiers, Mithraism exalted the military virtues above all others. In the war which the zealous champion of piety carries on unceasingly with the malign DOCTRINE OF THE MITHRAIC MYSTERIES I43 demons, he is assisted by Mithra. Mithra^is the god of help, whom one never invokes in vain, an unfaiHno- haven, the anchor of salva; tion for mortals in all their trials, the dauntless champion who sustains his devotees in their frailty, through all the tribulations of life. As with the Persians, so here he is still the de- fender of truth and justice, the protector of holiness, and the intrepid antagonist of the powers of darkness. Eternally young and vigorous, he pursues them without mercy; "always awake, always alert," it is impossible to surprise him; and from his never-ceasing combats he always emerges the victor. This is the Idea that unceasingly occurs in the in- scriptions, the idea expressed by the Persian surname iVabarze (Fig. 36), by the Greek and Latin epithets of dviKrjTo^, invictiis, insiipe^'a- bilis. As the god of armies, Mithra caused his protdgds to triumph over their barbarous ad- versaries, and likewise in the moral realm he gave them victory over the instincts of evil, inspired by the Spirit of Falsehood, and he assured them salvation both in this world and in that to come. Like all the Oriental cults, the Persian Mys teries mingled with their cosmogonic fables and their theological speculations, ideas of deliverance and redemption. They believed in the_conscious survival after death of the divine essence that dwells within us, and in punishments and rewards beyond the tomb. 144 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA The souls, ot which an infinite muhitude peopled the habitations of the Most High, descended here below to animate the bodies of men, either because they were compelled by bitter necessity to fall into this material and corrupt world, or because they had dropped of their own accord upon the earth to undertake here the battle against the de- mons. When after death the genius of cor- ruption took possession of the body, and the soul quitted its human prison, the devas of darkness and the emissaries of Heaven dis- puted for its possession. A special decree decided whether it was worthy to ascend again into Paradise. If it was stained by an impure life, the emissaries of Ahriman dragged it down to the infernal depths, where they in- flicted upon it a thousand tortures; or perhaps, as a mark of its fall, it was condemned to take up its abode in the body of some unclean ani- mal. If, on the contrary, its merits outweighed its faults, it was borne aloft to the regions on high. - The heavens were divided into seven spheres, each of which was conjoined with a planet. A sort of ladder, composed of eight superposed gates, the first seven of which were constructed of different metals, was the symbolic sugges- tion in the temples, of the road to be followed to reach the supreme region of the fixed stars. To pass from one story to the next, each time the wayfarer had to enter a gate guarded by DOCTRINE OF THE MITHRAIC MYSTERIES I45 an angel of Ormazd. The initiates alone, to whom the appropriate formulas had been taught, knew how to appease these inexorable guardians. As the soul traversed these differ- ent zones, itTi3_itselt, as one "would of gar- ments, of the passions and faculties that it had received in its descent to tHe~eart1ir^Tt aban- doned to the Moon its vital and nutritive energy, to Mercury its desires, to Venus its "wicked appetites, to the bun its intellectilaT "capacities, to Mars its love ot war, to Jupiter ~its ambitious dreams, to Saturn its inclina- tions. It was naked, stripped of every vice and every sensibility, when it penetrated the eighth heaven to enjoy there, as an essence supreme, and in the eternal light that bathed the gods, beatitude without end.* _It was Mithra, the protector of truth, that presided over the judgment of the soul after its decease. It was he, the mediator, that served as a guide to his faithful ones in their courageous ascent to the empyrean; he was the celestial father that received them in his resplendent mansion, like children who had returned from a distant voyage. The happiness reserved for these quintes- sentialized monads in a spiritual world is rather difficult to conceive, and doubtless this doc- trine had but feeble attraction for vulgar ♦This Mithraic doctrine has recently been compared with other analogous beliefs and studied in detail by M. Bossuet. "Die Himmelreise der Seele" {Af'chiv fi'ir Religionsivissen- schaft. Vol. IV., 1901, p. 160 ff.). 146 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA minds. Another belief, which was added to the first by a sort of superfoetation, offered the prospect of more material enjoyment. The doctrine of the immortality of the soul was rounded off by the doctrine of the resurrection of the flesh. _The struggle between the principles of goocl and evil is not destined to continue into all eternity. When the age assigned for its dura- tion shall have rolled away, the scourges sent by Ahriman will compass the destruction of the world. A marvellous bull, analogous to the primitive bull, will then again appear on earth, and Mithra will redescend and reawaken men to life. All will sally forth from the "tombs, will assume their former appearance, and recognize one another. Humanity entire will unite in one grand assembly, and the god of truth will separate the good from the bad. Then in a supreme sacrifice he will immolate the divine bull; will mingle its fat with the consecrated wine, and will offer to the just this miraculous beverage which will endow them all with immortality. Then Jupiter-Ormazd, yielding to the prayers of the beatified ones, will cause to fall from the heavens a devour- ing fire which will annihilate all the wicked. The defeat of the Spirit of Darkness will be achieved, and in the general conflagration Ahriman and his impure demons will perish and the rejuvenated universe enjoy unto all eternity happiness without end. DOCTRINE OF THE MITHRAIC MYSTERIES I47 We who have never experienced the Mith- raic spirit of grace are apt to be disconcerted by the incoherence and absurdity of this body of doctrine, such as it has been shown forth in our reconstruction. A theology at once naive Jl^ and artificial here combines/ primitive myths j ' the naturalistic tendency ]of which is still trans- -'^/ \ . garent, with anfastrological systemjwhose log- ical structure only serves to render its radical Talsity all the more palpable. All the impos- sibilities of the ancient polytheistic fables here subsist side by side with philosophical specu- lations on the evolution of the universe and the destiny of man. The discordance between tradition and reflection is extremely marked here and it is augmented by the contrariety between the doctrine of fatalism and that of the efficacy of prayer and the need of worship. But this religion, like any other, must not be estimated by its metaphysical verity. It would in become us to-day to dissect the cold corpse of this faith in order to ascertain its inward organic vices. The important thing is to understand how Mithraism lived and grew great, and why it failed to win the empire of the world. Its success was in great part undoubtedly-;^ due to the vigor of its ethics, which above all tPitngs favored action. In an epoch of anarchy and emasculation, its mystics found in its pre- cepts both stimulus and support. The cojivic- tion that the faithful ones formed part of a 148 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA sacred army chargred with siisj^ajrnrKrwith the Principle of Good the struggle against the power of evil, was singularly adapted to pro- voking their most pious efforts and transform- ing them into ardent zealots. "" "" ^"^ _JN^ The Mysteries exerted another powerful in- ' fluence, also, in fostering some of the most exalted aspirations of the human soul: the desire for immortality and the expectation of final justice. The hopes of life beyond the tomb which this religion instilled in its vota- ries were one of the secrets of its power in these troublous times, when solicitude for the life to come disturbed all minds. But several other sects offered to their adepts just as consoling prospects of a future life. The special attraction of Mithraism dwelt, therefore, in other qualities of its doc- trinal system. Mithraism, in fact, satisfied alike both the intelligence of the educated and the hearts of the simple-minded. The apothe- osis of Time as First Cause and that of the Sun, its physical manifestation, which main- tained on earth heat and light, were highly philosophical conceptions. The worship ren- dered to the Planets and to the Constellations, the course of which determined terrestrial events, and to the four Elements, whose infi- nite combinations produced all natural phe- nomena, is ultimately reducible to the worship of the principles and agents recognized by ancient science, and the theology of the Mys- DOCTRINE OF THE MITHRAIC MYSTERIES I49 teries was, in this respect, nothing but the re- ligious expression of the physics and astronomy of the Roman world. 50>tAC€_'. This theoretical conformity of revealed dog- mas with the accepted ideas of science was calculated to allure cultivated minds, but it had no hold whatever upon the ignorant souls of Ittie populace. T^^se, on the other hand, were eminently amenable to the allurements of a doctrine that deified the whole of physical and tangible reality. The gods were everywhere, and they mingled in every act of life; the fire that cooked the food and warmed the bodies of the faithful, the water that allayed their thirst and cleansed their persons, the very air that they breathed, and the light that illumi- nated their paths, were the objects of their adoration. Perhaps no other religion ever offered to its sectaries in a higher degree than Mithraism opportunities for prayer and mo- tives for veneration. When the initiated be- took himself in the evening to the sacred grotto concealed in the solitude of the forests, at every step new sensations awakened in his heart some mystical emotion. The stars that shone in the sky, the wnnd that whispered in the foliage, the spring or brook that babbled down the mountain-side, even the earth that he trod under his feet, were in his eyes divine, and all surrounding nature provoked in him a worshipful fear for the infinite forces that swayed the universe. THE MITHRAIC LITURGY, CLERGY AND DEVOTEES IN ALL the religions of classical antiquity there is one feature which, while formerly very conspicuous and perhaps the most im- portant of all for the faithful, has to-day al- most totally disappeared. It is their liturgy. The Mysteries of Mithra form no exception to this unfortunate rule. The sacred books which contain the prayers recited or chanted during the services, the ritual of the initiations, and the ceremonials of the feasts, have vanished and left scarce a trace behind. A verse bor- rowed from one unknown hymn is almost all that has come down to us from the collections which anciently must have been so abundant. The old Gathas composed in honor of the Mazdean gods were translated into Greek during the Alexandrian epoch, and Greek re- mained for a long time the language of the Mithraic cult, even in the Occident. Barbaric words, incomprehensible to the profane, were interspersed throughout the sacred texts and augmented the veneration of the worshippers for the ancient formulary, as well as their con- fidence in its efficacy. Such were the epithets like Nabarze, "victorious," which has been ap- plied to Mithra, or the obscure invocations 150 THE MITHRAIC LITURGY 151 like Nanta, Nania Sebesio, engraved on our bas-reliefs, which have never yet been inter- Fig- 