How We Rate Evidence
Share
Every page says how well supported it is, so you can tell a public record from a legend at a glance.
Each page says how well supported it is, from Documented to Speculation.
How we rate evidenceDocumented
Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.
The files rated Documented
- The Book of Enoch: What Is It, and Why Isn't It in Most Bibles?
- 2 Enoch: What Did Enoch See in the Heavens?
- 3 Enoch: How Was Enoch Turned Into the Angel Metatron?
- The AARO Report: What the Pentagon Found in Its Own UFO History
- Abraham Lincoln's dream of his own death
- Amelia Earhart's disappearance
- Ancient Maps of Antarctica
- Antarctica Without Ice: The Real Map and the Old Maps
- Apocalypse of Abraham: Why Does Azazel Try to Stop His Ascent?
- Apollo 10 'outer-space music'
- Apollo 11: the object Aldrin saw
- Armies in the Clouds: Josephus' Sky Chariots Over Judea
- Atrahasis: The Epic Where Gods Made Humans, Then Sent the Flood
- Baalbek and its giant stones
- Beringia, the Bering land bridge
- Berossus: The Babylonian Who Explained His World to the Greeks
- The Book of Giants: The Nephilim Story Told by the Giants
- Book of Jasher: Is It the Lost Book the Bible Mentions?
- The Book of Jubilees: Genesis Retold by an Angel
- Bundahishn: What Does the Zoroastrian Creation Story Say?
- Cahokia, the city of mounds
- Cave of Treasures: A Human Answer to the Sons of God?
- Chichen Itza and the Castillo
- D. B. Cooper, the hijacker who jumped
- The Dead Sea Scrolls: What Was Found in the Caves at Qumran?
- Derinkuyu underground city
- El Dorado, the Gilded Man
- Emerald Tablet: Where Does "As Above, So Below" Come From?
- Enuma Elish: What the Babylonian Creation Story Says
- Eridu: The City Where Kingship First Came From Heaven
- Gemini 4: McDivitt's cylinder
- Gemini 7: the 'bogey at 10 o'clock high'
- Genesis Apocryphon: What Does This Dead Sea Scroll Add to Genesis?
- Giant skeletons in old American mounds
- Great Zimbabwe
- Greek Fire
- Harappa
- Hesiod's Five Ages of Man: Humanity Made and Unmade Five Times
- Kebra Nagast: How Did the Ark Reach Ethiopia?
- Knossos, the palace of the Labyrinth
- Book of Invasions: The Lebor Gabála Érenn Explained
- Legend of the Suns: The Aztec Story of Four Destroyed Worlds
- Life of Adam and Eve: What Happened After Eden?
- Livy's Ships in the Sky: Rome's Strange Sighting of 218 BCE
- Manetho: Why Did Egypt's First Historian Begin With Gods?
- Maya Long Count: The Calendar Behind the 2012 Myth
- MKUltra: What the CIA Admitted to the Senate in 1977
- Mohenjo-daro
- Mount Hermon: Where the Watchers Swore Their Oath
- Mycenae and the gold of Agamemnon
- Nag Hammadi Library: The Buried Gnostic Books Found in 1945
- Nan Madol, the city on the reef
- NASA's 2023 UAP Study: What the UFO Report Found
- Newgrange and the winter sunrise
- The 2021 UAP Report: 144 Sightings, One Balloon Explained
- Persepolis
- Petra, the Rose-Red City
- Pliny's Burning Shield: The Sparking Object Over Rome in 100 BCE
- Popol Vuh: The Maya Book Where Gods Made Humans Four Times
- What Was Project Blue Book? Inside the Air Force UFO Files
- Puma Punku
- Pyramid Texts: How Did Egypt's Kings Plan to Reach the Stars?
- Rendlesham Forest: What the Halt Memo Actually Says
- Samarangana Sutradhara: A Medieval Text's Secret Flying Machine
- Serpent Mound
- Shuruppak: The Flood Hero's City and Its Real Flood Layer
- Project Stargate: Did the CIA Really Pay for Psychic Spies?
- Sumerian King List: Why Did Early Kings Reign for Millennia?
- Tale of the Shipwrecked Sailor: What Did the Serpent Lose?
- Teotihuacan, where the gods were made
- Testament of Solomon: How Did Solomon Command Demons?
- The 1952 Washington UFO Sightings: What Did Radar See?
