Pushback and Answers: Objections to a Literal Reading
Share
Every objection a sharp reader will raise, with the answer the sources give.
No story will be unarguable to a professor. What we can do is make sure every objection has an answer that comes from the texts themselves. These are the objections a sharp reader will raise.
They are in the Ethiopian Orthodox Bible. Jude quotes Enoch by name as prophecy (Jude 14–15), and copies of both were found among the Dead Sea Scrolls next to Genesis.
In this reading that is the point. The older record is closer to the event. Each later culture kept the same history and put its own god in charge.
Some are, and the story admits it. But many are told as plain events with witnesses and dates: Livy's ships, Pliny's shield in a named consul's year, 2 Maccabees' forty days over a whole city.
Many of them did misquote. The catalog lists 14 of those mistakes and uses only what the texts actually say. A character who corrects Sitchin earns the reader's trust.
Floods are common. A warning from a god, a chosen survivor, a boat, animals, a mountain landing and a sacrifice afterward are specific. That package shows up in Babylon, Israel, India and Greece.
They were written from memory of the named public-domain translations. Check each line you use against the edition before the book is final.

Questions people ask about Pushback and Answers
Did the Bible copy the Babylonian stories?
Scholars have argued about this since 1902, when German Assyriologist Friedrich Delitzsch gave lectures called Babel and Bible claiming that much of the Old Testament came from Babylon. The talks caused a public uproar. Today most scholars think Israel shared and reshaped older Near Eastern stories rather than copying them word for word.
Why is the Book of Enoch not in most Bibles?
The Jewish canon never included it, and Christian views split. Early writers like Tertullian treated it as scripture, while Jerome and Augustine did not. It dropped out of use in most churches and survived complete only in Ge'ez, the old language of Ethiopia. The Scottish traveler James Bruce brought copies to Europe in 1773.
Was there a real flood in ancient Mesopotamia?
There were many. In 1929 Leonard Woolley found a deep layer of clean silt at Ur and announced he had found the Flood. Later digs showed that flood layers at Ur, Kish, Shuruppak and other cities come from different dates, which points to repeated local river floods rather than one disaster covering the whole region.
Updated
Where this comes from
Comes from The ancient texts quoted in each answer. Each answer quotes the passage it rests on. The passages, with their translation and sources, are on our Ancient texts index.
What this means
Each answer cites the texts. The arguments themselves are still open.
Several independent lines of evidence agree, such as excavations, measurements or peer-reviewed studies. Experts still argue about details.