37. TAUROCTONOUS MITHRA. BAS-RELIEF OF WHITE MARBLE (bologna). Important for its accessory figures. In the center, the dog, serpent, scorpion, the two torch-bearers, and above the one to the left the raven. Near each torch-bearer is a pine-tree (?). On the upper border are the busts of the seven planets in the following order from the left: The Sun, Saturn, Venus, Jupiter, Hermes, Mars, and Luna. The lower border, three figures at a banquet; infant, or Eros(?); bearded figure reclining (Oceanus). ( T. et M., Fig. 99, p. 261.) preted. A scrupulous respect for the tradi- tional practices of their sect characterized the Magi of Asia Minor, and continued to be mani- 152 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA fested with unabated ardor among their Latin successors. On the downfall of paganism, the latter still took pride in worshipping the gods according to the ancient Persian rites which Zoroaster was said to have instituted. These rites sharply distinguished their religion from all the others that were practised at the same time in Rome, and prevented its Persian origin from ever being forgotten. If some piece of good fortune should one day unearth for us a Mitliraic missal, we should be able to study there these ancient usages and to participate in imagination in the cele- bration of the services. Deprived as we are of this indispensable guide, we are excluded utterly from the sanctuary and know the eso- teric discipline of the Mysteries only from a few indiscretions. A text of St. Jerome, con- firmed by a series of inscriptions, informs us that there were seven degrees of initiation and that the mystic (yxucrTr;?, sacraf?is) successively assumed the names of Raven {corax), Occult {cryphius), Soldier {uiilcs), Lion [Ico), Persian \Perses), Runner of the Sun {hcliodrou/us), and Father" (^(27^r). These strange appellations were not empty epithets with no practical bear- ing. On certain occasions the celebrants donned garbs suited to the title that had been accorded them. On the bas-reliefs we see them carrying the counterfeit heads of ani- mals, of soldiers, and of Persians. (See Fig. 38, p. 159) "Some flap their wings like birds, imi- THE MITHRAIC LITURGY 153 tating the cry of crows; others growl like lions," says a Christian writer of the fourth century;* "in such manner are they that are called wise basely travestied.'' These sacred masks, of which the ecclesias- tical writer exhibits the ridiculous side, were interpreted by pagan theologians as an allusion to the signs of the Zodiac, and even to the doc- trine of metempsychosis. Such divergences of interpretation simply prove that the real mean- ing of these animal disguises was no longer understood. They are in reality a survival of primitive practices which have left their traces in numerous cults. We find the titles of Bear, Ox, Colt, and other similar names borne by the initiates of the different Mysteries in Greece and Asia Minor. They go back to that pre- historic period where the divinities themselves were represented under the forms of animals; and when the worshipper, in taking the name and semblance of his gods, believed that he identified himself with them. The lion-headed Kronos having become the incarnation of Time, was substituted for the lions which the forerunners of the Mithraists worshipped; and similarly the cloth and paper masks with which the Roman mystics covered their faces were substitutes for the animal skins with which their barbarous predecessors originally clothed themselves, be it that they believed they thus *Ps. Augustine, Quaest. vet. et novi Test., {T. et M., Vol. II.. p. 8). 154 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA entered into communion with the monstrous idols which they worshipped, or that, in en- veloping themselves in the pelts of their flayed victims, they conceived these bloody tunics to possess some purifying virtue. To the primitive titles of Raven and Lion others were afterward added for the purpose of attaining the sacred number seven. The seven degrees of initiation through which the mystic was forced to pass in order to acquire perfect wisdom and purit}^ answered to the seven planetary spheres which the soul was forced to traverse in order to reach the abode of the blessed.* After having been Raven, the initiates were promoted to the rank of Occult {Kpv(f)Lo<5). The members of this class, hidden by some veil, probably remained in- visible to the rest of the congregation. To exhibit them {ostcudcrc) constituted a solemn act. The Soldier {nii'les) formed part of the sacred militia of the invincible god and waged war under his directions on the powers of evil. The dignity of Persian recalled the first origin of the Mazdean religion, and he who obtained it assumed during the sacred ceremonies the Oriental custom of donning the Phrygian cap, which had also been bestowed on JMithra. The latter having been identified with the Sun, his servitors invested themselves with the name of Runners of the Sun fHXto8/3o/x.ot); lastly, the title "Fathers" was borrowed from the Greek *See supra, p. 144. THE MITHRAIC LITURGY I55 Thiasi, where this honorific appellation fre- quently designated the directors of the com- munity. In this septuple division of the deities, cer- tain additional distinctions were established. " We may conclude from a passage in PorpTiyry that the taking of the first three degrees did not authorize participation in the Mysteries. These initiates, comparable to the Christian catechumens, were the Servants {vir-qpeTovvTe^). To enter this order it was sufficient to have been admitted to the Ravens, doubtless so called because mythology made the raven the servitor of the Sun. Only the mystics that had received the Leontics became Participants [ixere^ovre^), and it is for this reason that the grade of Leo is mentioned more frequently in the inscriptions than any other. Finally, at the summit of the hierarchy were placed the Fathers,_who appear to have presided oyer the sacred ceremonies ( ^ater sacroriuu) and to have commanded the other classes of the J[aithful. The head_of the Fathers thejns^lyes bore the name of Pater Patruni, sometimes transformed into Pater_ patratus, in order to introduce an official sacerdotal title into a_sect vdiich had become Roman. These grand- masters of the adepts retained until their death the general direction of the cult. The rever- ence and affection which were entertained for these venerable dignitaries are indicated by their name of Father, and the mystics placed 156 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA under their authority were called brethren by one another, because the fellow-initiates {con- sacranei) were expected to cherish mutual af- fection.* Admission [acceptio) to the lower orders could be accorded even to children. We do not know whether the initiates were obliged to remain in any one of the grades for a fixed length of time. The Fathers probably decided when the novice was sufficiently prepared to receive the higher initiation, which they con- ferred in person {tradcrc). This ceremony of initiation appears to have borne the name of sacrament [sacramcniuni), doubtless because of the oath which the neo- phyte took and which was compared to that made by the conscripts enrolled in the army. The candidate engaged above all things not to divulge the doctrines and the rites revealed to him, but other and more special vows were exacted of him. Thus, the mystic that aspired to the title of Miles was presented with a crown on a sword. He thrust it back with his hand and caused it to fall on his shoulder, say- ing that Mithra was his only crown. There- after, he never wore one, neither at banquets nor when it was awarded to him as a military honor, replying to the person who conferred it: "It belongs to my god," that is to say, to the invincible god. We are as poorly acquainted with the liturgy ♦See infra, p. 190, footnote. THE MITHRAIC LITURGY 157 of the seven Mithralc sacraments as we are with the dogmatic instructions that accom- panied them. We know, however, that con- formably to the ancient jranian rites, repeate ablutions were prescribed to neophytes as a ^ind^f baptism designed to wash away their^ guilty stains. As with a certain class of Gnos-^ tics, this lustration doubtless had different effects at each stage of initiation, and it might consist according to circumstances either in a simple sprinkling of holy water, or in an actual immersion as in the cult of Isis. Tertullian also compared the confirmation of his co-religionists to the ceremony in which they '.Islgned" the forehead of the soldier. It appears, however, that the sign or seal im- pressed was not, as in the Christian liturgy, an unction, but a marj^liurned with a red-hot iron like that applied in the army to recruits be- fore they were admitted to the oath. This Indelible imprint perpetuated the memory of the solemn engagement by which the person under vow contracted to serve in that order of chivalry which Mithraism constituted. On reception among the Lions, there were new purifications. But this animal being the em- blem of the principle of fire, the use of water, the element hostile to fire, was renounced; and, in order to preserve the initiate from the blemish of sin, honey was poured on his hands and applied to his tongue, as was the custom with new-born children. It was honey also 158 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA that was presented to the Persian because of its preservative virtue, as Porphyry tells us;* in fact, marvellous properties appear to have been associated with this substance, which was believed to have been produced under the in- fluence of the moon. According to the ancient ideas, it was the food of the blessed, and its absorption by the neophyte made him a peer of the gods.f In the Mazdean service, the celebrant con- f secrated the bread and the water which he mingled with the intoxicating juice of the Haoma prepared by him, and he consumed these foods during the performance of his sac- rifice. These ancient usages were preserved in the Mithraic initiations, save that for the Haoma, a plant unknown in the Occident, was substituted the juice of the vine. A loaf of bread and a goblet of water were placed before the mystic, over which the priest pronounced the sacred formula. This oblation of bread and water, with which undoubtedly wine was afterward mixed, is compared by the apolo- lgists to the Christian sacrament of the Lord's Supper. Like the latter, it was not granted luntil after a long novitiate. It is probable that only those initiates who had attained the degree of Lions were admitted to it, and that this is the reason that the name of "Partici- *Porph., De aniro nyvph., c. 15 (7". et M., Vol. II., p. 40). fThe liturgic use of honey lias recently been elucidated by Usener, "Milch und Honig" [Hcnius, LVII), 1902, p. 177 ff. THE MITHRAIC LITURGY 159 QJ in fc Sv . a^ -c ^ ^ "^-^ "71 "'"^ rt 3 O ^ U Q '^ U . ^ c ^ S *^ - -" o '^ a> 03 ^ CD CD -^ ^ t/3 OJ O 0) 1^ 0) >->•-' <4-i t-. -jui (D ;,> y f^ 1^ rt rt ^-^ ~ — t/3 W3 ,_ p C O cd 5 oi ^ d ^ bo si; H Pi a> o 164 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA was seized lent to images which were really puerile a most formidable appearance; the vain allurements with which he was con- fronted appeared to him serious dangers over which his courage triumphed. The fermented beverage which he imbibed excited his senses and disturbed his reason to the utmost pitch; he murmured his mystic formulas, and they evoked before his distracted imagination di- vine apparitions. In his ecstasy, he believed himself transported beyond the limits of the world, and having issued from his trance he repeated, as did the mystic of Apuleius:* "I have transcended the boundaries of death, I have trodden the threshold