Credible Theories Sign in
One History · a story · chapter 1 of 11

The World Before This One: Earlier Worlds in Genesis and Myth

Share

Before the first day · story date: before 12,900 years ago

The theory · a story with no hard evidence

Earth is older than the story Genesis tells about it. When the Bible opens, the planet is already here, shapeless and empty under dark water (the exact words of Genesis 1:2 are quoted at the bottom of this chapter). Creation week is a rebuild.

Other cultures remember the earlier worlds directly. The Aztecs count four suns before ours, each ended by a different disaster. Hesiod counts four races of people before us, each made and then removed. An Egyptian priest tells the Greek lawgiver Solon that humanity has been destroyed "many times" by fire and flood, and that the Greeks only forget because their records are wiped each time.

The facts · on record

What the texts say

The theory above rests on these passages, quoted from published translations. What they mean is the open question.

Genesis 1:2 · KJVAnd the earth was without form, and void; and darkness was upon the face of the deep.
Legend of the Suns · 1558Four earlier worlds ended by jaguars, wind, a rain of fire, and a flood.
Hesiod, Works and Days 109–201Golden, silver, bronze, heroic, then iron: five races of humans.
Plato, Timaeus 22b–d · JowettThere have been, and will be again, many destructions of mankind arising out of many causes.
If someone pushes back"Without form and void" usually means unshaped, not ruined. Answer: the answer points to Jeremiah 4:23, where the same words describe a land destroyed by judgment.

The files behind this chapter

Where this comes from

EvidenceSpeculation

Comes from Genesis 1:2 · KJV and 3 more passages. The first book of the Bible, telling of Creation, Adam and Eve, Noah's Flood and the families of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. Scholars think it was written and edited over several centuries and finished by roughly 500 to 400 BC. The oldest surviving copies are pieces of the Dead Sea Scrolls.

What this means

A reading that treats the old texts as one record. It is an interpretation, not established history.

An idea or reading that goes beyond what the evidence shows. We include it because people ask about it, and we mark it so it never gets mixed in with the record.

See all five labels

A story, not a record

This series asks what history looks like if the old texts are records, not myths. Each claim rests on a quoted text. It is a reading, not an established fact. The files linked above say what the record shows.

Sources in this chapter

  1. The Book of GenesisThe first book of the Bible: Creation, the Flood and the first familiesGenesis 1:2 · KJV · full passage
  2. The Legend of the Suns (Leyenda de los Soles)An Aztec account of the world's five ages, written down in 1558Legend of the Suns · 1558
  3. Hesiod's Works and DaysA Greek farming poem with the myth of the five ages of humansHesiod, Works and Days 109–201 · full passage
  4. Plato's TimaeusPlato's dialogue that first tells the Atlantis story, about 360 BCPlato, Timaeus 22b–d · Jowett · full passage

Questions people ask about The world before this one

What does 'without form and void' mean in Genesis 1:2?

It is usually read as 'unshaped and empty', the raw state before creation. This chapter reads it as a ruin, pointing to Jeremiah 4:23, where the same words describe a land destroyed by judgment. That is a reading, not the standard interpretation.

Do other cultures describe worlds before ours?

Yes. The Aztec Legend of the Suns counts four earlier worlds ended by jaguars, wind, a rain of fire and a flood. Hesiod's Works and Days lists golden, silver, bronze and heroic races before our iron one.

What did Plato's Egyptian priest tell Solon?

In Plato's Timaeus, an Egyptian priest tells Solon that 'there have been, and will be again, many destructions of mankind arising out of many causes', and that the Greeks forget because their records are wiped out each time.

Updated

Discussion