Credible Theories Sign in
The evidence scale

How We Rate Evidence

Share

Every page says how well supported it is, so you can tell a public record from a legend at a glance.

1. Sources linked

Original texts and documents, one click away.

Sources and copyright
2. Scholars named

Every reading credited to a real person.

Source index
3. Evidence rated

Each page says how well supported it is, from Documented to Speculation.

How we rate evidence

Documented

Documented

Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.

The files rated Documented

Well supported

Well supported

Several independent lines of evidence agree, such as excavations, measurements or peer-reviewed studies. Experts still argue about details.

The files rated Well supported

Almost credible

Almost credible

Serious people have done real work and there is real evidence for the idea, but it falls short of proof. We show what supports it, what is missing and who disagrees.

The files rated Almost credible

Speculation

Speculation

An idea or reading that goes beyond what the evidence shows. We include it because people ask about it, and we mark it so it never gets mixed in with the record.

The files rated Speculation

Myth or legend

Myth or legend

The page covers something known from myths, scripture or tradition. The texts are real and we quote them, but no independent record shows the events or beings were real.

The files rated Myth or legend

How a page gets its label

The label describes what the main subject of the page rests on, not how interesting it is. A page is Documented only when the original record is public and linked. We move a page up or down when new evidence appears, and we say so on the page.

The track record meter

Some stories rest on one writer or one witness, like Atlantis, which comes only from Plato. For those we add a track record meter from 0 to 100: how often that source's factual claims have held up against archaeology, records and later scholarship. 0 to 19 is Mostly unreliable, 20 to 39 Often wrong, 40 to 59 Mixed record, 60 to 79 Mostly reliable and 80 to 100 Highly reliable. This rates how well the factual claims hold up against later evidence and scholarship. It is not a judgment of character or honesty. Each rating lists what checks out, what does not, and the sources behind it.

Strabo: 70/100, Mostly reliable

Alex Dietrich: 70/100, Mostly reliable

Berossus: 65/100, Mostly reliable

Flavius Josephus: 65/100, Mostly reliable

David Fravor: 65/100, Mostly reliable

Herodotus: 60/100, Mostly reliable

Manetho: 60/100, Mostly reliable

Ryan Graves: 60/100, Mostly reliable

Charles Halt: 55/100, Mixed record

Julius Obsequens: 50/100, Mixed record

Pliny the Elder: 45/100, Mixed record

David Grusch: 40/100, Mixed record

Plato: 25/100, Often wrong

Pat Price: 25/100, Often wrong

Graham Hancock: 20/100, Often wrong

Robert Temple: 15/100, Mostly unreliable

Ignatius Donnelly: 10/100, Mostly unreliable

Zecharia Sitchin: 5/100, Mostly unreliable

Erich von Däniken: 5/100, Mostly unreliable

Pandit Subbaraya Shastry: 5/100, Mostly unreliable

Doreal and the "Emerald Tablets of Thoth": 3/100, Mostly unreliable

Silas Newton: 3/100, Mostly unreliable

Nancy Lieder: 2/100, Mostly unreliable

Disagree with a label?

Tell us on the corrections page and include the source. Corrections that cite a source are reviewed first.

Updated

Discussion