of Proserpine, and having traversed all the elements I am re- turned to the earth. In the middle of the night I have seen the Sun scintillating with a pure light; I have approached the gods below and the gods above, and have worshipped them face to face." The tradition of all this occult ceremonial 'was scrupulously observed by a priesthoodin- structedjn the divine science and distinct from all classes of initiates. Its first founders were certainly the Oriental Magi, but we are almost entirely ignorant of the manner in which its ranks were later recruited and organized. Was it hereditary, named for life, or chosen for a fixed term? In the latter event, who had the *Apuleius, Met am. XI, 23, a propos of the mystics of I sis. THE MITHRAIC LITURGY 165 right of choosing and what conditions did the candidates have to fulfil ? None of these points is sufficiently elucidated. We can only state that the priest, who bore indifferently, as it seems, the title of sacerdos or that of antistcs, was often, but not always, a member of the Fathers. We find one vicar, and sometimes several, in each temple. There is every ground for believing that a certain hierarchy existed in this "sacerdotal order." Tertullian tells us that the chief pontiff {s2i]ji}uus ponti- fexY could marry but once; he doubtless des- ignated by this Roman name the "Father of the Fathers," who appears to have exercised general jurisdiction over all the initiates resid- ing in the city.t This is the only indication we possess regarding an organization which was perhaps as solidly constituted as that of the Magi in the Sassanian kingdom, or that of the Manichccans of the Roman empire. The same apologist adds that the sectarians of the Persian god also had, like the Christians, their "virgins and their continents." The existence of this kind of Mithraic monachism appears to be all the more remarkable as the merit at- tached to celibacy is antagonistic to the spirit of Zoroastrianism. The role of the clergy was certainly more extensive than in the ancient Greek and Ro- *Tertull., De praescr. haeret., XL. fCf. supra, p. 155. I adopt here the suggestion of M. Wis- sova, Religion der Romer, 1902, p. 309. l66 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA man religions. The priest was the interme- diary between God and man. His functions evidently included the administration of the sacraments and the celebration of the serv- ices. The inscriptions tell us that in addition he presided at the formal dedications, or at least represented the faithful one on such an occasion along with the Fathers; but this was the least portion only of the duties he had to perform; the religious service which fell to his lot appears to have been very exacting. He doubtless was compelled to see that a per- petual fire burned upon the altars. Three jtimes a day, at dawn, at noom_ancLat^Lusk, he addressed _ajprayer to the Sun, turning in the morning toward the East, at noon toward the South, at evening toward the West. The daily liturgy frequently embraced special sacrifices. The celebrant, garbed in sacerdotal robes resembling those of the Magi, sacrificed to the higher and lower gods divers victims, the blood of which was collected in a trench; or offered them libations, holding in his hands the bundle of sacred twigs which we know from the Avesta. Long psalmodies and chants accom- panied with music were interspersed among the ritual acts. A solemn moment in the service, — one very probably marked by the sounding of a bell, — was that in which the image of the tauroctonous Mithra, hitherto kept veiled, was uncovered before the eyes of the initiates. In some temples, the sculptured THE MITHRAIC LITURGY 167 slab, like our tabernacles, revolved on a pivot, and alternately concealed and exposed the figures that adorned its two faces. Each day in the week, the Planet to which the day was sacred was invoked in a fixed spot in the crypt; and Sunday, over which the Sun presided, was especially holy. Further, the liturgic calendar solemnized certain dates by festivals concerning which we are unfortu- nately very poorly informed. Possibly the sixteenth or middle day of the month con- tinued (as in Persia) to have Mithra for its patron. On the other hand, there is never a word in the Occident concerning the celebra- tion of the Mithrakana, which were so popular In Asia.* They were doubtless merged in the celebration of the 25th of December, for a 3^ery wide-spread custom required thatjthenew birth of the Sun {N^aialts invicti), which began to wax great again on the termination of the winter solstice, should be celebrated by sacred .festivals^ We have good reasons for believing that the equinoxes were also days of rejoicing, the return of the deified seasons being inau- gurated by some religious salutation. The initiations took place preferably at the begin- ning of spring, in March or in April, at the Paschal period, when Christians likewise ad- mitted their catechumens to the rites of bap- tism. But concerning all these solemnities, as generally with everything connected with *See above, p. 9. l68 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA the heortology* of the Mysteries, our Ignorance is almost absolute. The Mithraic communities were not only brotherhoods united by spiritual bonds; they •V..^ ^were also associations possessing juridic exist- •ence and enjoying the right of holding prop- erty. For the management of their affairs and the care of their temporal interests, they elected officers, who must not be confounded either with the initiates or the priests. The titles borne in the descriptions by the mem- bers of these boards of trustees prove to us that the organization of the colleges of the worshippers of MIthra did not differ from that of the other religious sodalicia, which was based upon the constitutions of the munici- palities or towns. These corporations pub- lished an official list of their members, an albiiiu sacratoriim, in which the latter were ranked according to the importance of their office. They had at their head a council of decurions, a directing committee named most likely in a general assembly, a sort of minia- ture senate, of which the first ten [dcccui pritiii) possessed, as in the cities, special privileges. They had their masters [niagistri) or presi- dents, elected annually, their curators {cura- fores), upon whom fell the task of manag- ing the finances, their attorneys {dcfcnsorcs), charged with presenting their cause before *The science of festivals. From iopT-q, festival, holiday. — Tr. THE MITHRAIC LITURGY l6g the courts or public bureaus; and finally, their patrons [pa/nvii), persons of consequence, from whom they expected not only efficient protec- tion but also pecuniary aid in replenishing their budget. As the state granted them no subsidies, their well-being depended exclusively on private generosity. X'oluntary contributions, the reg- ular revenues of the college, scarcely covered the expenses of worship, and the least extraor- dinary expenditure was a heavy burden for the common purse. These associations of unmoneyed people could not, with their slen- der resources, construct sumptuous temples; ordinarily they acquired from some favorably disposed land-holder a piece of ground, on which they erected, or rather dug, their chapel, some other benefactor defraying the cost of the construction. Or, some wealthy burgher placed at the disposal of the mystics a cellar, where they installed themselves as best they could. If the original donor had not the means to pay for the interior decoration of the crypt and the modelling of the sacred images, other Brothers supplied the necessary sum, and a honorific inscription perpetuated the memory of their munificence. Three votive inscriptions found in Rome enable us to witness the founding of one of these Mith- raic congregations.* A freedman and a free- *-Corpus inscriptionum latinariim, Vol. VI., Nos. 556, 717, 734=30822 (T: et RL, Vol. II, p. loi, nos47_48>^i«). 170 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA man contributed a marble altar, two other initiates consecrated a second one, and a slave likewise made his modest offering. The generous protectors obtained in return for their liberality the highest dignities in the little church. Through their efforts it was gradually furnished, and in the end could allow itself certain luxuries. Marble suc- ceeded common stone, sculpture replaced plaster, and mosaic was substituted for paint- ing. Finally, when the first temple fell into decay, the enriched community frequently re- built it with new splendor. The number of the gifts mentioned in the epigraphic texts bears witness to the attach- ment of the faithful to the brotherhoods into which they had been admitted. It was owing to the constant devotion of the thousands of zealous disciples that these societies, the or- ganic cells of the great religious body, could live and flourish. The order was divided Into a multitude of little circles, strongly knit to- gether and practising the same rites in the same sanctuaries. The size of the temples in which they worshipped is proof that the num- ber of members was always very limited. Even supposing that the Participants only were allowed to enter the subterranean crypt and that the initiates of inferior rank were admitted only to the vestibule {proiiaos), it is impossible that these societies should have counted more than one hundred members. THE MITHRAIC LITURGY I/I When the number increased beyond measure, a new chapel was constructed and the group separated. In these compact churches, where every one knew and aided every one else, pre- vailed the intimacy of a large family. The clear-cut distinctions of an aristocratic society were here effaced; the adoption of the same faith had made the slave the equal, and some- times the superior, of the decurion and the clarissiiuiis. All bowed to the same rules, all were equally honored guests at the same festi- vals, and after their death they all doubtless reposed in one common sepulcher. Although no Mithraic cemetery has been discovered up to the present day, the special belief of the sect regarding the future life and its very defi- nite rites render it quite probable that like the majority of the Roman sodalicia it formed not only religious colleges but also funerary asso- ciations. It certainly practised inhumation, and the liveliest and most ardent desire of its adepts must have been that of obtaining an interment that was at once honorable and re- ligious, a "mansion eternal," where they could await in peace the day of the Resurrection. If the name of brothers which the initiates gave themselves was not an empty term, they were bound to render to one another at least this last duty. r^ The very imperfect image that we can frame jy^^lVJ 1 of the interior life of the Mithraic conventicles . ^1 aids us nevertheless in fathoming the reasons 1/2 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA J of_theIr rapid multiplication. The humble plebeians who first entered its vaults in great /: I numbers found in the fraternity of these con- jgregations succor and solace. In joining J them, they passed from their isolation and ! abandonment to become a part of a powerful organization with a fully developed hierarch}^ and having ramifications that spread like a j dense net over the entire empire. Besides, Ithe titles which were conferred upon them 'satisfied the natural desire that dwells in every man of playing a part in the world and of enjoying some consideration in the eyes of his Jellows. With these purely secular reasons were asso- ciated the more powerful motives of faith. The members of these little societies imagined themselves in the privileged possession of a body of ancient wisdom derived from the far Orient. The