Credible Theories Sign in
Shared stories · Death and return

Gods Who Die and Return: Osiris, Adonis, Persephone, Baldr and Jesus

Share

A god dies, the land mourns, and the god comes back, at least for a season. Egypt, Syria, Greece and Scandinavia all tell it. How close are these stories to Easter, and how close are they really to each other?

8 tellings · 5 parts of the world · written down c. 650-550 BCE to c. 1220 CE

Paul's letter to the Corinthians, written about twenty years after the crucifixion, gives the oldest Christian summary: Christ died, was buried, and rose again the third day. Older religions of the Near East and Mediterranean also mourned a god who died. In Egypt, Osiris is murdered and cut apart, put back together by Isis, and lives again as king of the dead. In Byblos, Lucian saw women wail for Adonis and then declare him alive again. Ezekiel saw women in the Jerusalem temple weeping for Tammuz, the Mesopotamian shepherd who goes down to the underworld. In the Homeric Hymn, Persephone returns from Hades every spring.

The Norse Baldr is killed by mistletoe and stays with Hel, to return only after the end of the world. Krishna, often named in these lists, dies from a hunter's arrow and goes up to heaven without coming back to earth. Each version below is quoted from a public-domain translation with a link so you can read it in full.

The open question: Is the death-and-return story one pattern across the ancient world, or are the stories too different to group together? Scholars still argue, so where do you land? Join the debate

Follow the story through time

  1. GreekGreece · c. 650-550 BCE · Ancient text
  2. Mesopotamian (seen in Jerusalem)Jerusalem temple, seen in a vision · c. 593-571 BCE · Ancient text
  3. HinduDvaraka, western India · c. 400 BCE · Ancient text
  4. ChristianWritten in Greek from Ephesus to Corinth · c. 53-55 CE · Ancient text
  5. EgyptianEgypt · c. 100 CE · Ancient text
  6. RomanRome · c. 100 CE · Ancient text
  7. Phoenician / SyrianByblos, Lebanon · c. 150 CE · Ancient text
  8. NorseIceland · c. 1220 CE · Medieval text

The versions, quoted side by side

1 of 8 · Greek

Homeric Hymn to Demeter (Persephone's return)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 650-550 BCE
Where
Greece; tied to the Mysteries at Eleusis
When
Composed c. 650-550 BCE
From the text
But when the earth shall bloom with the fragrant flowers of spring in every kind, then from the realm of darkness and gloom thou shalt come up once more to be a wonder for gods and mortal men.
Hymn to Demeter, lines 384-404 · Translation: Hugh G. Evelyn-White, Hesiod, the Homeric Hymns and Homerica (Loeb), 1914

Same and different: Same: a descent to the dead and a return that brings life back. Different: Persephone does not die, she is taken; and her return is every year, a third of the year below.

2 of 8 · Mesopotamian (seen in Jerusalem)

Ezekiel 8:14 (women weeping for Tammuz)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 593-571 BCE
Where
Jerusalem temple, seen in a vision
When
Ezekiel prophesied c. 593-571 BCE
From the text
Then he brought me to the door of the gate of the LORD's house which was toward the north; and, behold, there sat women weeping for Tammuz.
Ezekiel 8:14 · Translation: King James Bible, 1611

Same and different: Tammuz is the Sumerian Dumuzi. In the older poem Inanna's Descent he is taken to the underworld, and a later ending has him spend half of each year there. Scholars still argue whether he was ever said to 'rise'.

3 of 8 · Hindu

Mahabharata, Mausala Parva (the death of Krishna)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 400 BCE
Where
Dvaraka, western India
When
Composed c. 400 BCE-400 CE
From the text
The hunter, mistaking Keshava, who was stretched on the earth in high Yoga, for a deer, pierced him at the heel with a shaft and quickly came to that spot for capturing his prey.
Mausala Parva, Section 4 · Translation: Kisari Mohan Ganguli, The Mahabharata, 1883-1896

Same and different: Often listed as a god who rose from the dead. In the text Krishna dies and goes up to heaven, but nothing says he came back to life on earth.

4 of 8 · Christian

Paul, First Letter to the Corinthians 15:3-6

Documented · Ancient text, c. 53-55 CE
Where
Written in Greek from Ephesus to Corinth
When
c. 53-55 CE; Paul says he is passing on an earlier creed
From the text
how that Christ died for our sins according to the scriptures; And that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the scriptures: And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve: After that, he was seen of above five hundred brethren at once
1 Corinthians 15:3-6 · Translation: King James Bible, 1611

Same and different: A single death and a bodily return on a set day, tied to named witnesses, not to the seasons. This is the main difference scholars point to.

5 of 8 · Egyptian

Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris

Documented · Ancient text, c. 100 CE
Where
Egypt (written by a Greek priest at Delphi)
When
Plutarch wrote c. 100 CE; Osiris's death and revival are in the Pyramid Texts, c. 2400 BCE
From the text
affirming that Osiris is then buried when the sown corn is covered over by the earth, and that he revives again and re-appears when it begins to sprout.
Isis and Osiris 65 · Translation: William W. Goodwin (ed.), Plutarch's Morals vol. IV, 1878

Same and different: Same: a murdered god who lives again, mourned by women. Different: Osiris does not return to the living; he rules the dead, and his son Horus takes the throne. Plutarch reports this harvest reading as one view among several.

