Credible Theories Sign in
Shared story points

Horus and Jesus: Virgin Birth, December 25 and 12 Disciples in the Sources

Share

A comparison first set out in Gerald Massey's 1907 book, and repeated in the 2007 film Zeitgeist, says Horus was born of a virgin on December 25, had twelve disciples, walked on water, was crucified and rose after three days. Here is what each source says, and where each detail is first written down.

In plain words

Horus is the falcon-headed Egyptian sky god, son of Isis and Osiris, worshipped for about three thousand years. The Egyptian story shares several points with the Jesus story: a miraculous conception, a birth that Plutarch places at the winter solstice, and a mother and child pictured much like Mary and Jesus. Other points in the comparison, such as the twelve disciples and the crucifixion, are first found in Gerald Massey's 1907 book. Each point is shown below with its source.

Where these comparisons appear

  • Peter Joseph, in the film Zeitgeist (2007): The film's first part lists Horus, Mithras, Krishna, Attis and Dionysus as gods with the Jesus life story: a virgin birth on December 25, twelve disciples, miracles, crucifixion and resurrection after three days.
  • Bill Maher, in the film Religulous (2008): Says the Book of the Dead describes Horus, 'born to a virgin', baptized by 'Anup the Baptizer', who walked on water, had twelve disciples and was crucified.
  • Gerald Massey, Ancient Egypt: The Light of the World (1907): An English poet and writer on Egypt who compared the Gospel story with the Egyptian stories in detail. Many Horus points in later comparisons (twelve followers, 'Anup the baptizer', walking on water) first appear in his book.

Each story point and its source

Told differently

The story point: Horus was born of a virgin.

What the sources say: Plutarch, the fullest ancient telling, says Isis conceived the child Horus with Osiris after Osiris had died. It is a miraculous conception; Egyptian texts call Isis a wife and mother rather than a virgin.

From the text
Isis had also by Osiris, who accompanied with her after his decease, Harpocrates, who came into the world before his time and was lame in his lower parts.
Isis and Osiris 19 · Translation: William W. Goodwin (ed.), Plutarch's Morals vol. IV, 1878
Similar in the ancient texts

The story point: Horus was born on December 25.

What the sources say: Plutarch says Isis gave birth to Harpocrates (the child Horus) about the winter solstice, which the Roman calendar of his day placed on December 25. The Egyptian calendar itself had no December.

From the text
Isis is reported, upon her finding herself to be with child, to have hung a certain amulet or charm about her upon the sixth day of the month Phaophi, and to have been delivered of Harpocrates about the winter solstice
Isis and Osiris 65 · Translation: William W. Goodwin (ed.), Plutarch's Morals vol. IV, 1878
First written in a modern book

The story point: Horus had twelve disciples.

What the sources say: The surviving Egyptian texts give Horus four sons, gods who guard the organs of the dead. A group of twelve around Horus is first found in Gerald Massey (1907), who linked it to twelve harvesters in a Book of the Dead field scene and to the twelve signs of the zodiac.

From the text
At a later stage the followers in the train of Horus are the twelve who are his harvesters in the cornfields of Amenta. ... The disciples of Jesus likewise become the twelve who reap the harvest.
'The Founders of the Kingdom', vol. II p. 864 (a modern book) · Translation: Gerald Massey, Ancient Egypt: The Light of the World, 1907
First written in a modern book

The story point: Horus walked on water.

What the sources say: The surviving Egyptian texts do not include this detail; it is first found in Massey (1907), who compared it to a god who 'rises unwetted from the water to rest upon the deck of the bark'. Healing stones called cippi show the child Horus standing on crocodiles in the water.

First written in a modern book

The story point: Horus was baptized by 'Anup the Baptizer', who was later beheaded.

What the sources say: Anup is Anubis, the jackal god of embalming. Egyptian religion had purification with water. The title 'Anup the baptizer' is first found in Massey (1907), who paired Anubis with John the Baptist.

From the text
In the Gospel, when Jesus cometh 'unto John' = Anup the baptizer, 'John would have hindered him.'
'Jesus Christ', vol. II p. 795 (a modern book) · Translation: Gerald Massey, Ancient Egypt: The Light of the World, 1907
First written in a modern book

The story point: Horus was crucified and rose after three days.

What the sources say: In the surviving Egyptian texts it is Horus's father Osiris who dies and is revived, after being shut in a chest and cut apart. A crucified Horus is first found in 19th-century books; Massey himself wrote that Horus was not pictured on a cross.

From the text
affirming that Osiris is then buried when the sown corn is covered over by the earth, and that he revives again and re-appears when it begins to sprout.
Isis and Osiris 65 · Translation: William W. Goodwin (ed.), Plutarch's Morals vol. IV, 1878
Found in the ancient texts

The story point: Isis nursing Horus looks like Mary holding the baby Jesus.

What the sources say: Statues and paintings of Isis seated with the infant Horus on her lap (Isis lactans) were common across the Roman Empire. Many art historians see them as a model for early pictures of Mary holding Jesus.

The shared points in the ancient texts

Three shared points come straight from the ancient sources: a god conceived in a miraculous way, a child-god whose birth Plutarch places at the winter solstice, and the image of Isis holding the infant Horus, common in the Roman world when Christian art began. The death and return in the Egyptian story belongs to Osiris, who lives on as king of the dead.

The same story in other traditions

Where this comes from

EvidenceDocumented

Comes from Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris, in Plutarch's Morals vol. IV, ed. William W. Goodwin (1878). On Isis and Osiris, by Plutarch: An essay by the Greek writer Plutarch, written around AD 100 to 120, explaining the Egyptian myth of Isis and Osiris and comparing it with Greek and Persian beliefs. It is one of the fullest ancient tellings of the Osiris story.

What this means

The Egyptian and Greek texts quoted here exist and say what is quoted. Points first found in Gerald Massey's 1907 book are marked as such.

Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.

See all five labels

Sources

  1. On Isis and Osiris, by PlutarchAn essay by the Greek writer Plutarch, written around AD 100 to 120, explaining the Egyptian myth of Isis and Osiris and comparing it with Greek and Persian beliefs. It is one of the fullest ancient tellings of the Osiris story.Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris, in Plutarch's Morals vol. IV, ed. William W. Goodwin (1878)Primary text
  2. Internet ArchiveA nonprofit digital library in San Francisco, founded in 1996, that holds millions of scanned books, papers and recordings. A scan there shows the pages of a real printed book or document.Gerald Massey, Ancient Egypt: The Light of the World (1907)Primary text
  3. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 'Magical Stela with Horus the Child' (Metternich Stela), 360-343 BCE, accession 50.85Primary text

More shared story points

Updated

Discussion