Credible Theories Sign in
Shared stories · Death and return

Taken Up to Heaven: Ascension Stories Compared

Share

Enoch, Elijah, Romulus, Heracles, Krishna and Jesus all leave the earth by going up: in a whirlwind, a cloud, a storm or a blaze of light. The stories quoted side by side.

7 tellings · 3 parts of the world · written down c. 600-400 BCE to c. 620 CE

The Book of Acts says the risen Jesus was taken up into a cloud while his followers watched. He is not the first in the Bible to leave this way: Enoch 'was not; for God took him', and Elijah went up to heaven in a whirlwind with a chariot of fire. Greek and Roman readers knew the pattern too. Romulus vanished in a sudden storm and the Romans were told he had been caught up into heaven. Heracles' funeral pyre was lifted to heaven by a cloud with a peal of thunder.

In India, the Mahabharata says Krishna, after a hunter's arrow struck him, rose upward filling the sky with light. In Islam, the Quran's Night Journey was later told as Muhammad's ascent through the heavens. Each version is quoted from a public-domain translation with a link to read it in full.

The open question: Why do so many stories end with a great figure leaving the earth alive instead of dying like everyone else? Join the debate

Follow the story through time

  1. Hebrew BibleJudah · c. 600-400 BCE · Ancient text
  2. Hebrew BibleNear the Jordan River, Israel · c. 600-550 BCE · Ancient text
  3. HinduDvaraka, western India · c. 400 BCE · Ancient text
  4. GreekMount Oeta, central Greece · c. 1st-2nd century CE · Ancient text
  5. ChristianMount of Olives, Jerusalem · c. 80-90 CE · Ancient text
  6. RomanRome, near the Goat's Marsh · c. 100 CE · Ancient text
  7. IslamicMecca to Jerusalem · c. 620 CE · Medieval text

The versions, quoted side by side

1 of 7 · Hebrew Bible

Genesis 5:24 (Enoch)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 600-400 BCE
Where
Judah (written); set before the Flood
When
Composed c. 600-400 BCE from older sources
From the text
And Enoch walked with God: and he was not; for God took him.
Genesis 5:24 · Translation: King James Bible, 1611

Same and different: The shortest ascension story there is. Later books, such as 1 Enoch, describe his journey through the heavens in detail.

2 of 7 · Hebrew Bible

2 Kings 2:11 (Elijah)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 600-550 BCE
Where
Near the Jordan River, Israel
When
Kings compiled c. 600-550 BCE; Elijah lived c. 850 BCE
From the text
behold, there appeared a chariot of fire, and horses of fire, and parted them both asunder; and Elijah went up by a whirlwind into heaven.
2 Kings 2:11 · Translation: King James Bible, 1611

Same and different: Same as Acts: a disciple, Elisha, watches his master go up and takes on his role. Different: Elijah never dies first.

3 of 7 · Hindu

Mahabharata, Mausala Parva (the end of Krishna)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 400 BCE
Where
Dvaraka, western India
When
Composed c. 400 BCE-400 CE
From the text
The high-souled one comforted him and then ascended upwards, filling the entire welkin with splendour. When he reached Heaven, Vasava and the twin Ashvinis and Rudra and the Adityas and the Vasus and the Viswedevas, and Munis and Siddhas and many foremost ones among the Gandharvas, with the Apsaras, advanced to receive him.
Mausala Parva, Section 4 · Translation: Kisari Mohan Ganguli, The Mahabharata, 1883-1896

Same and different: This point is found in the Mahabharata: after his death he rises to heaven and is welcomed by the gods. He forgives the hunter who shot him first.

4 of 7 · Greek

Apollodorus, The Library (the death of Heracles)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 1st-2nd century CE
Where
Mount Oeta, central Greece
When
The Library compiled c. 1st-2nd century CE from much older myths
From the text
While the pyre was burning, it is said that a cloud passed under Hercules and with a peal of thunder wafted him up to heaven. Thereafter he obtained immortality
Library 2.7.7 · Translation: James George Frazer, Apollodorus: The Library (Loeb), 1921

Same and different: Same: a son of a god and a mortal woman, a cloud, and a place among the gods. Different: he climbs his own funeral pyre.