secrecy with which these un- fathomable arcana were surrounded increased the veneration that they inspired: Oi//>ic igno- tiiiii pro ))iagnifico est. The gradual initiations kept alive in the heart of the neophyte the hopes of truth still more sublime, and the strange rites which accompanied them left in his ingenuous soul an ineffaceable impression. The converts believed they found, and, the suggestion being transformed into reality, actually did find, in the mystic ceremonies a stimulant and a consolation. They l-jpllc-ypd themselves purified of their guilt by the ritual THE MITHRAIC LITURGY I73 f ablutions, and this baptism lightened their con- i^cieiiCe of the welkin uf itrdr heavy responsi- : bility. They came torth strengthened from j these sacred banquets, which contained the promise of a better life, where the sufferings \ of this world would find their full compensa- \ tion. The astonishing spread of Mithraism is \ due in large measure to these stupendous illu- ; sions, which would appear ludicrous were they \ not so profoundly and thoroughly human. ^ Nevertheless, in the competition between the rival churches that disputed under the Caesars the empire of human souls, one cause of inferiority rendered the struggle unequal for the Persian sect. Whilst the majority of the Oriental cults accorded to women a con- siderable role in their churches, and some- ^tim^es even a preponderating one, finding in "them ardent supporters of the faith, Mithra forbade their participation in his Mysteries ^ and so ..deprived himsel£-o£_t]ie iucalculabk-^ assistance of these propagandisis.. The rude discipline of the order did not permit them to take the degrees in the sacred cohorts, and, as among the Mazdeans of the Orient, they occupied only a secondary place in the society of the faithful. Among the hundreds of in- scriptions that have come down to us, not one mentions either a priestess, a woman initiate, or even a donatress. But a religion which aspired to become universal could not deny a knowledge of divine things to one half of the .W 1/4 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA human race, and in order to afford some op- portunity for feminine devotion it contracted at Rome an alliance which certainly contrib- uted to its success. The history of Mithraism in the Occident would not be intelligible if we neglected to consider its policy toward the rest of paganism. MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE THE acts of the Oriental martyrs bear eloquent testimony to the intolerance of the national clergy of the Persia of the Sassanids; and the Magi of the ancient em- pire, if they were not persecutors, at least con- stituted an exclusive caste, and possibly even a privileged race. The priests of Mithra afford no evidence of having assumed a like attitude. Like the Judaism of Alexandria, Mazdaism had been softened in Asia Minor by the Hellenic civilization. Transported into a strange world, it was compelled to accom- modate itself to the usages and ideas there prevailing; and the favor with which it was received encouraged it to persevere in its policy of conciliation. The Iranian gods who accompanied Mithra in his peregrinations were worshipped in the Occident under Greek and Latin names; the Avestan yazatas as- sumed there the guise of the immortals en- throned on Olympus, and these facts are in themselves sufficient to prove that far^ from exhibiting hostility toward the ancient Graeco- RBmanTlbenefs, the Asiatic religion sought to accommodate itself to them, in appearance at least. A pious mystic could, without renoun- 1/6 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA cing his faith, dedicate a votive inscription to the Capitoline triad,— Jupiter, Juno, and Mi- nerva; he merely invested these divine names Fig. 40. TAUROCTONOUS MITHRA In the possession of Mr. S. H. Janes, Janes Build- ings, Toronto, Canada. "With the usual accessories. In the upper left-hand corner a bust of the vSun, and in the upper right-hand corner a bust of the Moon. The left hand of the god, which has been broken off, appar- ently grasps a horn and not the nostrils of the bull. In all probability partly restored, it being scarcely possible that the dadophori could both have held upright torches. {T. ct 31., Fig. 418, p. 4S3.) with a different meaning from their ordinary acceptation. If the injunction to refrain from participating in other Mysteries, which is said tohave been imposed upon Mithraic initiates, MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE \']'J was ever obeyed it was not long able to with- stand^ tHe syncretic tendencies of imperial paganism. For in the fourth century the "Fathers of the Fathers" were found perform- ing the highest offices of the priesthood, in temples of all sorts. Everywhere the sect knew how to adapt it- self with consummate skill to the environment in which it lived. In the valley of the Danube It exercised on the indigenous cult an influence that presupposes a prolonged contact between them. In the region of the Rhine, the Celtic divinities were worshipped in the crypts of the Persian god, or at least alongside of them. Thus, the Mazdean theology, according to the country in which it flourished, was colored with variable tints, the precise gradations of which it is now impossible for us to follow. But these dogmatic shadings merely diversi- fied the subordinate details of the religion, and never imperilled its fundamental unity. There is not the slightest evidence that these deviations of a flexible doctrine provoked heresies. The concessions which it made were matters of pure form. In reality, Mith- raism having arrived in the Occident in its full maturity, and even showing signs of decrepi- tude, no longer assimilated the elements that it borrowed from the surrounding life. The only inriuences that profoundly modified its "clrararter were those to which it was subjected in its youth amidst the populations of Asia. 1 78 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA The close relation in which Mithra stood to certain gods of this country is explained not only by the natural affinity which united all Oriental immigrants in opposition to the paganism of Greece and Rome. The ancient religious hostility of the Egyptians and Per- sians persisted even in Rome under the em- "perors, and the Iranian Mysteries appear to have been separated from those of Isis by secret rivalry if not by open opposition. On tFi^'bther hand, they associated readily with the Syrian cults that had emigrated with them from Asia and Europe. Their doctrines, thor- oughly imbued with Chaldsean theories, must have presented a striking resemblance to that of the Semitic religions. Jupiter Dolichenus, who was w^orshipped simultaneously with Mithra in Commagene, the land of his origin, and who like the latter remained a preemi- nently military divinity, Is found by his side In all the countries of the Occident. At Carnun- tum in Pannonia, a mithra:um and a doliche- nuiJi^ adjoined each other. Baal, the lord of the heavens, was readily identified with Or- mazd, who had become Jupiter-Ca:lus, and Mithra was easily likened to the solar god of the Syrians. Even the rites of the two litur- gies appear to have offered some resemblances. As in Commagene, so also in Phrygia, Maz- dalsm had sought a common ground of under- standing with the religion of the country. In *A temple of Jupiter Dolichenus. — Fr. MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE 1 79 the union of Mithra and Anahita the counter- part was found of the intimacy between the great indigenous divinities Attis and Cybele, and this harmony between the two sacred couples persisted in Italy. The most ancient mithra?,um known to us was contiguous to the nietroon^ of Ostia, and we have every reason to believe that the worship of the Iranian god and that of the Phrygian goddess were con- ducted in intimate communion with each other throughout the entire extent of the empire. Despite the profound differences of their char- acter, political reasons drew them together. In conciliating the priests of the Mater Magna, the sectaries of Mithra obtained the support of a powerful and officially recognized clergy, and so shared in some measure in the protec- tion afforded it by the State. Further, since men only were permitted to take part In the secret ceremonies of the Persian liturgy, other Mysteries to which women were admitted must have formed some species of alliance with the former, to make them complete. The Great "TVTother succeeded thus to the place of Ana- hita; she had her Matrcs or "Mothers," as Mithra had his "Fathers"; and her initiates were known among one another as "Sisters," just as the votaries of her associate called one another "Brothers." This alliance, fruitful generally in its results, was especially profitable to the ancient cult of * A temple of Cybele. — 7?-. \h l80 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA Pessinus, now naturalized at Rome. The loud pomp of its festivals was a poor mask of the vacuity of its doctrines, which no longer satis- fied the aspirations of its devotees. Its gross theology was elevated by the adoption of cer- tain Mazdean beliefs. There can be scarcely any doubt that the practice of the taurobo- lium, with the ideas of purification and immor- tality appertaining to it, had passed under the Antonines from the temples of Anahita into those of the Mater Magna. The barbarous custom of allowing the blood ot a vicTlm slaughtered on a latticed platform to fall down iip'Trth-^^-m-y^ti^ b'ing in p pit h^lJ^j^^Ty^p*''^^^- jiblj; practised jn Asia froiTitime immemorial. According to a wide-spreacr~~notion among primitive peoples, the blood is the vehicle of the vital energy, and the person who poured it upon his body and moistened his tongue with it, believed that he was thereby endowed with the courage and strength of the slaugh- tered animal. This sacred bath appears to have been administered in Cappadocia in a great number of sanctuaries, and especially in those of Ma, the great indigenous divinity, and in those of Anahita. These goddesses, to whom the bull was consecrated, had been generally likened by the Greeks to their Artemis Tauropolos, and the ritualistic bap- tism practised in their cult received the name of tanropoliuiu [ravpo-nokiov), which was trans- formed by the popular etymology into fauro- MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE l8l bolinm {Tavpo/36\iov). But under the influence _ of the Mazdean beUefs regarding the future life, a more profound significance was attrib- "uted to this baptism of blood. In taking it the devotees no longer imagined they acquired the strength of the bull; it was no longer a renewal of physical strength that the life-sus- taining liquid was now thought to communi- cate, but a renovation, temporary or even perpetual, ot the human soul.* vVhen, under the empire, the taurobolium was introduced into Ital}^ it was not quite cer- tain at the outset what Latin name should be given the goddess in whose honor it was cele- brated. Some saw in her a celestial Venus; others compared her to Minerva, because of her warlike character. But the priests of Cybele soon introduced the ceremony into their liturgy, — evidently with the complicity of the official authorities, for nothing in the ritual of this recognized cult could be modified without the authorization of the quindecem- virs. Even the emperors^re known to have granted privileges to those who performed this hideous sacrifice for their salvation, though their motives for this special favor are not clearly apparent. The efficacy which was ^attributed to this bloody purification, the eter- nal new birth that was expected of it> j';esem- ♦These pages summarize the conclusions of a study entitled Le taurobole et Ic culte de Be/lone, published in the Revue d" histoire et de litteratiirc reliirieuses. l82 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA bled the hopes which the mystics of Mithra attached to the immolation of the mythical bull.