How the rabbit hole works. Start with anything that grabs you, say UFOs. Every person, place and document a page mentions links to its own page, so a UFO file leads to a witness, the witness leads to the people who investigated the case, and it keeps going.
The path you take shows in the bar under the top menu on every page, so you can step back any time or climb out and start again.
The shortest day of the year, when the light starts to come back, was marked as a birthday in Rome, Egypt and Syria, and Christians in Rome chose it for Christmas. The sources side by side.
6 tellings · 4 parts of the world · written down c. 77 CE to 1922
In the Roman calendar the winter solstice fell on December 25. Pliny the Elder puts the start of winter on that day. Rome's calendar for the year 354 marks it as the birthday of the Unconquered, the sun god Sol, with thirty chariot races, and the same book holds the oldest record of Christians in Rome keeping December 25 as the birth of Christ. Plutarch says the Egyptians placed the birth of the child Horus at the winter solstice.
James Frazer gathered reports that in Syria and Egypt worshippers came out of their shrines at midnight on the solstice crying that the Virgin had given birth and the light was growing. The Gospels themselves give no date for the birth of Jesus. Each source is quoted below with a link to read it in full.
The open question: Was the birth date chosen for the solstice, worked out from other dates, or both? The early sources point more than one way, so which do you think? Join the debate
Same and different: The eighth day before the Kalends of January is December 25. This is why the solstice and December 25 go together in Roman sources.
Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris (the birth of Harpocrates)
Documented · Ancient text, c. 100 CE
Where
Egypt (written by a Greek priest at Delphi)
When
Plutarch wrote c. 100 CE
From the text
Isis is reported, upon her finding herself to be with child, to have hung a certain amulet or charm about her upon the sixth day of the month Phaophi, and to have been delivered of Harpocrates about the winter solstice
Same and different: The child Horus, born at the solstice, 'very imperfect and tender' like the first shoots. Plutarch also reports a festival of the birth after the spring equinox.
Same and different: The oldest record of Christmas on December 25. Eastern churches first kept January 6. Scholars discuss whether the date matched the sun's birthday or was counted from March 25.
Same and different: The birthday of Sol, the Unconquered Sun. Some scholars date this feast to Emperor Aurelian in 274 CE; others date it later.
6 of 6 · Syrian and Egyptian
The midnight cry at the solstice, as reported by James Frazer
Documented · Modern book, 1922
Where
Syria and Egypt
When
Rite of the Roman era; Frazer wrote in 1922
From the text
The celebrants retired into certain inner shrines, from which at midnight they issued with a loud cry, "The Virgin has brought forth! The light is waxing!"
Same and different: Frazer draws on a Byzantine Greek commentator writing about older rites. A virgin, a birth at midnight and the return of light all meet in one rite.
Why are these stories so alike?
The winter solstice is the turning point of the sun's year, and many cultures marked it with feasts of light and rebirth. In Rome it fell on December 25. Two main explanations are given for the Christmas date. One holds that Christians in Rome chose the sun's birthday and gave it a Christian meaning, since Christ was called the 'sun of righteousness'. The other holds that early Christians counted nine months from March 25, the date they gave to his conception, and reached December 25 on their own. Both views are argued by scholars today, and Andrew McGowan sets them out side by side.
Where do you land?
Was the birth date chosen for the solstice, worked out from other dates, or both? The early sources point more than one way, so which do you think?
Every text quoted here exists and says what is quoted. Why Christmas fell on December 25 is discussed by scholars, with two main explanations.
Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.