How the rabbit hole works. Start with anything that grabs you, say UFOs. Every person, place and document a page mentions links to its own page, so a UFO file leads to a witness, the witness leads to the people who investigated the case, and it keeps going.
The path you take shows in the bar under the top menu on every page, so you can step back any time or climb out and start again.
Jesus is not the only hero said to be born of a maiden and a god. Rome, India, Greece and Persia tell it too, and Egypt and India tell the births of Horus and Krishna in their own ways.
9 tellings · 4 parts of the world · written down c. 740-700 BCE to 9th century CE
Matthew and Luke say Mary conceived Jesus while still a virgin, by the Holy Spirit. Many older and later stories also give a hero a divine father and a mother who had not been with a man. Rome's founder Romulus was born to a Vestal priestess sworn to stay a virgin, with the war god Mars named as father. In the Mahabharata the unmarried princess Kunti bears Karna to the Sun god, who then gives her back her maidenhood. In Greece, Zeus reaches the locked-away Danae as a shower of gold and she bears Perseus. In Persian tradition the last savior, Saoshyant, is to be born from the prophet Zoroaster's seed kept in a lake.
Two names that often appear on lists of virgin-born gods do not fit when you read their own texts. Horus was conceived by Isis with the dead Osiris, and Krishna was the eighth son of a married couple, Devaki and Vasudeva. The Buddha's mother was a married queen. Each version below is quoted from a public-domain translation with a link to read it in full.
The open question: Why do so many traditions give their great figures a birth unlike anyone else's? A shared pattern, or each people's own way of saying "this one is special"? Join the debate
Same and different: Matthew quotes this verse. The Hebrew word is almah, 'young woman'; the Greek Septuagint translated it parthenos, 'virgin'. In Isaiah the sign is about a child born in King Ahaz's own day.
Same and different: Same: an unmarried maiden, a god as father, her virginity said to remain. Different: the god is the Sun, the boy is set adrift in a basket on a river (like Moses and Sargon), and he grows up to fight on the losing side.
3 of 9 · Greek
Apollodorus, The Library (Danae and Perseus)
Documented · Ancient text, c. 1st-2nd century CE
Where
Argos, Greece
When
The Library compiled c. 1st-2nd century CE from much older myths
From the text
some say that Zeus had intercourse with her in the shape of a stream of gold which poured through the roof into Danae's lap. When Acrisius afterwards learned that she had got a child Perseus, he would not believe that she had been seduced by Zeus
Same and different: Same: a locked-away maiden, a god as father, a jealous king. Different: the mother and baby are cast into the sea in a chest, and the son later kills the king by accident.
Written in Greek, probably in Syria or Galilee; set in Bethlehem and Nazareth
When
Written c. 80-90 CE (Matthew) and c. 85-95 CE (Luke)
From the text
Now the birth of Jesus Christ was on this wise: When as his mother Mary was espoused to Joseph, before they came together, she was found with child of the Holy Ghost.
Same and different: The model for the comparison: a betrothed young woman, no human father, a divine conception announced by an angel. Luke adds Mary's question: 'How shall this be, seeing I know not a man?'
Plutarch wrote c. 100 CE; the legend is older (Livy, c. 27 BCE)
From the text
made her a priestess of Vesta, bound to live unwedded and a virgin all her days. Her name is variously given as Ilia, or Rhea, or Silvia. Not long after this, she was discovered to be with child, contrary to the established law for the Vestals.
Same and different: Same: a sworn virgin, a god (Mars) named as father, and a king who orders the babies killed. Different: Plutarch himself reports that some said a human man was the father.
Buddhacarita (Fo-sho-hing-tsan-king), the birth of the Buddha
Documented · Ancient text, c. 100 CE
Where
Lumbini, Nepal (written in India, translated into Chinese)
When
Composed by Ashvaghosha c. 100 CE; Chinese version c. 420 CE
From the text
Whilst she (thus) religiously observed the rules of a pure discipline, Bodhisattva was born from her right side, (come) to deliver the world, constrained by great pity, without causing his mother pain or anguish.
Same and different: Same: a pure mother, a spirit descending into her womb, a child born 'to deliver the world'. Different: Queen Maya is married to King Suddhodana, the birth is from her side, and in other Buddhist texts the conception comes in a dream of a white elephant.
7 of 9 · Egyptian
Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris (the birth of Harpocrates, the child Horus)
Documented · Ancient text, c. 100 CE
Where
Egypt (written by a Greek priest at Delphi)
When
Plutarch wrote c. 100 CE; the Isis and Osiris myth goes back to the Pyramid Texts, c. 2400 BCE
From the text
Isis had also by Osiris, who accompanied with her after his decease, Harpocrates, who came into the world before his time and was lame in his lower parts.
Same and different: Often listed as a virgin birth, but the texts say the opposite: Isis conceives with her husband Osiris after his death. It is a miraculous birth, not a virgin one. See our page on the Horus claims.
Composed in the first millennium CE (often dated c. 400-900 CE); Krishna worship is older
From the text
The Muni Narada informed Kansa that the supporter of the earth, Vishnu, would be the eighth child of Devaki; and his wrath being excited by this report, he placed both Vasudeva and Devaki in confinement. Agreeably to his promise, the former delivered to Kansa each infant as soon as it was born.
Same and different: Often listed as a virgin birth, but Devaki is married and Krishna is her eighth child. What is close to the Gospels is the tyrant king who kills babies to stop a prophesied child, like Herod in Matthew 2. See our page on the Krishna claims.
Bundahishn (the seed of Zoroaster kept for the last saviors)
Documented · Medieval text, 9th century CE
Where
Iran
When
Written down in Middle Persian in the 9th century CE from older tradition
From the text
Zaratust went near unto Hvov three times, and each time the seed went to the ground; the angel Neryosang received the brilliance and strength of that seed, delivered it with care to the angel Anahid, and in time will blend it with a mother.
Same and different: In the fuller tradition (Dinkard book 7) a young maiden bathes in a lake, conceives from this seed, and bears the savior. Same: a virgin mother and a world savior. Different: the father is the human prophet Zoroaster, and the births come at the end of time.
Why are these stories so alike?
Historians of religion group these as 'divine birth' stories, which were common in the ancient Mediterranean world: Greek and Roman writers gave heroes, kings and even philosophers (Alexander, Augustus, Plato in some accounts) a god for a father. Scholars disagree on how much this background shaped the Gospels. Many see Matthew and Luke drawing mainly on Jewish scripture, chiefly the Greek wording of Isaiah 7:14, while others argue Greco-Roman readers would have heard the story against their own hero births. One difference most agree on: in the Greek and Roman stories the god physically couples with the woman, while Matthew and Luke describe no union at all. The comparisons that call Horus, Krishna and Mithras virgin-born are first found in 19th-century writers such as Kersey Graves; the oldest texts tell those births in their own ways.
Where do you land?
Why do so many traditions give their great figures a birth unlike anyone else's? A shared pattern, or each people's own way of saying "this one is special"?
Every text quoted here exists and says what is quoted. Whether any of these births happened is a matter of faith or legend; whether the Gospels borrowed from the others is debated by scholars.
Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.
Raymond E. Brown, The Birth of the Messiah (Doubleday, 1977; updated 1993)Reference
WikipediaA free online encyclopedia written and edited by volunteers. It is a good starting point and usually lists its own sources, but anyone can change it, so we treat it as a guide to better sources, not the final word.Wikipedia, 'Miraculous births' (survey with scholarly citations)Reference