Credible Theories
Place · Historicity disputed

Jishi Gorge and the Yellow River

A Yellow River gorge where geologists proposed a dam-burst megaflood around 1920 BCE as the origin of China's Great Flood legend.

c. 1920 BCE
Location
Upper Yellow River, Qinghai–Gansu border
Modern country
China
Type
River gorge
Claimed event
Landslide-dam outburst flood, c. 1920 BCE
Proposed by
Wu Qinglong and colleagues, Science, 2016
Nearby site
Lajia (Qijia culture)

What are Jishi Gorge and the Yellow River known for?

Jishi Gorge is a narrow stretch of the upper Yellow River near the border of Qinghai and Gansu provinces in northwest China. Close by lies Lajia, a settlement of the Qijia culture that was buried by a disaster around 4,000 years ago; it is also famous for the oldest known noodles.

In 2016 a team led by Wu Qinglong published evidence in the journal Science that an earthquake caused a landslide to dam the gorge, and that the dam later burst, sending a huge flood down the river around 1920 BCE. They suggested this flood could lie behind the legend of the Great Flood tamed by Yu the Great, and the founding of the Xia dynasty.

Other researchers disputed the claim. Critics argued that the dating did not fit, that the Lajia destruction and the outburst did not coincide, and that the evidence for such a flood was weaker than presented. The link between Jishi Gorge and the Yu legend remains a hypothesis.

Why it is on Credible Theories

The Jishi Gorge flood is the proposed real-world event behind Yu the Great's flood.

Mentioned on these pages

Sources

  1. Wikipedia, 'Lajia'Reference
  2. Wu Qinglong et al., 'Outburst flood at 1920 BCE supports historicity of China's Great Flood and the Xia dynasty', Science 353 (2016)Primary text

Pictures on profile pages are drawn placeholders, not likenesses. Public-domain portraits and photographs will replace them.

Updated