Credible Theories Sign in
Shared story points

Mithras and Jesus: Miracles, a Mark on the Forehead and December 25 in the Sources

Share

A comparison repeated in Kersey Graves's 1875 book and the 2007 film Zeitgeist says Mithras was born of a virgin on December 25, performed miracles, had twelve disciples, was marked by the sign of the cross and rose on the third day. Here is what each source says.

In plain words

Mithras was the god of a Roman mystery cult for men, popular with soldiers from about 80 to 400 CE, the same years Christianity was spreading. His followers met in cave-like halls under a carved scene of Mithras killing a bull. The cult left almost no writings of its own, so it is known from carvings, inscriptions and Christian writers. Those writers point out shared practices: a sacred meal of bread and a cup, and a mark on the forehead. Each point on the popular lists is shown below with its source.

Where these comparisons appear

  • Bill Maher, in the film Religulous (2008): At the Holy Land Experience in Orlando he tells an actor playing Jesus that Krishna 'was a carpenter, born of a virgin, baptized in a river', and that Mithra, '600 years before Christ', was born December 25, performed miracles and rose on the third day.
  • Peter Joseph, in the film Zeitgeist (2007): The film's first part lists Horus, Mithras, Krishna, Attis and Dionysus as gods with the Jesus life story: a virgin birth on December 25, twelve disciples, miracles, crucifixion and resurrection after three days.
  • Kersey Graves, The World's Sixteen Crucified Saviors (1875): The book many later comparisons draw on. Graves names sixteen 'crucified saviors', including Krishna and Mithras.

Each story point and its source

Similar in the ancient texts

The story point: Mithras lived 600 years before Christ.

What the sources say: An older Persian god, Mithra, is praised in the Avesta hymns as a god of contracts and light. The Roman Mithras of the rites and the bull scene is first seen around 80-100 CE. Scholars discuss how much the Roman cult drew from Persia.

Told differently

The story point: Mithras was born of a virgin.

What the sources say: The Roman sources say Mithras was born from a rock, fully grown, with no mother. Carvings show him rising from the stone holding a dagger and a torch.

From the text
And when those who record the mysteries of Mithras say that he was begotten of a rock, and call the place where those who believe in him are initiated a cave, do I not perceive here that the utterance of Daniel, that a stone without hands was cut out of a great mountain, has been imitated by them
Dialogue with Trypho, chapter 70 · Translation: Alexander Roberts and James Donaldson (eds.), Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 1, 1885
First written in a modern book

The story point: Mithras was born on December 25.

What the sources say: The Roman calendar of 354 marks December 25 'N. INVICTI', the birthday of the Unconquered one, Sol the sun god. Mithras was also called the unconquered sun, so Franz Cumont (1903) and James Frazer took his birthday to be the same day. Later Mithras scholars such as Roger Beck and Manfred Clauss note that no Mithraic inscription names the date. The same Roman document holds the oldest record of Christmas on December 25.

From the text
VIII kal. Ian. natus Christus in Betleem Iudeae.
Chronography of 354, list of martyrs' burials (our plain English: 'December 25: Christ born in Bethlehem of Judea.') · Translation: Latin text from Theodor Mommsen, Chronica Minora I, 1892
Similar in the ancient texts

The story point: Mithras performed miracles.

What the sources say: Carvings show a 'water miracle': Mithras shoots an arrow at a rock and water springs out, much like Moses striking the rock. It is known from pictures; no written account survives.

From the text
The divine archer discharged his arrows against a precipitous rock, and there gushed forth from it a spring of living water to which the suppliants thronged to cool their parched palates.
Chapter IV, p. 138 (describing the carved reliefs) · Translation: Franz Cumont, The Mysteries of Mithra, trans. Thomas J. McCormack, 1903
Similar in the ancient texts

The story point: Mithras was marked by the sign of the cross.

What the sources say: Tertullian, a Christian writer around 200 CE, says Mithras 'sets his marks on the foreheads of his soldiers'. He does not describe the shape of the mark. He saw it as a counterpart to Christian baptism.