* The similarity of these doctrines is quite naturally explained by the identity of their origin. The taurobolium, like many rites of the Oriental cults, is a survival of a sav- age past which a spiritualistic theology had adapted to moral ends. It is a characteristic fact that the first immolations of this kind that we know to have been performed by the clergy of the Phrygian goddess took place at Ostia, where the uictroon, as we saw above, adjoined a Mithraic crypt. The symbolism of the Mysteries certainly saw in the Magna Ala^er the nourishing Earth which the Heavens yearly fecundated. So the Graico-Roman divinities which they adopted changed in character on entering their dogmatic system. Sometimes, these gods were identified with the Mazdean heroes, and the barbaric legends then celebrated the new exploits which they had performed. Sometimes, they were considered the agents that produced the various transformations of the universe. Then, in the center of this pantheon, which had again become natural- istic, as it was at its origin, was placed the Sun, for he was the supreme lord that governed the movements of all the planets and even the revolutions of the heavens themselves, — the one who suffused with his light and his heat *See above, p. 146. MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE I83 all of life here below. This conception, as- tronomical in its origin, predominated more _an^d^ more according as Mithra entered into more intimate relatj(>ns^with Greek thought Mithra slaying the bull. On the reverse Cupid and Psyche (broken). Obverse: The sun-god standing upright on his quadriga and holding in his hand the globe on which the four quarters are indicated. Reverse: Mithra leading off the bull. (Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York.) Fig- 41. MITHRAIC GEMS. Green jasper. {T. ct M., p. 449.) and became a more faithful subject of the Roman state. The worship of the Sun, the outcome of a sentiment of recognition for its daily benefac- l84 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA tions, augmented by the observation of its tre- mendous role in the cosmic system, was the ^logical upshot of paganism. When critical "thought sought to explain the sacred tradi- tions and discovered in the popular gods the forces and elements of nature, it was obliged perforce to accord a predominant place to the star on which the very existence of our globe depended, "Before religion reached the point where it proclaimed that God should be sought in the Absolute and the Ideal, that is to say, outside the world, one cult only was reason- able and scientific and that was the cult of the Sun."* From the time of Plato and Aris- totle, Greek philosophy regarded the celestial bodies as animate and divine creatures; Stoi- cism furnished new arguments in favor of this opinion; while Neo-Pythagorism and Neo- Platonism insisted still more emphatically on the sacred character of the luminary which is the ever-present image of the intelligible God. These beliefs, approved by the thinkers, were widely diffused by literature, anci particularly by the works in which romantic fiction served to envelop genuinely theological teachings. If heliolatry was in accord with the philo- sophical doctrines of the day, it was not less in conformity with its political tendencies. We have essayed to show the connection which existed between the worship of the emperors * Renan, Lettre h Bert helot {Dialogues et fragments philosophiqucs'), p. i68. MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE 185 and that of the Solinvictiis. When the Caesars of the third century pretended to be gods de- scended from heaven to the earth, the justifica- tion of their imaginary claims had as its corol- lary the establishment of a public worship of the divinity from whom they believed themselves the emanations. Heliogabalus had claimed for his Baal of Emesa the supremacy over the Fig. 42. MriHRAIC CAMEO (reD JASPER). Principal face: In the center, the tauroctonous Mithra, with the dog, the scorpion, the two torch- bearers, etc. Reverse: A lion with a bee in his mouth; above, seven stars surrounded by magic Greek inscriptions. {T. et M., p. 450.) entire pagan pantheon. The eccentricities and violences of this unbalanced man resulted in the lamentable wreck of his undertaking; but it answered to the needs of the time and was soon taken up again with better success. Near the Flamlnian Way, to the east of the Field of Mars, Aurelian consecrated a colossal edifice to the tutelary god that had granted him victory in Syria. The religion of state 1 86 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA that he constituted must not be confounded with Mithraism. Its imposing temple, its ostentatious ceremonies, its quadrennial games, its pontifical clergy, remind us of the great sanctuaries of the Orient and not of the dim caves in which the Mysteries were cele- Fig. 43- SOL THE SUN-GOD. Installed by Mithra as the governor of the world. To the right the globe of power. {T. ct M., p. 202.) brated. Nevertheless, the Sol iiivichts, whom the emperor had intended to honor with a pomp hitherto unheard of, could well be claimed as their own by the followers of Mithra. The imperial policy gave the first place in the official religion to the Sun, of which the sovereign was the emanation, just as in the MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE 187 Chaldecan speculations propagated by the Mithraists the royal planet held sway over the other stars. On both sides, the growing tendency was to see in the brilliant star that illuminated the universe the only God, or at least the sensible image of the only God, and "to establish in the heav.eng. a,, monotheism in imitation of the monarchy that ruled on earth. ' Macrobius (400 A.D.), in his Saturnalia, has learnedly set forth that the gods were ulti- mately reducible to a single Being considered under different aspects, and that the multiple names by which they were worshipped were "the equivalent of that of Helios (the Sun). The theologian Vettius Agorius Proctextatus who defended this radical syncrasy was not only one of the highest dignitaries of the em- pire, but one of the last chiefs of the Persian Mysteries. J>^ Mithraism, at least in the fourth century, ^ had therefore as its end and aim the union of all gods and all myths in a vast synthesis, — the foundation of a new religion in harmony with the prevailing philosophy and political constitution of the empire. This religion would have been as far removed from the ancient Iranian Mazdaism as from Grseco- Roman paganism, which accorded the sidereal powers a minimal place only. It had in a measure traced idolatry back to its origin, and ^dTscovered in the myths that obscured its comprehension the deificatjon of nature. l88 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA Breaking with the Roman principle of the na- tionahty of worship, it would have established the universal domination of Mithra, identified with the invincible Sun. Its adherents hoped, by concentrating all their devotion upon a single object, to impart new cohesion to the disintegrated beliefs. Solar pantheism was the last refuge of conservative spirits, now menaced b}^ a revolutionary propaganda that aimed at the annihilation of the entire ancient order of things. At the time when this pagan monotheism sought to establish its ascendency in Kome, the struggle between tlie IMithraic Mysteries and Christianity had long begun. The propa- gation of the two religions had been almost contemporaneously conducted, and their diffu- sion had taken place under analogous condi- tions. Both from the Orient, they had spread because of the same general reasons, viz., the /political unity) and the (^moral anarchy/of the empire. Their diffusion had been accom- plished with like rapidity, and toward the close of the second century they both numbered adherents in the most distant parts of the Roman world. The sectaries of Mithra might justly lay claim to the hyperbolic utterance of TertuUian : ''' Hcstcrni siiiiius ct vcstra ouinia i/u- plevimusr If we consider the number of the monuments that the Persian religion has left us, one may easily ask whether in the epoch of the Severi its adepts were not more numer- MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE 1 89 ous than the disciples of Christ. Another 4Joint of resemblance between the two antago- nistic creeds was that at the outset they drew their proselytes chiefly from the inferior classes of society; their propaganda was at "the origin essentially popular; unlike the phil- osophical sects, they addressed their endeav- ors less to cultivated minds than to the masses, and consequently appealed more to sentiment than to reason- But by the side of these resemblances con- siderable differences are to be remarked in the methods of procedure of the two adver- saries. The initial conquests of Christianity ^ were favored by the Jewish diaspora, and it first spread in the countries inhabited by Israelitic colonies. It was therefore chiefly in the countries washed by the Mediterranean that its communities developed. They did not extend their field of action outside the cities, and their multiplication is due in great part to missions undertaken with the express purpose of "instructing the nations." The ex- tension of Mithraism, on the other hand, was essentially a natural product of social and political factors; namely, of the importation of slaves, the transportation of troops, and the transfer of public functionaries. It was in government circles and in the army that it counted its greatest number of votaries, — that is, in circles where very few Christians could \ be found because of their aversion to official igO THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA paganism. Outside of Italy, it spread prin- cipally along- the frontiers and simultaneously gained a foothold in the cities and in the country. It found its strongest points of sup- port in the Danubian provinces and in Ger- many, whereas Christianity made most rapid progress in Asia Minor and Syria. The spheres of the two religious powers, therefore, were not coincident, and they could accord- ingly long grow and develop without coming directly into conflict. It was in the valley of the Rhone, in Africa, and especially in the city of Rome, where the two competitors were most firmly established, that the rivalry, dur- ing the third century, became particularly brisk between the bands of Mithra's worship- pers and the disciples of Christ. =» The struggle between the two rival religions was the more stubborn as their characters wprp 1-Itp T[r>nrf- alike, "l^he adepts of both formed secret conventicles, closely united, the members of which gave ihemsetves the name of "Brothers."