Credible Theories Sign in
Shared stories · Heroes and trials

A Child Offered Up: Abraham, Jephthah, Agamemnon and Harishchandra

Share

A father is told, or promises, that he must give up his own child. Sometimes an animal is found in time and sometimes no one stops the knife, and the story is told in the Bible, the Quran, Greece, India and Viking-age Sweden.

9 tellings · 4 parts of the world · written down c. 850 BCE to 1699

In Genesis, God tells Abraham to take his only son Isaac up a mountain and offer him as a burnt offering. Abraham raises the knife before an angel calls out, and a ram is found caught in a bush. The Quran tells the same moment, and there the son himself says, "Do that which thou art commanded." In the Book of Judges, the war leader Jephthah promises God whatever first comes out of his door, and his only daughter comes out dancing.

Far away, the pattern repeats. In India, King Harishchandra begs the god Varuna for a son and promises to sacrifice him, then stalls for years until the boy runs off into the forest. In Greece, King Agamemnon gives his daughter Iphigenia to the altar so the winds will carry his ships to Troy. In a later legend from Crete, King Idomeneus swears to the sea god that he will sacrifice the first living thing he sees, and the first one he sees is his son. A Phoenician history and the Bible both tell of kings who gave a son in a desperate war, and an Icelandic saga tells of a Swedish king who traded his sons, one by one, for more years of life. Below, each version is quoted from a public-domain translation, with a link so you can read it in full.

The open question: Do these stories remember a time when people really gave up their children, or were they told to teach that it must never happen? Join the debate

Follow the story through time

  1. Hebrew Bible (about Moab)Kir-hareseth, Moab · c. 850 BCE · Ancient text
  2. Vedic IndiaNorthern India · c. 800-600 BCE · Ancient text
  3. Hebrew BibleGilead, east of the Jordan · c. 7th-6th century BCE · Ancient text
  4. Hebrew BibleJudah / Israel · 1st millennium BCE · Ancient text
  5. GreekAthens, Greece · 458 BCE · Ancient text
  6. Phoenician (in Greek)Byblos, Lebanon · c. 100 CE · Ancient text
  7. IslamArabia · 7th century CE · Medieval text
  8. Norse (Swedish legend)Uppsala, Sweden · c. 1225 CE · Medieval text
  9. French (Greek legend)France · 1699 · Recorded folklore

The versions, quoted side by side

1 of 9 · Hebrew Bible (about Moab)

2 Kings 3 (King Mesha of Moab)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 850 BCE
Where
Kir-hareseth, Moab (Jordan)
When
Events c. 850 BCE; Kings compiled c. 600-550 BCE. Mesha himself left an inscription, the Mesha Stele, c. 840 BCE
From the text
Then he took his eldest son that should have reigned in his stead, and offered him for a burnt offering upon the wall. And there was great indignation against Israel: and they departed from him, and returned to their own land.
2 Kings 3:27 · Translation: King James Version, 1611

Same and different: Same king giving his heir in a time of disaster, as in the Phoenician account. Different: it is told by his enemies, in one short line, and the sacrifice seems to work, since the armies around him withdraw.

2 of 9 · Vedic India

Aitareya Brahmana (Harishchandra, Rohita and Shunahshepa)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 800-600 BCE
Where
Northern India
When
Composed orally c. 800-600 BCE; manuscripts much later
From the text
He went to Varuna the king, praying, “Let a son be born to me; I will sacrifice him to thee.” Then a son, Rohita by name, was born to him. Varuna said to him, “A son is born to thee, sacrifice him to me.”
Aitareya Brahmana 7.14 (Haug pp. 462-463) · Translation: Martin Haug, The Aitareya Brahmanam of the Rigveda, Vol. II, 1863

Same and different: Same father who promises a god his child, as with Jephthah and Idomeneus. Different: the king stalls for years with excuses, the son runs away and buys another boy, Shunahshepa, to die in his place, and Shunahshepa is freed by praying to the gods.

