Credible Theories Sign in
Greece and Rome · Plutarch, Life of Lucullus 8.6

A silver jar falls between two armies, Plutarch, Life of Lucullus 8.6

Share

In plain words

This is a short passage from Plutarch's Lives, life stories of famous Greeks and Romans written around 100 CE. It describes an event in 73 BCE. The text says the sky burst open and a huge, flaming object fell between two armies. It was shaped like a wine jar and colored like melted silver. Plutarch reports it as an omen.

ReferencePlutarch, Life of Lucullus 8.6
Writtenc. 100 CE
Set73 BCE
The sky burst asunder, and a huge, flame-like body was seen to fall between the two armies. In shape, it was most like a wine-jar, and in colour, like molten silver.

Documented · Ancient text, c. 100 CE Translation: Perrin, 1914 · About the translator

Read it literally

Both armies stop fighting and go home. A landing that ends a battle.

What scholars say

Plutarch was a careful biographer; this is a reported omen.

Themes From the sky
People and places herePlutarch

Questions people ask about Plutarch, Life of Lucullus 8.6

Where is Plutarch's Life of Lucullus found?

It is one of Plutarch's Parallel Lives, a set of paired biographies of famous Greeks and Romans. Lucullus is paired with the Athenian general Cimon. The Loeb translation by Bernadotte Perrin is free online on Bill Thayer's LacusCurtius website at the University of Chicago, along with the Greek text.

When did Plutarch write about Lucullus?

Plutarch lived from about 46 to after 119 CE and wrote the Lives late in his career, around 100 CE. The event he describes took place in 73 BCE, near a place called Otryae in Phrygia, during the Third Mithridatic War between Rome and King Mithridates VI of Pontus. So he was writing about 170 years after the fact.

What was the flaming object Plutarch described?

Most modern readers take it as a large fireball, a bright meteor that can glow silver and seem to break apart with a loud boom. Plutarch does not say where he got the story, and he treats it as a sign from the gods. UFO writers sometimes list it as an ancient sighting, but the text offers no detail beyond the shape and color.

Used on these files

  • Lucullus and the Silver Jar: The Sky Object That Stopped a Battle DocumentedTwo armies in Phrygia were about to clash when, Plutarch says, the sky burst apart and a flaming object shaped like a wine jar and colored like molten silver fell between them. Both sides drew back, and no battle took place. Was it an omen, a meteor or something else? Plutarch wrote it down long afterward.

Where this comes from

EvidenceDocumented

Comes from Plutarch's Lives, Plutarch, Life of Lucullus 8.6, read here in the Bernadotte Perrin. Life stories of famous Greeks and Romans written by Plutarch, a Greek writer and priest at Delphi, around AD 100 to 120. They are full of personal detail and anecdotes, not all of them checked.

What this means

The text exists and is quoted from a published translation. What it describes is a separate question.

Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.

See all five labels

Sources

  1. LacusCurtiusLacusCurtius, a website of Greek and Roman texts and translations, many from the Loeb Classical Library, put online and carefully proofread by Bill Thayer and hosted on a University of Chicago server.Bernadotte Perrin, Plutarch's Lives, vol. 2 (Loeb, 1914) Online copyPrimary text
  2. Plutarch's LivesLife stories of famous Greeks and Romans written by Plutarch, a Greek writer and priest at Delphi, around AD 100 to 120. They are full of personal detail and anecdotes, not all of them checked. Bernadotte Perrin's English version came out from 1914.Plutarch, Life of Lucullus 8.5–6, trans. Bernadotte Perrin (1914)Primary text

Scholarly dates are rounded. The wording follows the named public-domain translation.

More from Greece and Rome

The story before and after this one, and what each shares with A silver jar falls between two armies.

Photo credits
‹ Before thisThe burning shieldPliny the Elder, Natural History 2.34

It reports that in 100 BCE a burning shield, throwing off sparks, was seen racing across the sky at sunset, from west to east.

Same theme: From the sky
Photo credits
Next ›Chariots in the clouds over JudeaJosephus, Jewish War 6.5.3

It describes a sign seen in 66 CE, before the fall of Jerusalem.

Same theme: From the sky

Updated

Discussion