* The rites which they prac- tised offered numerous analogies. The sec- taries of the Persian god, like the Christians, purified themselves by baptism; received, by a species ot conhrmation, the power necessary to combat the spirits of evil; and expected *I may remark that even the expression "dearest brothers" had already been used by the sectaries of Jupiter Dolicheuus (CIL, VI, 406^=30758: frat7'es carissimos et cojilegas /ion [esiisswios]) and probably also in the Mithraic associations. MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE IQI from a Lord's Supper salvation of body and soul. Like the latter, they also held Sunday sacred, and celebrated the birth of the Sun on the 25th of December, the same day on which Christmas has been celebrated, since the fourth century at least. They both preached a categorical system of ethics, regarded ascet- icism as meritorious, and counted among their principal virtues abstinence and conti- nence, renunciation and self-control. Their conceptions of the world and of the destiny of man were similar. They both admitted the existence of a Heaven inhabited by beatified ones, situate in the upper regions, and of a Hell peopled by demons, situate in the bowels of the earth. They both placed a Flood at the beginning of history; they both assigned as the source of their traditions a primitive revelation; they both, finally, believed in the immortality of the soul, in a last judgment, and in a resurrection of the dead, consequent upon a final conflagration of the universe. We have seen that the theology of the Mys- teries made of Mithra a "mediator" equivalent to the Alexandrian Logos. Like him, Christ also was a /xeo-ir-r^?, an intermediary between his celestial father and men, and like him he also was one of a trinity. These resemblances were certainly not the only ones that pagan exegesis established between the two religions, and the figure of the tauroctonous god reluc- tantly immolating his victim that he might 192 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA Fig. 4+- THE PASSION OF THE GOD. The Dying Alexander, so called. Type of a group of sculptures from the school of Pergamon, dating from the second century before Christ. The idealized portrait of Alexander as solar god has been discovered in the head of the celebrated Mithraic statue of the Capitol (see Fig. 4, page 21), and the facial expressions of dolor, pathos, and compassion which characterize this work are shared by all the more important repre- sentations of the Mithraic sacrifice. The present sculpture has been partly restored, and it is therefore impossible to determine absolutely whether it originally formed part of an Asiatic group of the tauroctonous Mithra. {T. ct 3f., Introduction, p. 1S2.) MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE I93 create and save the human race, was certainly compared to the picture of the redeemer sac- rificing his own person for the salvation of the world. On the other hand, the ecclesiastical wri- ters, reviving a metaphor of the prophet Mal- achi, contrasted the "Sun of justice" with the "invincible Sun," and consented to see in the dazzling orb which illuminated men a symbol of Christ, "the light of the world." Should we be astonished if the multitudes of devotees failed always to observe the subtle distinctions of the doctors, and if in obedience to a pagan custom they rendered to the radiant star of day the homage which orthodoxy reserved for God ? In the fifth century, not only heretics, but even faithful followers, were still wont to bow their heads toward its dazzling disc as it rose above the horizon, and to murmur the prayer, "Have mercy upon us." The resemblances between the two hostile churches were so striking as to impress even the minds of antiquity. From the third cen- tury, the Greek philosophers were wont to draw parallels between the Persian Mysteries and Christianity which were evidently entirely in favor of the former. The Apologists also dwelt on the analogies between the two relig- ions, and explained them as a Satanic travesty of the holiest rites of their religion. If the polemical works of the Mithraists had been preserved, we should doubtless have heard the 194 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA same accusation hurled back upon their Chris- tian adversaries. We cannot presume to unravel to-day a question which divided contemporaries and which shall doubtless forever remain insol- uble. We are too imperfectly acquainted with the dogmas and liturgies of Roman Maz- daism, as well as with the development of primitive Christianity, to say definitely what mutual influences were operative in their simultaneous evolution. But be this as it j^ may, resemblances do not necessarily suppose r^ an imitation. Many correspondences between the Mithraic doctrine and the Catholic faith are explicable by their common Oriental jjorigin. Nevertheless, certain ideas and cer- jMtain ceremonies must necessarily have passed j llifrom the one cult to the other; but in the ilmajority of cases we rather suspect this trans- \ iference than clearly perceive it. Apparently the attempt was made to dis- cern in the legend of the Iranian hero the counterpart of the life of Jesus, and the dis- ciples of the Magi probably drew a direct con- trast between the Mithraic worship of the shepherds, the Mithraic communion and ascension, and those of the Gospels. The rock of generation, which had given birth to the genius of light, was even compared to the immovable rock, emblem of Christ, upon which the Church was founded; and the crypt in which the bull had perished was made the MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE I95 counterpart of that in which Christ is said to have been born at Bethlehem.* But this strained paralleHsm could result in nothing but a caricature. It was a strong source of inferiority for Mazdaism that it believed in only a mythical redeemer. That unfailing wellspring of religious emotion supplied by the teachings and the passion of the God sacrificed on the cross, never flowed for the disciples of Mithra. On the other hand, the orthodox and heret- ical liturgies of Christianity, which gradually sprang up during the first centuries of our era, could find abundant inspiration in the Mith- raic Mysteries, which of all the pagan religions offered the most affinity with Christian insti- tutions. We do not know whether the ritual of the sacraments and the hopes attaching to them suffered alteration through the influence of Mazdean dogmas and practices. Perhaps the custom of invoking the Sun three times each day, — ^at dawn, at noon, and at dusk,^ — was * M. Jean Reville {Etudes publiecs en hommage a lafaculte de th^ologie de Montauban, 1901, pp. 339 et seq.) thinks that the Gospel story of the birth of Christ and the adoration of the Magi was suggested by the Mithraic legend ; but he remarks that we have no proof of the supposition. So also M. A. Die- terich in a recent article {Zeztschr.f. Neutest. JTiss., 1902, p. 190), in which he has endeavored not without ingenuity to ex- plain the formation of the legend of the Magi kings, admits that the worship of the shepherds was introduced into Christian tradition from Mazdaism. But I must remark that the Maz- dean beliefs regarding the advent of Mithra into the world have strangely varied. (Cf. T. et M., Vol. I. , pp. 160 et seq.) 196 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA reproduced in the daily prayers of the Church, and it appears certain that the commemora- tion of the Nativity was set for the 25th of December, because it was at the winter sol- stice that the rebirth of the invincible god,* the Natalis invicti, was celebrated. In adopt- ing this date, which was universally distin- guished by sacred festivities, the ecclesiastical Fig. 45- BAS-RELIEF OF MAYENCE. Mithra drawing his bow; and the god of the winds. authority purified in some measure the pro- fane usages which it could not suppress. The only domain in which we can ascertain in detail the extent to which Christianity imi- tated Mithraism is that of art. The Mithraic sculpture, which had been first developed, fur- nished the ancient Christian marble-cutters with a large number of models, which they adopted or adapted. For example, they drew *See above, p. 167. MITIIRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE I97 inspiration from the figure of Mithra causing the living waters to leap forth by the blows of his arrows,* to create the figure of Moses smiting with his rod the rock of Horeb (Fig. 45). Faithful to an inveterate tradition, they even reproduced the figures of cosmic divini- ties, like the Heavens and the Winds, the worship of which the new faith had expressly proscribed; and we find on the sarcophagi, in miniatures, and even on the portals of the Romance Churches, evidences of the influence exerted by the imposing compositions that adorned the sacred grottos of Mithra. f It would be wrong, however, to exaggerate the significance of these likenesses. 4f Chris- ^tianity and Mithraism offered profound reseniv blances, the principal of which were the belief, "in the purification of souls and the hope of a beatific resurrection, differences no less essen- tial separated them. The most important was"* the contrast of their relations to Roman pa- ganism. The Mazdean Mysteries sought to "conciliate paganism by a succession of adapta- tions and compromises; they endeavored to establish monotheism while not combating "^polytheism, whereas the Church was, in point of principle, if not always in practice, the unrelenting antagonist of idolatry in any form. The attitude of Mithraism was appar- ently the wiser; it gave to the Persian relig- *See above, p. 13S. f See p. 227. 198 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA ion greater elasticity and powers of adaptation, and it attracted toward the tauroctonous god all who stood in dread of a painful rupture with ancient traditions and contemporaneous society. The preference must therefore have been given by many to dogmas that satisfied their aspirations for greater purity and a bet- ter world, without compelling them to detest the faith of their fathers and the State of which they were citizens. As the Church grew in power despite Its persecutors, this policy of compromise first assured to Mlthra- ism much tolerance and afterward even the favor of the public authorities. But it also prevented it from freeing itself of the gross and ridiculous superstitions which compli- cated its ritual and its theology; it Involved it, in spite of its austerity, in an equivocal alli- ance with the orgiastic cult of the beloved of Attis; and It compelled It to carry the entire weight of a chimerical and odious past. If Romanized Mazdaism had triumphed, it would not only have preserved from oblivion all the aberrations of pagan mysticism, but would also have perpetuated the erroneous doctrine of physics on which its dogmatism reposed. The Christian doctrine, which broke with the cults of nature, remained exempt from these impure associations, and its liberation from every compromising attachment assured it an immense superiority. Its negative value, its struggle against deeply-rooted prejudices, MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE I99 gained for it as many souls as did the positive hopes which it promised. It performed the miraculous feat of triumphing over the an- cient world in spite of legislation and the im- perial policy, and the Mithraic Mysteries were promptly abolished the moment the protection of the State was withdrawn and transformed into hostility. Mithraism reached the apogee of its power toward the middle of the third century, and it appeared for a moment as if the world was on the verge of becoming Mithraic. But the first invasions of the barbarians, and especially the definitive loss of Dacia (275 A.D.), soon after followed by that of the Agri Decumates, ad- ministered a terrible blow to the Mazdean sect, which was most powerful in the periphery of the orbis RoiJiamis. In all Pannonia, and as far as Virunum, on the frontiers of Italy, its temples were sacked. By way of compensa- tion, the authorities, menaced by the rapid progress of Christianity, renewed their sup- port to the most redoubtable adversary that they could oppose to it. In the universal downfall the army was the only institution that remained standing, and the Caesars cre- ated by the legions were bound perforce to seek their support in the favored religion of their soldiers. In 273 A.D., Aurelian founded by the side of the Mysteries of the taurocto- nous god a public religion, which he richly endowed, in honor of the Sol mvictus. Dio- 200 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA cletian, whose court with its complicated hier- archy, its prostrations before its lord, and its crowds of eunuchs, was, by the admission of contemporaries, an imitation of the court of the Sassanids, was naturally inclined to adopt doctrines of Persian origin, which flattered his despotic instincts. The emperor and the princes whom he had associated with himself, meeting in conference at Carnuntum in 307 A.D., restored there one of the temples of the celestial protector of their newly-organized empire.