Credible Theories Sign in
Shared story points

Krishna and Jesus: Carpenter, Virgin Birth, Baptism and Ascension in the Sources

Share

A comparison going back to Kersey Graves's 1875 book, and repeated in the 2007 film Zeitgeist, says Krishna was a carpenter, born to a virgin, baptized in a river, rose from the dead and ascended into heaven. Here is what the Hindu texts say on each point.

In plain words

Krishna is one of the most loved gods in Hinduism, worshipped as an incarnation of Vishnu. His story is told in the Mahabharata, the Harivamsa and the Puranas, and Krishna worship is older than Christianity. The Hindu texts share two strong points with the Jesus story: a king who kills infants to stop a prophesied child, and a rise to heaven at the end of his life on earth. They tell the birth, the river crossing and the death in their own way. Each point is shown below with its source.

Where these comparisons appear

  • Bill Maher, in the film Religulous (2008): At the Holy Land Experience in Orlando he tells an actor playing Jesus that Krishna 'was a carpenter, born of a virgin, baptized in a river', and that Mithra, '600 years before Christ', was born December 25, performed miracles and rose on the third day.
  • Kersey Graves, The World's Sixteen Crucified Saviors (1875): The book many later comparisons draw on. Graves names sixteen 'crucified saviors', including Krishna and Mithras.
  • Peter Joseph, in the film Zeitgeist (2007): The film's first part lists Horus, Mithras, Krishna, Attis and Dionysus as gods with the Jesus life story: a virgin birth on December 25, twelve disciples, miracles, crucifixion and resurrection after three days.

Each story point and its source

Similar in the ancient texts

The story point: Krishna lived about 1,000 years before Christ.

What the sources say: Krishna worship is older than Christianity. The Chandogya Upanishad, usually dated around the 6th century BCE, names a Krishna son of Devaki, and the Heliodorus pillar at Vidisha (c. 110 BCE) honors Vasudeva. Hindu tradition places Krishna's life around 3100 BCE. The full birth story is written in the Mahabharata (400 BCE-400 CE) and the Vishnu Purana (first millennium CE).

From the text
Ghora Angirasa, after having communicated this (view of the sacrifice) to Krishna, the son of Devaki
Chandogya Upanishad 3.17.6 · Translation: F. Max Müller, The Upanishads Part I (Sacred Books of the East 1), 1879
First written in a modern book

The story point: Krishna was a carpenter.

What the sources say: In the Hindu texts Krishna is born to a royal family and grows up among cowherds as the foster son of Nanda. The carpenter detail is first found in Kersey Graves (1875), who wrote it of Krishna's father. Mark 6:3 calls Jesus 'the carpenter'.

From the text
16. The father of Chrishna, as well as that of Christ, was a carpenter.
Chapter XXXII, the list of 346 'analogies' (a modern book) · Translation: Kersey Graves, The World's Sixteen Crucified Saviors, 1875
Told differently

The story point: Krishna was born to a virgin.

What the sources say: The texts say Vishnu entered the womb of Devaki, wife of Vasudeva, and Krishna was her eighth son: a divine birth to a married mother. Graves (1875) named Krishna's foster mother Yasoda as a virgin; the Vishnu Purana says she had just given birth to a daughter.

From the text
The Muni Narada informed Kansa that the supporter of the earth, Vishnu, would be the eighth child of Devaki; and his wrath being excited by this report, he placed both Vasudeva and Devaki in confinement. Agreeably to his promise, the former delivered to Kansa each infant as soon as it was born.
Vishnu Purana, Book V, chapter 1 · Translation: H. H. Wilson, The Vishnu Purana, 1840
Told differently

The story point: Krishna was baptized in a river.

What the sources say: As a newborn Krishna is carried across the flooded Yamuna river by his father to escape King Kamsa, and the waters are stilled. As a boy he subdues the serpent Kaliya in the river. A baptism is first found in modern books.

Found in the ancient texts

The story point: A king killed the babies to reach him.

What the sources say: King Kamsa, warned that Devaki's eighth child would kill him, kills her children, and the baby Krishna is carried to safety, much like Herod and the children of Bethlehem in Matthew 2. The Puranas that tell it in full were written in the same centuries as the Gospels or after.

Told differently

The story point: Krishna rose from the dead.

What the sources say: The Mahabharata says a hunter named Jara shot Krishna in the heel while he sat in meditation, and Krishna left his body and rose to heaven. A return to life on earth is not part of the text.

From the text
The hunter, mistaking Keshava, who was stretched on the earth in high Yoga, for a deer, pierced him at the heel with a shaft and quickly came to that spot for capturing his prey.
Mausala Parva, Section 4 · Translation: Kisari Mohan Ganguli, The Mahabharata, 1883-1896
Found in the ancient texts

The story point: Krishna ascended into heaven.

What the sources say: Right after his death the Mahabharata says Krishna rose upward in light and was welcomed into heaven by the gods.

From the text
The high-souled one comforted him and then ascended upwards, filling the entire welkin with splendour.
Mausala Parva, Section 4 · Translation: Kisari Mohan Ganguli, The Mahabharata, 1883-1896

The shared points in the ancient texts

Two shared points come straight from the texts: a tyrant king who kills infants to stop a prophesied child (Kamsa and Herod), and a divine figure who rises into heaven in light at the end of his life on earth. Scholars since the 1800s have discussed whether the stories met; many now see them as growing up separately, since the Krishna birth story took its full written form in India in the same centuries the Gospels were written around the Mediterranean.

The same story in other traditions

Where this comes from

EvidenceDocumented

Comes from The Mahabharata, Mausala Parva, trans. Kisari Mohan Ganguli (1883-1896). One of the two great Sanskrit epics of India, about a war between two branches of a royal family. With about 100,000 verses it is one of the longest poems ever made.

What this means

The Hindu texts quoted here exist and say what is quoted. The carpenter point is first found in Kersey Graves (1875) and is marked as such.

Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.

See all five labels

Sources

  1. The MahabharataOne of the two great Sanskrit epics of India, about a war between two branches of a royal family. With about 100,000 verses it is one of the longest poems ever made. It was mostly put together between about 300 BC and AD 300. Kisari Mohan Ganguli made the first full English version, 1883 to 1896.The Mahabharata, Mausala Parva, trans. Kisari Mohan Ganguli (1883-1896)Primary text
  2. The Vishnu PuranaA Sanskrit book of Hindu stories and teaching about the god Vishnu, the making of the world and its long cycles of ages. Scholars date it roughly to the first thousand years AD. H. H. Wilson published the first English translation in 1840.The Vishnu Purana, trans. H. H. Wilson (1840)Primary text
  3. Internet ArchiveA nonprofit digital library in San Francisco, founded in 1996, that holds millions of scanned books, papers and recordings. A scan there shows the pages of a real printed book or document.The Upanishads Part I, trans. F. Max Müller (Sacred Books of the East 1, 1879)Primary text
  4. Project GutenbergThe oldest digital library, started in 1971, with more than 70,000 free e-books whose copyright has run out. Volunteers type and check the texts against printed editions.Kersey Graves, The World's Sixteen Crucified Saviors (1875)Primary text
  5. Internet ArchiveArchaeological Survey of India, Annual Report 1908-09, 'The Garuda Pillar of Besnagar' (the Heliodorus inscription to Vasudeva, c. 110 BCE)Primary text

More shared story points

Updated

Discussion