5 of 7 · Christian

Acts of the Apostles 1:9

Documented · Ancient text, c. 80-90 CE
Where
Mount of Olives, Jerusalem
When
Written c. 80-90 CE
From the text
And when he had spoken these things, while they beheld, he was taken up; and a cloud received him out of their sight.
Acts 1:9 · Translation: King James Bible, 1611

Same and different: Comes forty days after the resurrection, before named witnesses, with angels promising he will return the same way.

6 of 7 · Roman

Plutarch, Life of Romulus

Documented · Ancient text, c. 100 CE
Where
Rome, near the Goat's Marsh
When
Plutarch wrote c. 100 CE; the legend is older
From the text
exhorted them all to honour and revere Romulus, since he had been caught up into heaven, and was to be a benevolent god for them instead of a good king.
Romulus 27 · Translation: Bernadotte Perrin, Plutarch's Lives (Loeb), 1914

Same and different: Same: darkness, a disappearance, a later appearance to a witness, and worship as a god (Quirinus). Different: no one sees him go up; the senators announce it, and Plutarch notes some suspected murder.

7 of 7 · Islamic

Quran 17:1 (the Night Journey)

Documented · Medieval text, c. 620 CE
Where
Mecca to Jerusalem
When
Revealed c. 620 CE
From the text
Glorified be He Who carried His servant by night from the Inviolable Place of Worship to the Far Distant Place of Worship the neighbourhood whereof We have blessed, that We might show him of Our tokens!
Surah 17 (Al-Isra), verse 1 · Translation: Marmaduke Pickthall, The Meaning of the Glorious Koran, 1930

Same and different: The verse names a night journey; the ascent through the seven heavens (the Mi'raj) comes from hadith collections. Different: Muhammad returns to earth the same night.

Why are these stories so alike?

Scholars call these 'rapture' or 'assumption' stories. In the Greek and Roman world a disappearance into the sky, often with a storm, cloud or darkness, was a standard way to say a great man had become a god; Romulus and Heracles were the best-known examples, and Roman emperors were later said to have risen too. Many New Testament scholars think Luke, who wrote Acts, told the ascension in terms his Greek readers would recognize, while drawing first on the Elijah story in his own scriptures. Others stress that Acts ties the event to witnesses and a resurrection, which the Roman stories lack. The Indian and Islamic versions grew up separately and show the image of a holy figure rising to heaven is very widespread.

Where do you land?

Why do so many stories end with a great figure leaving the earth alive instead of dying like everyone else?

Tap one to see how other readers voted.

Jesus, Horus, Mithras and Krishna

Books since 1875, and films since 2007, line up story points from Horus, Mithras and Krishna beside the Jesus story. See where each point is found in the sources.

Connected stories

These stories share people, places or books with this one.

Next shared story: Born at Midwinter: December 25 and the Winter Solstice → All shared stories

Where this comes from

EvidenceDocumented

Comes from Wikipedia, 'Ascension of Jesus' (sources and background, with scholarly citations). A free online encyclopedia written and edited by volunteers. It is a good starting point and usually lists its own sources, but anyone can change it, so we treat it as a guide to better sources, not the final word.

What this means

Every text quoted here exists and says what is quoted. The events are matters of faith or legend; no independent record shows them.

Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.

See all five labels

Sources

  1. WikipediaA free online encyclopedia written and edited by volunteers. It is a good starting point and usually lists its own sources, but anyone can change it, so we treat it as a guide to better sources, not the final word.Wikipedia, 'Ascension of Jesus' (sources and background, with scholarly citations)Reference
  2. WikipediaWikipedia, 'Apotheosis' (Greek and Roman deification, Romulus and Heracles)Reference
  3. WikipediaWikipedia, 'Isra and Mi'raj' (the Night Journey and its sources)Reference

Updated

Discussion