* The Christians believed, not with- out some appearance of reason, that the Mith- raic clergy were the instigators of the great persecutions under Galerius. In the Roman empire as in Iran, a vaguely monistic heliol- atry appeared on the verge of becoming the sole, intolerant religion of state. But the con- version of Constantine shattered the hopes which the policy of his predecessors had held out to the worshippers of the sun. Although he did not persecute the beliefs which he him- self had shared, f they ceased to constitute a recognized cult and were tolerated only. His successors were outspokenly hostile. To latent deflance succeeded open persecution. Christian polemics no longer restricted its attacks to ridiculing the legends and practices of the Mazdean Mysteries, nor even to taunt- * See above, pp. 8S-89. \Cf. Preger, Konstantiitos-Helios (Hermes, XXXVI), 1901, P- 457- M ITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE 201 ing them for having as their founders the irrec- oncilable enemies of Rome; it now stridently demanded the total destruction of idolatry, and its exhortations were promptly carried into effect. When a rhetorician* tells us that under Constantius no one longer dared to look at the rising or setting sun, that even farmers and sailors refrained from observing the stars, and tremblingly held their eyes fixed upon the ground, we have in these emphatic declara- tions a magnified echo of the fears that then filled all pagan hearts. The proclamation of Julian the Apostate (331-363 A.D.) suddenly inaugurated an unex- pected turn in affairs. A philosopher, seated on the throne by the armies of Gaul, Julian had cherished from childhood a secret devo- tion for Helios. He was firmly convinced that this god had rescued him from the perils that menaced his youth; he believed that he was entrusted by him with a divine mission, and regarded himself as his servitor, or rather as his spiritual son. He dedicated to this celes- tial "king" a discourse in which the ardor of his faith transforms in places a cold theolog- ical dissertation into an inflamed dithyrambic, and the fervor of his devotion for the star that he worshipped never waned to the mo- ment of his death. The young prince had been presumably drawn to the Mysteries by his superstitious *Mamert., Grat. actio in Itilian., c. 23. 202 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA predilection for the supernatural. Before his accession, perhaps even from youth, he had been introduced secretly into a Mithraic con- venticle by the philosopher Maximus of Eph- ^y esus. The ceremonies of his initiation must have made a deep impression on his feelings. He imagined himself thenceforward under the special patronage of Mithra, in this life and in that to come. As soon as he had cast aside his mask and openly proclaimed himself a pagan, he called Maximus to his side, and doubtless had recourse to extraordinary ablu- tions and purifications to wipe out the stains which he had contracted in receiving the bap- tism and the communion of the Christians. Scarcely had he ascended the throne (361 A.D.) than he made haste to introduce the Persian cult at Constantinople; and almost simultaneously the first taurobolia were celebrated at Athens. On all sides the sectaries of the Magi lifted their heads. At Alexandria the patriarch George, in attempting to erect a church on the ruins of a mithra:um, provoked a sanguinary riot. Arrested by the magistrates, he was torn from his prison and cruelly slain by the populace on the 24th of December, 361, the eve of the A^atalis iiivicii. The emperor con- tented himself with addressing a paternal remonstrance to the city of Serapis. \/^ But the Apostate soon met his death in the historic expedition against the Persians, to which he had possibly been drawn b}^ the \ / V MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE 203 secret desire to conquer the land which had given him his faith and by the assurance that his tutelary god would accept his homage rather than that of his enemies. Thus per- ished this spasmodic attempt at reaction, and Christianity, now definitively victor, addressed itself to the task of extirpating the erroneous doctrine that had caused it so much anxiety. Even before the emperors had forbidden the exercise of idolatry, their edicts against astrol- ogy and magic furnished an indirect means of attacking the clergy and disciples of Mithra. In 371 A.D., a number of persons who culti- vated occult practices were implicated in a pretended conspiracy and put to death. The mystagogue Maximus himself perished as the victim of an accusation of this kind. It was not long before the imperial govern- melirTegislated formally and directly against the disgraced sect. In the provinces, popular uprisings frequently anticipated the interfer- ence of the magistrates. Mobs sacked the temples and committed them to the flames, with the complicity of the authorities. The ruins of the mithraeums bear witness to the violence of their devastating fury. Even at Rome, in 2>11 A.D., the prefect Gracchus, seeking the privilege of baptism, offered as a pledge of the sincerity of his conversion the "destruction, shattering, and shivering,"* of a *St. Jerome, Epist. 107 ad Lcetam {T. et M., Vol. IT., p. 18), siibvertit, f regit, excussit. 204 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA Mithraic crypt, with all the statues that it con- tained. Frequently, in order to protect their grottoes from pillage by making them inac- cessible, the priests walled up the entrances, or conveyed their sacred images to well-pro- tected hiding-places, convinced that the tern- Fig. 46. CHAINED SKELETON. Discovered in the ruins of a Mithraic temple at Sarrebourg, in Lorraine. {T. et M., p. 51Q.) pest that had burst upon them was momentary only, and that after their days of trial their god would cause again to shine forth the light of final triumph. On the other hand, the Christians, in order to render places contami- nated by the presence of a dead body ever afterward unfit for worship, sometimes slew MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE 205 the refractory priests of Mithra and buried them in the ruins of their sanctuaries, now forever profaned (P ig. 46). The hope of restoration was especially tenacious at Rome, which remained the cap- ital of paganism. The aristocracy, still faith- ful to the traditions of their ancestors, supported the j^eligion with their wealth and prestige. Its members loved to deck them- selves with the titles of "Father and Herald of Mithra Invincible," and multiplied the offerings and the foundations. They re- doubled their generosity toward him when ,Gratian in 382 A.D. despoiled their temples ofTHetf~wealth. A great lord recounts to us in poor verses how he had restored a splendid crypt erected by his grandfather near the Flaminian Way, boasting that he was able to dispense with public subsidies of any kind.* The usurpation of Eugenius appeared for a moment to bring on the expected resurrec- tion. The prefect of the prretorium, Nicoma- chus Flavianus, celebrated solemn taurobolia and renewed in a sacred cave the Mysteries of the "associate god" {deiini coinitcni) of the pretender. But the victory of Theodosius, 394 A.D., shattered once and foT"alt"rlTe hopes oflTiese belated partisans of the ancient Maz- dean belief. A few clandestine conventicles may, with stubborn persistence, have been held in the *CIL, VI, {T. et M., Vol II, p. 94, No. 13). 206 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA subterranean retreats of the palaces. The cult of the Persian god possibly existed as late as the fifth century in certain remote cantons of the Alps and the Vosges. For example, devotion to the Mithraic rites long persisted in the tribe of the Anauni, masters of a flour- ishing valley, of which a narrow defile closed the mouth. But little by little its last disciples in the Latin countries abandoned a religion tainted with moral as well as political deca- dence. It maintained its ground with greater tenacity in the Orient, the land of its birth. Driven out of the rest of the empire, it found a refuge in the countries of its origin, where its light only slowly flickered out. Nevertheless, the conceptions which Mith- raism had diffused throughout the empire during a period of three centuries were not destined to perish with it. Some of them, even those most characteristic of it, such as its ideas concerning Hell, the efficacy of the sacraments, and the resurrection of the flesh, were accepted even by its adversaries; and in disseminating them it had simply accelerated their universal domination. Certain of its sacred practices continued to exist also in the ritual of Christian festivals and in popular usage. Its fundamental dogmas, however, were irreconcilable with orthodox Christian- ity, outside of which only they could maintain their hold. Its theory of sidereal influences, alternately condemned and tolerated, was MITHRAISM AND THE RELIGIONS OF THE EMPIRE 20/ carried down by astrology to the threshold of modern times; but it was to a religion more powerful than this false science that the Per- sian Mysteries were destined to bequeath, along with their hatred of the Church, their cardinal ideas and their influence over the masses. Manichaeism, although the work of a man and not the product of a long evolution, was connected with these Mysteries by numerous affijikies. The tradition according to which Its original founders had conversed in Persia with the priests of Mithra may be inexact in form, but it involves nevertheless a profound truth. Both religions had been formed in the Orient from a mixture of the ancient Babylon- ian mythology with Persian dualism, and had afterward absorbed Hellenic elements. The sect of Manichceus spread throughout the em- pire during the fourth century, at the moment when Mithraism was expiring, and it was called to assume the latter's succession. Mys- tics whom the polemics of the Church against paganism had shaken but not converted were enraptured with the new conciliatory faith which suffered Zoroaster and Christ to be simultaneously worshipped. The wide dif- fusion which the Mazdean beliefs with their mixture of Chaldasism had enjoyed, prepared the minds of the empire for the reception of the new heresy. The latter found its way made smooth for it, and this is the secret of 208 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA its sudden expansion. Thus^renewed, the Mithraic doctrines were destined to withstand for centuries all persecutions, and rising again Tin a new form in the Middle Ages to shake once more the ancient Roman world. MITHRAIC ART* THE monuments of Mithraism, which have been found in considerable numbers in the provinces of the Occident and even in the Orient, constitute a homogeneous group, of which it is desirable to characterize the im- portance for the history of Roman art. In point of fact, their artistic merit is far below that of their value as historical documents, and their chief worth is not aesthetic but religious. The late epoch in which these works were produced destroys the least