- The 1976 Tehran UFO Incident: What Happened to the F-4s?
- The 2023 UFO Hearing: What David Grusch Told Congress
- The Ħal Saflieni Hypogeum
- The Battle of Los Angeles (1942)
- The Colossus of Rhodes
- The Condon Report: Did Science Close the Book on UFOs?
- The curse of Tutankhamun
- The Easter Island statues (moai)
- The Face on Mars and the Cydonia Pyramids
- The FBI's ESP File: Could the Blind Read Without Eyes?
- The Great Sphinx of Giza
- The Hottel Memo: The FBI Vault's Most-Viewed UFO File
- The Hanging Gardens of Babylon
- The Library of Alexandria
- The Lighthouse of Alexandria (Pharos)
- The Lost Colony of Roanoke
- The Lubbock Lights (1951)
- Majestic 12: The Secret UFO Briefing the FBI Called Bogus
- The Mary Celeste ghost ship
- The Nazca lines
- The Olmec colossal heads
- The Oronteus Finaeus Map of 1531
- The Phaistos disc
- The Piri Reis Map of 1513
- The Princes in the Tower
- Plato's Statesman Myth: The Cosmos That Spun Backward
- The Richat Structure (Eye of the Sahara)
- The Robertson Panel: Why a CIA Panel Wanted to Debunk UFOs
- Lucullus and the Silver Jar: The Sky Object That Stopped a Battle
- The SRI Psychic Experiments: Puthoff, Targ and Uri Geller
- The Terracotta Army and the First Emperor's Tomb
- The Tic Tac UFO: The Nimitz Encounter and the Navy Videos
- The Valley of the Kings
- The Voynich manuscript
- The Walls of Jericho
- The Wow! signal
- Turin King List: Did Gods Rule Egypt Before the Pharaohs?
- Vaimanika Shastra: The 'Ancient' Aircraft Manual From the 1920s
- Voluspa: The Seeress Who Told Odin How the World Ends
Well supported
Several independent lines of evidence agree, such as excavations, measurements or peer-reviewed studies. Experts still argue about details.
The files rated Well supported
- Bronze Age Collapse: Why Did the Ancient World Fall Around 1200 BCE?
- Doggerland: The Real Lost Land Beneath the North Sea
- Göbekli Tepe: Who Built It 11,000 Years Ago, and Why?
- Helike: The Greek City Swallowed by the Sea in 373 BCE
- Libyan Desert Glass: How Did Impact Glass Reach Tutankhamun?
- Ötzi the Iceman
- STS-48: the 'zig-zag' video
- STS-75: the tether incident video
- Supernova of 1006: The New Star That Cast Shadows at Night
- The 1876 plot to steal Lincoln's body
- The 774 CE Event: A Radiation Spike and a Red Cross in the Sky
- The Dancing Plague of 1518
- The Dyatlov Pass incident
- 536 CE: The Year Without a Sun, and Why It Happened
- The Younger Dryas: What Caused the Big Freeze 12,900 Years Ago?
- Tunguska Event: The 1908 Siberian Blast That Left No Crater
- Vitrified Forts: The Hillforts With Walls Melted Into Glass
Almost credible
Serious people have done real work and there is real evidence for the idea, but it falls short of proof. We show what supports it, what is missing and who disagrees.
Speculation
An idea or reading that goes beyond what the evidence shows. We include it because people ask about it, and we mark it so it never gets mixed in with the record.
The files rated Speculation
- 9/11 and the questions about Building 7
- Agartha (Agharti)
- Charles Hapgood and Earth Crust Displacement
- Emerald Tablets of Thoth: Who Was Doreal, and Are They Real?
- Edgar Mitchell's UFO and ESP claims
- Gordon Cooper's UFO statements
- Lemuria, the continent of the lemurs
- Nibiru: Babylonian Star Name or Hidden Planet?
- The Cash-Landrum incident (Texas, 1980)
- The Falcon Lake burns (Canada, 1967)
- The JFK police recording and the 'probable conspiracy' finding
- The Villas Boas case (Brazil, 1957)
- Zecharia Sitchin: Where the Anunnaki Alien Theory Came From
Myth or legend
The page covers something known from myths, scripture or tradition. The texts are real and we quote them, but no independent record shows the events or beings were real.
The files rated Myth or legend
- Iram of the Pillars: What Happened to the People of 'Ad?