From the text
Mithra there, (in the kingdom of Satan,) sets his marks on the foreheads of his soldiers; celebrates also the oblation of bread, and introduces an image of a resurrection, and before a sword wreathes a crown.
The Prescription Against Heretics, chapter 40 · Translation: Peter Holmes (trans.), in Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 3, ed. Alexander Roberts and James Donaldson, 1885
Found in the ancient texts

The story point: Mithras shared a sacred meal of bread and a cup.

What the sources say: Justin Martyr wrote around 155 CE that the Mithras rites used bread and a cup of water, and saw this as a counterpart to the Last Supper. Carvings show Mithras and the Sun god sharing a meal.

From the text
Which the wicked devils have imitated in the mysteries of Mithras, commanding the same thing to be done. For, that bread and a cup of water are placed with certain incantations in the mystic rites of one who is being initiated, you either know or can learn.
First Apology, chapter 66 · Translation: Alexander Roberts and James Donaldson (eds.), Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 1, 1885
First written in a modern book

The story point: Mithras had twelve disciples.

What the sources say: Many carvings ring the bull scene with the twelve signs of the zodiac, and some show twelve small scenes from his story. A group of twelve followers is first found in modern books.

From the text
The twelve signs of the Zodiac, which in their daily revolution subject creatures to their adverse influences, were represented in all of the mithræums under their traditional aspect
Chapter IV, p. 121 · Translation: Franz Cumont, The Mysteries of Mithra, trans. Thomas J. McCormack, 1903
First written in a modern book

The story point: Mithras died and rose on the third day.

What the sources say: No surviving source describes the death of Mithras. Carvings show him riding up into the sky in the Sun god's chariot after the bull scene, and Tertullian mentions 'an image of a resurrection' in the rites without details. A third-day return is first found in modern books.

The shared points in the ancient texts

Mithras worship and early Christianity grew up side by side in Roman cities and shared practices: a sacred meal, initiation, a mark on the forehead, a holy day of the sun, and a god called savior. Because the Mithras cult left almost no writings, the order in which these practices arose is not known.

The same story in other traditions

Where this comes from

EvidenceDocumented

Comes from Justin Martyr, First Apology and Dialogue with Trypho, in Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 1…. Internet Archive: A nonprofit digital library in San Francisco, founded in 1996, that holds millions of scanned books, papers and recordings. A scan there shows the pages of a real printed book or document.

What this means

The sacred meal and the forehead mark are described by Christian writers of the 100s and 200s. Points first found in modern books are marked as such.

Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.

See all five labels

Sources

  1. Internet ArchiveA nonprofit digital library in San Francisco, founded in 1996, that holds millions of scanned books, papers and recordings. A scan there shows the pages of a real printed book or document.Justin Martyr, First Apology and Dialogue with Trypho, in Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 1 (1885)Primary text
  2. Internet ArchiveTertullian, The Prescription Against Heretics, in Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 3 (1885)Primary text
  3. The Tertullian ProjectA private website by Roger Pearse that collects early Christian texts, especially those of Tertullian, with notes on ancient manuscripts. Careful but informal.Chronography of 354, calendar and list of martyrs (Latin text, Mommsen 1892)Primary text
  4. Project GutenbergThe oldest digital library, started in 1971, with more than 70,000 free e-books whose copyright has run out. Volunteers type and check the texts against printed editions.James George Frazer, The Golden Bough, abridged edition (1922), chapter XXXVIIReference
  5. Internet ArchiveFranz Cumont, The Mysteries of Mithra, trans. Thomas J. McCormack (1903)Reference
  6. Encyclopaedia IranicaA large scholarly encyclopedia of the history, religions and cultures of Iran and nearby lands, based at Columbia University in New York since the 1970s. Its articles are written by specialists.Roger Beck, 'Mithraism', Encyclopaedia Iranica (2002)Reference
  7. Manfred Clauss, The Roman Cult of Mithras (Edinburgh University Press, 2000)Reference

More shared story points

Updated

Discussion