Credible Theories Sign in

The record

After a wave of sightings in 1952, the CIA sponsored the Scientific Advisory Panel on Unidentified Flying Objects. It became known as the Robertson Panel after its chairman, Caltech physicist H. P. Robertson. The CIA describes it as a distinguished panel of nonmilitary scientists. Its members were Samuel Goudsmit, Luis Alvarez, Thornton Page and Lloyd Berkner, and CIA officer Frederick Durant served as secretary. The panel met in mid-January 1953 and reviewed Air Force case files and films.

The panel decided that most sightings had ordinary explanations. It concluded that the images on the Tremonton film, shot in Utah in 1952, were caused by sunlight reflecting off seagulls. Its report found no indication that these phenomena constitute a direct physical threat to national security. It warned, however, that continued emphasis on the reporting of these phenomena does, in these parlous times, result in a threat to the orderly functioning of the protective organs.

The best-remembered recommendation came next. In the words of a CIA history by Gerald K. Haines, the panel recommended that the National Security Council debunk UFO reports and institute a policy of public education to reassure the public of the lack of evidence behind UFOs. It suggested using the mass media, advertising, business clubs, schools, and even the Disney corporation to get the message across. It also recommended that private UFO groups in Los Angeles and Wisconsin be monitored for subversive activities.

The report stayed classified at first. After NICAP pressed for it in 1958, the Air Force released three summary paragraphs and the members' names, and a nearly complete version appeared in Saturday Review in 1966. Decades later, the Pentagon's UAP office noted that the panel had discussed the complete lack of the recovery of any 'hardware' from unexplained sightings. The detailed notes of the meetings by the panel's secretary, Frederick Durant, are cited throughout the CIA's own history of the episode.

Questions people ask about The Robertson Panel

Which famous scientists sat on the Robertson Panel?

Several members were leading physicists. Luis Alvarez went on to win the 1968 Nobel Prize in Physics. Samuel Goudsmit had co-discovered electron spin in 1925 and led the wartime Alsos mission that tracked German nuclear research. Lloyd Berkner helped launch the International Geophysical Year. The astronomer J. Allen Hynek presented to the panel but was not a full member.

What did the Robertson Panel conclude?

It judged that the reports posed no direct danger, but that a flood of them could clog military channels and let an enemy trigger false alarms. It urged security agencies to strip UFOs of their special status and the aura of mystery they had gained. The formal sessions ran for four days, starting on January 14, 1953.

What was the Tremonton UFO film?

It is a short color film shot on July 2, 1952, near Tremonton, Utah, by Navy Chief Warrant Officer Delbert C. Newhouse, a trained photographer. It shows a group of bright, shifting points of light. A Navy photo lab study could not identify them, but the Robertson Panel decided they were most likely birds and asked for film of seagulls to compare.

The open question

Still strange: The panel also recommended that private UFO groups in Los Angeles and Wisconsin be watched for subversive activities.

What Was Project Blue Book? Inside the Air Force UFO Files →
  1. Step 1 of 4 · This fileThe Robertson Panel
  2. Step 2 of 4 · Next fileWhat Was Project Blue Book? Inside the Air Force UFO Files
  3. Step 3 of 4 · Next fileThe 1952 Washington UFO Sightings: What Did Radar See?
  4. Step 4 of 4 · Next fileThe Condon Report: Did Science Close the Book on UFOs?
About these videos

Found by a YouTube search for this topic, not checked by us. The player loads from YouTube only when you press play.

Where this comes from

EvidenceDocumented

Comes from Gerald K. Haines, CIA's Role in the Study of UFOs, 1947-90, Studies in Intelligence, CIA…. An article by Gerald K. Haines, the CIA's chief historian, in the agency's journal Studies in Intelligence in 1997. Using CIA files, it traces the agency's interest in UFOs from 1947 to 1990 and says that many 1950s and 1960s sightings were secret US spy planes.

What this means

The original document is public and linked below.

For The Robertson Panel, the original record exists and is linked: Gerald K. Haines, CIA's Role in the Study of UFOs, 1947-90, Studies in Intelligence, CIA…. That tells you the record is real and what it says. It does not mean every claim in it is true.

Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.

See all five labels

Sources

  1. CIA's Role in the Study of UFOs, 1947-90An article by Gerald K. Haines, the CIA's chief historian, in the agency's journal Studies in Intelligence in 1997. Using CIA files, it traces the agency's interest in UFOs from 1947 to 1990 and says that many 1950s and 1960s sightings were secret US spy planes.Gerald K. Haines, CIA's Role in the Study of UFOs, 1947-90, Studies in Intelligence, CIA Center for the Study of IntelligencePrimary text Archived copy, 2026-09-27
  2. Central Intelligence Agency (CIA)The official website of the CIA, the US government's foreign intelligence agency. Its online Reading Room holds documents the agency has declassified, meaning released from secrecy.How to Investigate a Flying Saucer, Central Intelligence Agency, January 21, 2016Primary text Archived copy, 2026-09-23
  3. WikipediaA free online encyclopedia written and edited by volunteers. It is a good starting point and usually lists its own sources, but anyone can change it, so we treat it as a guide to better sources, not the final word.Robertson Panel, WikipediaReference Archived copy, 2026-09-18
  4. AARO Historical Record Report, Volume 1 (2024)A report published in March 2024 by AARO, the Pentagon office set up in 2022 to look into UFOs, now called UAP. It reviewed US government records since 1945 and found no evidence that the government ever recovered alien technology or that sightings were alien craft.Report on the Historical Record of U.S. Government Involvement with Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP), Volume I, AARO, February 2024 (official PDF, U.S. Department of Defense)Primary text Archived copy, 2026-09-03
  5. 'Pentagon releases sixth batch of declassified UFO files including video of swarm of objects over Utah in 1952', FOX 5 New York, September 18, 2026 (on the digitized 16mm Tremonton film released by the Department of War)Reference

Quotations come from public-domain translations. A book in our Library links to its Library page; other links open the free online copy or the reference page.

Updated

Credible or not?

Tap one to see how other readers voted.

Discussion