- Adapa: The Wise Man Who Turned Down Immortality
- Admiral Byrd, the polar flights and the 'hollow earth' diary
- Ahriman: Who Is Zoroastrianism's Destructive Spirit?
- The Anakim: Who Were the Giant Sons of Anak?
- Anu: Who Was the Sumerian God of the Sky?
- Anunnaki: Who Were the Great Gods of Sumer?
- Apkallu: Who Were the Seven Sages of Mesopotamia?
- Archons: The Gnostic Rulers Who Built the Human Body
- Ark of the Covenant: Where Did It Go, and Why Did It Kill?
- Asif ibn Barkhiya: Who Brought Sheba's Throne in a Blink?
- Atlantis: Is Plato's Sunken Island Real or a Myth?
- Atum: Why Did Egypt's Creator Promise to Destroy the World?
- Azazel: Scapegoat of Leviticus 16 or Fallen Watcher?
- Balor of the Evil Eye: The Fomorian With a Killing Gaze
- Bifrost: The Burning Bridge Between Earth and Asgard
- Brahmashira: Was the Mahabharata's Weapon an Ancient Nuke?
- Cherubim: What Did the Bible's Guardians Really Look Like?
- Dhul-Qarnayn: Who Was the Two-Horned One of Surah 18?
- Enki: Who Was the Sumerian God Who Saved Humanity?
- Enlil: Why Did the King of the Gods Send the Flood?
- Enoch: The Man Who Walked With God and Was Not
- Etana: The Shepherd King Who Rode an Eagle to Heaven
- Gadreel: The Fallen Angel Blamed for Eve and for War
- Gigantopithecus, the real giant ape
- Gilgamesh: Was the King of Uruk Real, and Why Is He a Giant?
- Ginnungagap: The Yawning Void Where Fire Met Ice
- Gog and Magog: Who Is Held Behind the Wall?
- Gonggong: The Water God Who Broke a Pillar of Heaven
- Harut and Marut: Who Were the Two Angels of Babylon?
- Helel ben Shahar: How Did Isaiah's Morning Star Become Lucifer?
- Heliodorus: Who Tried to Rob the Temple and Met a Shining Rider?
- Hephaestus' Golden Maidens: Artificial Helpers in the Iliad
- Hermes Trismegistus: Who Wrote the Hermetic Books?
- Humbaba: The Cedar Forest Guardian Gilgamesh Killed
- Hyperborea, the land beyond the north wind
- Iblis: Why Did He Refuse to Bow to Adam?
- Idris: Is the Quran's Prophet the Same as Enoch?
- Igigi: Why Did the Junior Gods Go on Strike?
- Inanna: The Goddess Who Stole the Powers of Civilization
- Jinn: What Does the Quran Say About Beings of Smokeless Fire?
- Kainam: Who Found the Watchers' Star Lore Carved on a Rock?
- Kakudmi and Revati: The Short Visit That Lasted Ages
- Kali Yuga: What Is the Dark Age of Hindu Cosmology?
- Lamech and Bitenosh: Why Did Noah's Father Fear a Watcher?
- Mahway, Ohyah and Hahyah: The Giants Who Dreamed of Doom
- Manu and Matsya: India's Flood Story and the Fish Who Saved Humanity
- Marduk: How Babylon's God Became King of the Gods
- Mastema: Who Bargained With God to Keep a Tenth of the Demons?
- Merkabah: Why Was Ezekiel's Chariot Too Dangerous to Teach?
- Metatron: Who Is the Angel Called the Lesser YHWH?
- Methuselah: How Old Was He, and What Did Enoch Leave Him?
- Nephilim: Who Were the Giants of Genesis 6?
- Nimrod: Who Was the Mighty Hunter Before the Lord?
- Ninurta: The Warrior God Who Put the Stones on Trial
- Norea: The Gnostic Heroine Who Burned Noah's Ark
- Nüwa: The Goddess Who Made Humans and Repaired the Sky
- Oannes: The Fish-Man Who Rose From the Sea to Teach
- Og of Bashan: How Big Was the Last of the Giants?
- Ophanim: What Was Ezekiel's Wheel in the Middle of a Wheel?
- People of the Cave: Who Were the Seven Sleepers?
- Pushpaka Vimana: Ravana's Flying Palace in the Ramayana
- Raphael: The Angel Who Heals, and Who Bound Azazel
- Rephaim: Were They Giants or the Ghosts of the Dead?
