Credible Theories Sign in
Topic

Myths Checked: Famous Claims Tested Against the Real Documents

Famous claims checked against the actual documents. Sometimes the claim is wrong. Often the real record is stranger than the myth.

Often the popular claim is wrong but the real record is stranger. Nibiru really was a Babylonian name, and the Emerald Tablet really is a medieval alchemy text; the myths grew on top of them.

Pick a shelf

Files on this shelf (18)

Type:
Rating:
  • Ancient maps of Antarctica DocumentedThe four old maps said to show Antarctica before anyone saw it, Piri Reis 1513, Fine 1531, Mercator 1569 and Buache 1754, with what each one is and…
  • Antarctica without ice DocumentedWhat the land under Antarctica's ice really looks like on the 2025 Bedmap3 survey, and the old maps said to show the same coast before the ice.
  • Apollo 10 'outer-space music' DocumentedBehind the Moon and out of radio contact with Earth, the Apollo 10 crew heard a whistling sound they called 'outer-space-type music' and wondered…
  • Apollo 11: the object Aldrin saw DocumentedOn the way to the Moon, the Apollo 11 crew watched a bright object that looked like an open suitcase. In 2005 a TV program made it sound like a UFO…
  • Emerald Tablet DocumentedIn the oldest telling, the tablet is found in an underground chamber, held in the hands of an old man seated on a throne; its dozen or so lines…
  • The Face on Mars and the Cydonia pyramids DocumentedA mile-wide hill on Mars that looked like a human face in a 1976 NASA photo, and what four later spacecraft saw when they went back to look.
  • The Oronteus Finaeus map of 1531 DocumentedA French mathematician's 1531 world map with a great southern land around the pole, and the 1960s claim that it shows Antarctica's real coast…
  • The Piri Reis map of 1513 DocumentedAn Ottoman admiral's 1513 world map that says it copied a lost chart by Columbus, and the 1960s claim that its southern coast shows Antarctica…
  • Vaimanika Shastra DocumentedIts author said the whole text came to him through psychic contact with a sage who lived thousands of years earlier, yet it was dictated in the…
  • STS-48: the 'zig-zag' video Well supportedA camera on Space Shuttle Discovery filmed dots of light drifting over the Earth; after a flash, some of them suddenly changed direction.
  • STS-75: the tether incident video Well supportedAfter a 12-mile tether snapped and its satellite drifted away from Space Shuttle Columbia, a camera filmed dozens of glowing discs that seemed to…
  • Doreal and the "Emerald Tablets of Thoth" SpeculationA teacher who founded the Brotherhood of the White Temple in Denver said he found emerald tablets at the Great Pyramid in 1925, written by Thoth, a…
  • Nibiru SpeculationIn Babylon, Nibiru was a name of the god Marduk, who "upheld the paths" of the stars. In modern lore, it is a hidden planet that would knock the…
  • Zecharia Sitchin SpeculationA single 4,300-year-old cylinder seal in a Berlin museum, VA 243, became the most famous piece of evidence for one man's claim that Sumerian gods…
  • Atlantis Myth or legendPlato says a great island empire sank in a single day and night, and then his unfinished dialogue stops mid-sentence just as Zeus starts to speak…
  • The Black Knight satellite Myth or legendOnline legend says a 13,000-year-old alien satellite circles the Earth, and NASA photographed it in 1998. NASA's own photo catalog files that…
  • The Challenger crew 'still alive' claim Myth or legendA viral claim says the seven astronauts killed on Challenger in 1986 are still alive, because people with the same names and similar faces work in…
  • 'There is a Santa Claus': the Christmas 'code' claim Myth or legendWhen Apollo 8 came out from behind the Moon on Christmas Day 1968, Jim Lovell radioed 'Please be informed there is a Santa Claus.' Some UFO writers…

Features

What does this topic check?

Myths checked takes famous claims and holds them up against the actual documents. The planet Nibiru, the alien origin of the Sumerian gods, the Emerald Tablet's lost Atlantean authors, a satellite circling Earth for 13,000 years: each page quotes the claim, then the record it is supposed to rest on. Sometimes the claim is simply wrong. Often the real record is stranger than the myth.

How people see it

Scholars

  • MeasuredSpecialists. Language experts and historians who read the originals find the records do not say what the claims say. Our misquotes page lists the worst examples.

Alternative readings

  • ClaimClaim makers. Authors such as Zecharia Sitchin and Doreal presented their ideas as readings of ancient records.
Method
Find the original source a claim cites, quote it, and compare
Where claims come from
Popular books since the 1960s, television and viral posts
Common problem
Mistranslation, or a quote taken out of context

Speculation The claims checked here are speculation or worse; the records they are checked against are documented. How we rate evidence

Start here

  • Nibiru · In Babylon, a name of Marduk and a crossing point in the sky. In modern lore, a hidden planet always about…
  • Zecharia Sitchin · The author who turned the Anunnaki into gold-mining astronauts from Nibiru, and made Sumerian gods a global…
  • Emerald Tablet · A short, cryptic alchemical text attributed to Hermes: "That which is below is like that which is above."
  • The Black Knight satellite · Online legend says a 13,000-year-old alien satellite circles the Earth, and NASA photographed it in 1998…
  • Atlantis · Plato's island empire beyond the Pillars of Heracles, ruled by Poseidon's descendants, swallowed by the sea…
Sources for this overview
  1. WikipediaA free online encyclopedia written and edited by volunteers. It is a good starting point and usually lists its own sources, but anyone can change it, so we treat it as a guide to better sources, not the final word.Wikipedia, "Pseudoarchaeology"Reference
  2. WikipediaWikipedia, "Zecharia Sitchin"Reference Archived copy, 2026-10-03
  3. WikipediaWikipedia, "Nibiru cataclysm"Reference Archived copy, 2026-10-01

Questions people ask about Myths Checked

Is Nibiru real?

Nibiru is a real Babylonian word, meaning 'crossing', used for a celestial marker linked to the god Marduk, most often Jupiter. The hidden planet with a 3,600-year orbit is a modern idea from 1976. Astronomers note such a planet would be obvious, and the 3,600 figure comes from a Sumerian number unit.

Was Zecharia Sitchin right about the Anunnaki?

Specialists in cuneiform agree that Sitchin's translations are not supported by the languages or the texts. No Mesopotamian source describes gods mining gold or a twelfth planet. His 1976 book The 12th Planet still made the Anunnaki a global phenomenon.

Are the Emerald Tablets of Thoth ancient?

No. They were written in the 1930s by Doreal, an American occult teacher who claimed to have found and translated them. The older Emerald Tablet is a separate short alchemical text, 'that which is below is like that which is above', traced to Arabic sources of about 750 to 850 CE.

Other topics

Updated