3 of 9 · Hebrew Bible

Judges 11 (Jephthah's vow)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 7th-6th century BCE
Where
Gilead, east of the Jordan; written in Israel / Judah
When
Book of Judges compiled c. 7th-6th century BCE from older stories
From the text
And Jephthah came to Mizpeh unto his house, and, behold, his daughter came out to meet him with timbrels and with dances: and she was his only child; beside her he had neither son nor daughter. And it came to pass, when he saw her, that he rent his clothes, and said, Alas, my daughter! thou hast brought me very low
Judges 11:34-35 (the vow is 11:30-31) · Translation: King James Version, 1611

Same and different: Same rash promise as Idomeneus: 'whatsoever cometh forth of the doors of my house' after a victory. Different: no voice from heaven stops it; the daughter asks for two months to mourn, and then her father 'did with her according to his vow'.

4 of 9 · Hebrew Bible

Genesis 22 (the binding of Isaac)

Documented · Ancient text, 1st millennium BCE
Where
Judah / Israel (written); set at Moriah
When
Usually dated to the 1st millennium BCE (estimates range c. 900-500 BCE); oldest copies are Dead Sea Scroll fragments, c. 250 BCE to 50 CE
From the text
And Abraham stretched forth his hand, and took the knife to slay his son. And the angel of the LORD called unto him out of heaven, and said, Abraham, Abraham: and he said, Here am I. And he said, Lay not thine hand upon the lad, neither do thou any thing unto him: for now I know that thou fearest God, seeing thou hast not withheld thy son, thine only son from me.
Genesis 22:10-12 · Translation: King James Version, 1611

Same and different: Same command or vow to give up a beloved child as the other versions. Different: it is a test, the knife is stopped at the last moment, and a ram caught in a thicket is offered in the boy's place.

5 of 9 · Greek

Aeschylus, Agamemnon (the sacrifice of Iphigenia)

Documented · Ancient text, 458 BCE
Where
Athens, Greece; set at Aulis
When
First staged 458 BCE; the story is older (the lost epic Cypria, c. 7th-6th century BCE)
From the text
So, when the chant of sacrifice was done, Her father bade the youthful priestly train Raise her, like some poor kid, above the altar-stone, From where amid her robes she lay Sunk all in swoon away
Agamemnon, lines 231-235 of the Greek · Translation: E. D. A. Morshead, The House of Atreus, 1881

Same and different: Same king and father caught between his people and his child, and the same altar. Different: the goddess Artemis demands the girl so the winds will let the fleet sail to Troy; in other Greek versions she swaps in a deer at the last moment, like the ram in Genesis.

6 of 9 · Phoenician (in Greek)

Philo of Byblos, Phoenician History (Sanchuniathon), on Cronus and his only son

Documented · Ancient text, c. 100 CE
Where
Byblos, Lebanon
When
Written by Philo of Byblos c. 100 CE, who said he translated the older Phoenician writer Sanchuniathon; survives in Eusebius, c. 315 CE
From the text
It was the custom among the ancients, in times of great calamity, in order to prevent the ruin of all, for the rulers of the city or nation to sacrifice to the avenging deities the most beloved of their children as the price of redemption ... and when great dangers from war beset the land he adorned the altar, and invested this son with the emblems of royalty, and sacrificed him.
Sanchuniathon, via Eusebius, Preparation for the Gospel 1.10 (Cory, p. 17) · Translation: Isaac Preston Cory, Ancient Fragments, 1832

Same and different: Same 'only son' and same sacrifice in wartime as Mesha. Different: the father is the god Cronus (El) acting as a king, and his son is called Ieoud, which Philo says is the Phoenician word for 'only son'.

7 of 9 · Islam

Quran, Surah 37, As-Saffat (Abraham's son)

Documented · Medieval text, 7th century CE
Where
Arabia
When
7th century CE; early manuscripts such as the Birmingham leaves are radiocarbon dated to c. 568-645 CE
From the text
And when (his son) was old enough to walk with him, (Abraham) said: O my dear son, I have seen in a dream that I must sacrifice thee. So look, what thinkest thou? He said: O my father! Do that which thou art commanded. Allah willing, thou shalt find me of the stedfast.
Surah 37:102 (the ransom follows in 37:103-107) · Translation: Marmaduke Pickthall, The Meaning of the Glorious Koran, 1930

Same and different: Same test of Abraham and the same last-minute ransom 'with a tremendous victim' as Genesis. Different: the command comes in a dream, the son agrees to it, and he is not named (many Muslim scholars hold he was Ishmael).