- Saubha: The Mahabharata's Flying City That Could Turn Invisible
- Seal of Solomon: How Did King Solomon's Ring Control Demons?
- Semjaza: Who Led the 200 Fallen Watchers?
- Seraphim: Who Are the Six-Winged Burning Ones of Isaiah 6?
- Sharur: The Oldest Talking Weapon in Literature?
- Skidbladnir: The Ship of the Gods That Folds Into a Pouch
- Solon and the Priests of Sais: "You Greeks Are Children"
- Talos: The Bronze Giant Who Guarded Crete
- Tartarus: From the Titans' Prison to 2 Peter's Fallen Angels
- The Bermuda Triangle
- The Black Knight satellite
- The Challenger crew 'still alive' claim
- The Cyclopes
- The Divine Council: Who Sat in God's Heavenly Assembly?
- Imperishable Stars: Why Did Egypt's Kings Aim North?
- The Prince of Persia: Who Held Back Daniel's Angel for 21 Days?
- The Qigong Flying Cart: A Flying Machine in Ancient Chinese Texts
- The Shroud of Turin
- The Spear of Destiny (the Holy Lance)
- The Watchers: Who Were the Fallen Angels of Enoch?
- 'There is a Santa Claus': the Christmas 'code' claim
- Thoth: Who Was the Egyptian God of Writing and Wisdom?
- Tiamat: The Primeval Sea Whose Body Became the World
- Tuatha Dé Danann: Who Were Ireland's Divine Race?
- Unas: Why Is This Small Pyramid So Important?
- Uriel: Who Is the Angel Who Taught Enoch the Stars?
- Utnapishtim: The Flood Hero Who Was Granted Eternal Life
- Utsuro-bune: The Hollow Ship That Washed Up in Japan in 1803
- Uzair: Who Slept a Hundred Years in Surah 2:259?
- Uzzah: Why Did Touching the Ark of the Covenant Kill Him?
- Yaldabaoth: The Gnostic Creator Who Thought He Was the Only God
- Yima and the Vara: An Ancient Shelter Against the Ice?
- Ymir: The First Giant and the Body That Became the World
- Yu the Great: The Engineer-King Who Tamed China's Great Flood
- Ziusudra: The Sumerian Noah Settled in Dilmun Forever
How a page gets its label
The label describes what the main subject of the page rests on, not how interesting it is. A page is Documented only when the original record is public and linked. We move a page up or down when new evidence appears, and we say so on the page.
The track record meter
Some stories rest on one writer or one witness, like Atlantis, which comes only from Plato. For those we add a track record meter from 0 to 100: how often that source's factual claims have held up against archaeology, records and later scholarship. 0 to 19 is Mostly unreliable, 20 to 39 Often wrong, 40 to 59 Mixed record, 60 to 79 Mostly reliable and 80 to 100 Highly reliable. This rates how well the factual claims hold up against later evidence and scholarship. It is not a judgment of character or honesty. Each rating lists what checks out, what does not, and the sources behind it.
Strabo: 70/100, Mostly reliable
Alex Dietrich: 70/100, Mostly reliable
Berossus: 65/100, Mostly reliable
Flavius Josephus: 65/100, Mostly reliable
David Fravor: 65/100, Mostly reliable
Herodotus: 60/100, Mostly reliable
Manetho: 60/100, Mostly reliable
Ryan Graves: 60/100, Mostly reliable
Charles Halt: 55/100, Mixed record
Julius Obsequens: 50/100, Mixed record
Pliny the Elder: 45/100, Mixed record
David Grusch: 40/100, Mixed record
Plato: 25/100, Often wrong
Pat Price: 25/100, Often wrong
Graham Hancock: 20/100, Often wrong
Robert Temple: 15/100, Mostly unreliable
Ignatius Donnelly: 10/100, Mostly unreliable
Zecharia Sitchin: 5/100, Mostly unreliable
Erich von Däniken: 5/100, Mostly unreliable
Pandit Subbaraya Shastry: 5/100, Mostly unreliable
Doreal and the "Emerald Tablets of Thoth": 3/100, Mostly unreliable
Silas Newton: 3/100, Mostly unreliable
Nancy Lieder: 2/100, Mostly unreliable
Disagree with a label?
Tell us on the corrections page and include the source. Corrections that cite a source are reviewed first.

Updated