6 of 8 · Roman

Plutarch, Life of Romulus (the vanishing and the appearance)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 100 CE
Where
Rome
When
Plutarch wrote c. 100 CE; the legend is older
From the text
Romulus had replied: “It was the pleasure of the gods, O Proculus, from whom I came, that I should be with mankind only a short time, and that after founding a city destined to be the greatest on earth for empire and glory, I should dwell again in heaven.”
Romulus 27-28 · Translation: Bernadotte Perrin, Plutarch's Lives (Loeb), 1914

Same and different: Same: the sun fails and darkness falls as the founder disappears, he appears afterward to a witness in shining form, and is worshipped as a god. Different: no death is described, and Plutarch also reports that the senators may have killed him.

7 of 8 · Phoenician / Syrian

Lucian, The Syrian Goddess (the rites of Adonis at Byblos)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 150 CE
Where
Byblos, Lebanon
When
Written c. 150 CE; Adonis is named in Greek poetry by c. 600 BCE
From the text
When they have finished their mourning and wailing, they sacrifice in the first place to Adonis, as to one who has departed this life: after this they allege that he is alive again, and exhibit his effigy to the sky.
De Dea Syria 6 · Translation: Herbert A. Strong and John Garstang, The Syrian Goddess, 1913

Same and different: The clearest ancient statement that a god in these rites was said to come back to life. Different: it is a yearly festival, not a single event, and Lucian gives no number of days.

8 of 8 · Norse

Prose Edda, Gylfaginning (the death of Baldr)

Documented · Medieval text, c. 1220 CE
Where
Iceland
When
Written by Snorri Sturluson c. 1220 CE, after Iceland became Christian
From the text
If all things in the world, quick and dead, weep for him, then he shall go back to the Aesir; but he shall remain with Hel if any gainsay it or will not weep.
Gylfaginning 49 (and 53: 'After that Baldr shall come thither, and Hodr, from Hel') · Translation: Arthur Gilchrist Brodeur, The Prose Edda, 1916

Same and different: Same: a good, beloved god killed, the whole world mourning. Different: one giantess refuses to weep, so Baldr stays dead until the world is remade after Ragnarok. Written by a Christian, so some influence from the Gospels is possible.

Why are these stories so alike?

The term 'dying and rising god' comes from James Frazer's The Golden Bough (1890-1915), which tied these figures to the yearly death and return of crops. Later scholars split. Jonathan Z. Smith argued in 1987 that the category does not hold up: most of these gods die and stay dead, or return only as rulers of the dead, and the 'rising' is often supplied by modern writers or by late, Christian-era sources. Tryggve Mettinger answered in 2001 that some Near Eastern gods, such as Dumuzi, Baal and Melqart, really were believed to die and return, but he also concluded that this does not explain the Christian resurrection belief, which is a single historical claim rather than a yearly cycle. So: the shared theme is real and old; a direct borrowing by the first Christians is not supported by the evidence.

Where do you land?

Is the death-and-return story one pattern across the ancient world, or are the stories too different to group together? Scholars still argue, so where do you land?

Tap one to see how other readers voted.

Jesus, Horus, Mithras and Krishna

Books since 1875, and films since 2007, line up story points from Horus, Mithras and Krishna beside the Jesus story. See where each point is found in the sources.

Connected stories

These stories share people, places or books with this one.

Next shared story: Taken Up to Heaven: Ascension Stories Compared → All shared stories

Where this comes from

EvidenceDocumented

Comes from James George Frazer, The Golden Bough, abridged edition, part IV 'Adonis, Attis, Osiris'…. Project Gutenberg: The oldest digital library, started in 1971, with more than 70,000 free e-books whose copyright has run out. Volunteers type and check the texts against printed editions.

What this means

The texts exist and say what is quoted. How these stories relate to each other is discussed by scholars; each version is shown with its own source and date.

Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.

See all five labels

Sources

  1. Project GutenbergThe oldest digital library, started in 1971, with more than 70,000 free e-books whose copyright has run out. Volunteers type and check the texts against printed editions.James George Frazer, The Golden Bough, abridged edition, part IV 'Adonis, Attis, Osiris' (1922)Reference
  2. Jonathan Z. Smith, 'Dying and Rising Gods', Encyclopedia of Religion (Macmillan, 1987)Reference
  3. Tryggve N. D. Mettinger, The Riddle of Resurrection: 'Dying and Rising Gods' in the Ancient Near East (Almqvist & Wiksell, 2001)Reference
  4. WikipediaA free online encyclopedia written and edited by volunteers. It is a good starting point and usually lists its own sources, but anyone can change it, so we treat it as a guide to better sources, not the final word.Wikipedia, 'Dying-and-rising god' (the debate, with scholarly citations)Reference

Updated

Discussion