8 of 9 · Norse (Swedish legend)

Snorri Sturluson, Heimskringla, Ynglinga Saga (King On or Aun of Uppsala)

Documented · Medieval text, c. 1225 CE
Where
Uppsala, Sweden; written in Iceland
When
Written c. 1225 CE; draws on the poem Ynglingatal, c. 900 CE
From the text
He made a great sacrifice, and in it offered up his son to Odin. On got an answer from Odin, that he should live sixty years longer
Ynglinga Saga, chapter 29 in Laing (chapter 25 in modern editions) · Translation: Samuel Laing, The Heimskringla; or, Chronicle of the Kings of Norway, Vol. I, 1844

Same and different: Same father who pays a god with his sons. Different: the king does it for his own long life, giving one son every ten years, until his people stop him from killing the last one.

9 of 9 · French (Greek legend)

Fénelon, The Adventures of Telemachus, Book 5 (Idomeneus' vow)

Documented · Recorded folklore, 1699
Where
France; set in Crete
When
Written 1699; the legend appears earlier in Servius' commentary on Virgil, c. 400 CE
From the text
O mighty Deity, to whom belong the dominions of the deep, vouchsafe to hear me in this uttermost distress! If thou wilt protect me from the fury of the waves, and restore me in safety to my country, I will offer up to thee the first living object that I see on my return.
Telemachus, Book 5 · Translation: John Hawkesworth, The Adventures of Telemachus, 1768 (reprinted Houghton, Mifflin, 1887)

Same and different: Same rash vow as Jephthah, and the first to come out is the child. Different: a priest begs the king to offer a hundred bulls instead; in Servius the king carries out the vow and a plague drives him from Crete.

Why are these stories so alike?

Scholars read these stories in several ways. Many see Genesis 22 as a story that teaches that the God of Israel does not want a child's life, since the ram takes the son's place. Others note that the Hebrew Bible itself mentions child sacrifice among neighbors and sometimes in Israel (2 Kings 3:27, Jeremiah 7:31), and that King Mesha is a known historical ruler whose own stone inscription survives. Archaeologists have found burial grounds holding the burned bones of infants at Carthage and other Phoenician towns, called tophets; many read them as proof that children were offered in times of crisis, while others argue that some were children who died naturally. James Frazer gathered stories like King Aun's and argued that kings once gave a son to die in their place. The rash vow to give 'the first thing I meet' is a known folk-tale pattern, and writers have long compared Idomeneus with Jephthah: some think one story shaped the other, others see two separate tellings of a common idea. Scholars of India often read the Shunahshepa story as a turning point, where a human victim is set free and the rite moves to other offerings. Whether the stories remember real practice, warn against it, or test faith and loyalty is still argued.

Where do you land?

Do these stories remember a time when people really gave up their children, or were they told to teach that it must never happen?

Tap one to see how other readers voted.

Connected stories

These stories share people, places or books with this one.

Next shared story: Lost Lands Under the Sea: Atlantis, Dvaraka and Ys → All shared stories

Where this comes from

EvidenceDocumented

Comes from James George Frazer, The Golden Bough (abridged, 1922), chapter XXVI, 'Sacrifice of the…. Project Gutenberg: The oldest digital library, started in 1971, with more than 70,000 free e-books whose copyright has run out. Volunteers type and check the texts against printed editions.

What this means

Every text quoted here exists and is linked. King Mesha is confirmed by his own inscription. Whether child sacrifice was common in the ancient Mediterranean is debated; the Phoenician tophet burials are the main physical evidence and are read in more than one way.

Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.

See all five labels

Sources

  1. Project GutenbergThe oldest digital library, started in 1971, with more than 70,000 free e-books whose copyright has run out. Volunteers type and check the texts against printed editions.James George Frazer, The Golden Bough (abridged, 1922), chapter XXVI, 'Sacrifice of the King's Son'Reference
  2. WikipediaA free online encyclopedia written and edited by volunteers. It is a good starting point and usually lists its own sources, but anyone can change it, so we treat it as a guide to better sources, not the final word.Wikipedia, 'Binding of Isaac' (Jewish, Christian and Muslim readings, with scholarly citations)Reference
  3. WikipediaWikipedia, 'Child sacrifice' (the tophet debate and ancient sources)Reference
  4. WikipediaWikipedia, 'Mesha Stele' (King Mesha's own inscription, c. 840 BCE)Reference
  5. WikipediaWikipedia, 'Jephthah' (the vow and its parallels, including Idomeneus and Iphigenia)Reference

Updated

Discussion