Credible Theories Sign in

The record

From the text
Pytheas reported that the coast-line of the island was more than forty thousand stadia, and added his story about Thule and about those regions in which there was no longer either land properly so‑called, or sea, or air, but a kind of substance concreted from all these elements, resembling a sea-lungs
Documented · Modern book, Written by Strabo, a Greek geo
Strabo, Geography 2.4.1, reporting Polybius on Pytheas · Greece and Rome
Translation: H. L. Jones, The Geography of Strabo, vol. 1 (Loeb Classical Library, 1917) · Public domain

Pytheas, a Greek explorer, claimed to have travelled over the whole of Britain that could be reached, and wrote about an island beyond it called Thule. His book is lost. What survives is mostly what his critics said about it: Polybius, as Strabo reports, found it incredible that a private man, and a poor one, could have made such journeys.

Strabo reports that Pytheas put Thule a six days' sail north of Britain, near the frozen sea. Farther north still, Pytheas said, there was no longer land or sea or air, but a kind of substance concreted from all these elements, resembling a sea-lungs, which you could neither walk nor sail upon. He said he saw that himself and told the rest from hearsay. Strabo's translator explains a sea-lung as "an acaleph", a kind of jellyfish. Strabo even passes on Pytheas's report of how people up there lived: on millet, herbs, fruits and roots, threshing their grain indoors because there was so little sunshine and so much rain.

Strabo did not trust any of it. He called Pytheas an arch-falsifier and noted that travelers who had seen Britain never mentioned Thule. Yet when Agricola's Roman fleet first sailed around the north of Britain, Tacitus writes, Thule was also distinctly seen, which winter and eternal snow had hitherto concealed. A note in the Oxford translation of Tacitus lists the guesses at where Tacitus's Thule was: Shetland, one of the Hebrides, Foula, while Pliny's description pointed others to Iceland.

Questions people ask about Thule, the farthest island

How did Pytheas measure where he was?

He recorded the ratio of a sundial's pointer to its shadow at Massilia. Hipparchus said he observed the same ratio at Byzantium at the same time of year.

What else did Agricola's fleet find?

Tacitus says the fleet proved Britain was an island and discovered and subdued the Orkneys, islands until then unknown.

Did Strabo think anyone lived so far north?

He allowed that Pytheas might be right about peoples near the frozen zone having few animals and crops and living on millet, herbs, fruits and roots.

The open question

Still strange: The edge of the known world.

Strabo called him a liar, but a Roman fleet later reported seeing Thule from afar.

Atlantis: Is Plato's Sunken Island Real or a Myth? →
  1. Step 1 of 4 · This fileThule, the farthest island
  2. Step 2 of 4 · The passageNeither land nor sea nor air, Strabo, Geography 2.4.1, reporting Polybius on Pytheas
  3. Step 3 of 4 · Next fileAtlantis: Is Plato's Sunken Island Real or a Myth?
  4. Step 4 of 4 · Next fileDoggerland: The Real Lost Land Beneath the North Sea
About these videos

Found by a YouTube search for this topic, not checked by us. The player loads from YouTube only when you press play.

Where it turns up

Where this comes from

EvidenceAlmost credible

Comes from Strabo, Geography 1.4.2-3, trans. H. L. Jones (Loeb Classical Library, 1917), LacusCurtius. Geography, by Strabo: A 17-book description of the lands and peoples of the known world by Strabo, a Greek geographer, finished around AD 20 to 25. It includes an account of the city of Helike sinking in 373 BC.

What this means

Pytheas's report survives only through critics, and which northern land he meant is still argued.

For Thule, the farthest island, there is real evidence, but it does not settle the question (4 sources listed at the bottom of this page). The main doubt: No one knows which land Pytheas meant, and the Roman sighting may not have been the same place. Pytheas's own words survive only through writers who disliked him.

Serious people have done real work and there is real evidence for the idea, but it falls short of proof. We show what supports it, what is missing and who disagrees.

See all five labels

Sources

  1. Geography, by StraboA 17-book description of the lands and peoples of the known world by Strabo, a Greek geographer, finished around AD 20 to 25. It includes an account of the city of Helike sinking in 373 BC.Strabo, Geography 1.4.2-3, trans. H. L. Jones (Loeb Classical Library, 1917), LacusCurtiusPrimary text
  2. Geography, by StraboStrabo, Geography 2.4.1, trans. H. L. Jones (Loeb Classical Library, 1917), LacusCurtiusPrimary text
  3. Geography, by StraboStrabo, Geography 4.5.5, trans. H. L. Jones (Loeb Classical Library, 1923), LacusCurtiusPrimary text
  4. Project GutenbergThe oldest digital library, started in 1971, with more than 70,000 free e-books whose copyright has run out. Volunteers type and check the texts against printed editions.Tacitus, Agricola 10, the Oxford translation revised, with notes (Project Gutenberg ebook 7524)Primary text

Quotations come from public-domain translations. A book in our Library links to its Library page; other links open the free online copy or the reference page.

Updated

Credible or not?

Tap one to see how other readers voted.

Discussion