hope of finding in them any expression of true creative power or of following in them the progress of any orig- inal development. But it would be unjust if, inspired by a narrow-minded Atticism, we should cast upon them all a like measure of reproach. In the absence of inventive genius, their cleverness in the adaptation of ancient motifs and the manual skill shown in their ex- ecution,— all technical qualities of which they give evidence, — would alone be sufficient to claim our attention. Some of the groups in high and low relief, — for the paintings and mosaics which have been preserved are so few and mediocre as to dispense us from speaking *In the original this chapter appeared as an Appendix. We have given it an independent place in this edition, — Tr. 209 210 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA of them, — hold a very honorable place in the multitude of sculptured works which the im- perial period has left us, and are deserving of some consideration. It can be proved* that all our representations of the tauroctonous Mithra, the hieratic figure of which was fixed before the propagation of the Mysteries in the Occident, are more or less faithful replicas of a type created by a sculptor of the school of Pergamon, in imitation of the sacrificing Victory which adorned the balus- trade of the temple of Athena Nike on the Acropolis. Certain marbles discovered at Rome and at Ostia (see for example, Figs. 4, 5, 6 and 10), which unquestionably go back to the beginning of the second century, still reflect the splendor of the powerful com- positions of the Hellenistic epoch. After an ardent pursuit, the god captures the bull, which has fallen to the earth; with one knee on its croup and his foot on one of its hoofs, he bears down upon it, pressing it against the earth; and grasping it by the nos- trils with one hand, with the other he plunges a knife into its flank. The impetuosity of this animated scene throws into high relief the agility and strength of the invincible hero. On the other hand, the suffering of the mori- bund victim gasping its last, with its limbs con- tracted in the spasms of death, the singular ♦Compare my large work, Textes et Mo?tujnenfs figiirh relatifs aux Mystires de Mithra, Vol. II., pp. 180 et seq. MITHRAIC ART 211 mixture of exaltation and remorse depicted in the countenance of its slayer, give prominence to the pathetic side of this sacred drama, and even to-day inspire in the heart of the spec- tator an emotion which the faithful of old ex- perienced in all its living power. (See Fio. 44 and also the cover-stamp of this book.) The traditional type of torch-bearers, or dadopJiori, was not susceptible of a similar im- passioned treatment. But one remarks, never- theless, in the best specimens the advantageous effect which the artist has produced by the ample Phrygian garments and by emphasizing the different emotions of hope and sadness portrayed on the countenances of the two young men. We possess a remarkable repro- duction of this divine couple in the two statues discovered near the Tiber, which Zoega attrib- uted to the epoch of Hadrian and which were possibly imported from the Orient to Italy.* (See Figures 47 and 48.) It will be seen how their author succeeded in offsetting the defective symmetry resulting from the fact that the two figures, which are intended as counterparts, have both their mantles fastened at the right shoulder and falling down at the right side. The solicitous concern for details which characterizes the works of the Antonine epoch was also bestowed with more or less felicity * T. ct M., Mon. 27, Plate II, opposite p. 209, Vol. II. Conmut thinks these statues are prior to Hadrian. 212 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA upon the monuments of a slightly more recent date. Consider the group of Ostia, which Fig- 47. MITHRAIC DADOPHORUS. Wrongly restored as Paris. dates from the reign of Commodus, or the bas- relief of the \'illa Albani, which appears to be MITHRAIC ART 213 contemporaneous with the first.* The artist delighted in multiplying the folds of the gar- Fig-. 48. MITHRAIC DADOPHORUS. Wrongly restored as Paris. ments and in increasing the undulations of the hair merely to show his skill in conquering the * T. et M., Mon. 79, Fig. 67; and Mon. 3S, Fig. 45. 214 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA difficulties which he had himself created; yet even this bizaj-re mannerism does not atone for the coldness of the total impression. The success of this minute execution of details is more felicitous in fragments of smaller dimen- sions. A small marble recently discovered in Aquileia, and reproduced in our Frontispiece is distinguished in this respect by a "bewilder- ing cleverness of technique." The delicately carved figures are almost entirely severed from their massive base, to which they are attached only by the thinnest supports. It is a piece of artistic braggadocio in which the sculptor parades his virtuosity by producing with a brit- tle material the same effects that are obtained by workers in ductile metals.* But these comparatively perfect composi- tions are rare in Italy and especially so in the provinces, and it has to be acknowledged that the great mass of the Mithraic monuments is of discouraging mediocrity. The hewers and *M. von Schneider, loc. cit.. Vol. II., p. 488, who sees in this composition ''ein verbli'iffetides tccJuiisches Gesc/u'ck," compares it with the rehef on the base of the Antonine column (Brunn, Denkmdicr gr. it. rom. Skulptur, PI. 210/^), and a bas- relief of the Campo Santo of Pisa (Diitschke, Bildwerke in Ober-Iialiett, I., No. 60), and the bust of Commodus in the Palais des Conservateurs (Helbig, Fuhrer, second ed. , No. 524). The same application of the technique of metal-work- ing to marble may be noticed in two admirably preserved busts which were discovered at Smyrna and are to-day to be found in the Museum at Brussels {Cat a/, des anfigj///ecs acqjiises par It's musees royaiix dcpnis Ic /'•<' Jafiv/er igoo, Bruxelles, 1901, Nos. iio-iii). MITHRAIC ART 21$ cutters of stone — they deserve no other name — who are responsible for these productions, were often content with roughly outlining by a few strokes of the chisel the scene which they pretended to reproduce. A garish color- ing then emphasized certain details. The work is sometimes so hastily executed that the contours alone are distinctly marked, as in the hieroglyphics. It sufficed, it is true, merely to outline representations, the meaning of which every faithful devotee knew and which he completed in imagination; and it is our ignorance that feels so vividly the imper- fections of these awkward and vague compo- sitions. Still, some of the smaller bas-reliefs could never have been more than downright caricatures bordering on the grotesque, and their deformities strongly remind us of the little toy gingerbread men which are sold at our fairs. The carelessness with which these tablets were executed is excused by their places of destination. The mystics of Mithra were wont not only to consecrate them in their temples, but also to adorn with them their modest dwelling-houses. This domestic consumption explains the enormous quantity of these monu- ments, which have been found wherever the cult penetrated. To satisfy the incessant demand of the faithful for these figures, the workshops in which they were carved must have produced them rapidly and in quantities. 2l6 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA The manufacturers of this brummagem sculp- ture had no other thought than that of cheaply satisfying their clientage of devotees, whose artistic tastes were far from exacting. The ancient manufacturers turned out hundreds of smaller tauroctonous Mithras,* just as our image-makers multiply in profusion the very same type of crucifixes and the very same Virgin Mary. It was the religious imagery of the epoch, and it was not more esthetic than is ours to-day. These manufacturers did not restrict them- selves to the unceasing production of replicas of the same traditional type; they sought to diversify their wares, in order to recommend them to all tastes and purses. Look only at the series of ex-votos found in the mithra^um of Sarmizegetusa in Dacia.f We find here specimens of all the models that the work- shops of the place reproduced. High reliefs, which are difficult and costly, are avoided. At most, the marble was perforated in places, so as to show forth the group of the taurocto- nous god. But what a wondrous variety in the small bas-reliefs which were affixed to the walls of the sanctuaries ! For a mere bagatelle square tablets could be obtained bearing only * The absence of machinery naturally excluded any absolute resemblance, but some of our bas-reliefs are certainlj' from the same hand or at least from the same workshop. Cf. T. rf J/., Vol. II., Mon. 45 and 46; Figs. 85 and 95, Fig. 87; 192 and 192 bt's; 194 and 195. f T. ct M., Vol. II., NoF. 13S to 1S3. MITHRAIC ART 217 the immolation of the bull. Sometimes its value is enhanced by the addition of a sort of predella, divided into three or four smaller scenes. Again, its composition is complicated by an upper panel decorated with accessory scenes. These, finally, also occupy the bor- ders of the monuments, and encompass on four sides the principal representation. Again, the fancy of the workman taking flight, the tauroc- tonous god has been enclosed in a circle orna- mented with the signs of the Zodiac, or in a crown of foliage. Frames were added or omitted. Considerable ingenuity was exer- cised to give new forms to the sculptured plaques. They were indiscriminately square, oblong, semicircular, trapezoidal, or even round. There are no two of these pieces which are exactly alike. If these commercial products of labor for hire have only the remotest relationship with art, they nevertheless furnish a valuable com- mentary upon the stone-hewing industry of antiquity. We have many proofs that a goodly portion of the sculptures intended for the provincial cities were executed during the imperial epoch at Rome.* This is probably the case with some of the monuments discov- ered in Gaul, and also for those which adorned a mithraeum in London. f On the other hand, certain statues discovered in the capital were * Friedlander, Sittengeschichte, Vol. III., p. 280. ■f- T. et M., Vol. II., Mon. 267 and the note on p. 390. 2l8 THE MYSTERIES OF MITHRA presumably imported from Asia Minor." The beautiful bas-reliefs of Virunum were likewise brought from abroad, probably by way of Aquileia. We know by the passion of the Four Crowned Ones the importance of the quarries of Pannonia in the third century,t where marble was not only quarried but worked. These stone-yards appear to have been an important center for the manufacture of Mithraic votive offerings. In any event, there are several of them, exhumed in the temples of Germany, which were unquestion- ably sculptured on the banks of the Danube. These facts cast an interesting light on the traffic in church ornaments during the days of paganism. Yet the majority of the Mithraic monuments were undoubtedly executed on the spot. The matter is clear for thc^e which were sculptured on the walls of natural rocks smoothed for the purpose, — they are unfortunately all greatly damaged, — but the proof of local manufacture for many others is also forcibly forthcoming from the nature of the stone employed. The construction of these fragments likewise * T. et Af., Vol. II., Mon. 235 and the note on p. 338. Cf. supra, p. 122, Fig. 26. f Wattenbach, Passio sanct, quatuor coronat., with the notes of Benndorf and Max BUdinger, 1870; cf. Friedlander, op. ctf.,'p. 282. A new text has been published by Watten- bach, Sif^tmgsb. Akad., Berlin, XLVII., 1S96, p. 1281