Credible Theories Sign in
One History · a story · chapter 4 of 11

The Limits: Why the Old Texts Say Humans Lost Long Life

Share

Eden · story date: soon after the making

The theory · a story with no hard evidence

The workers turn out better than planned. Genesis records the makers' alarm: the man is become as one of us. So the makers put controls on the product.

First, long life. The tree of life goes behind a guarded perimeter with a turning weapon. In Babylon, Adapa is offered the bread and water of life and refuses it because his own patron god told him it was poison. Second, sight. The Maya say the first people could see through the sky to the edge of the world, so the gods clouded their eyes like breath on a mirror. The Gnostic texts go further: the makers feared what they had made and locked it into a heavier body.

The facts · on record

What the texts say

The theory above rests on these passages, quoted from published translations. What they mean is the open question.

Genesis 3:22, 24 · KJVLest he put forth his hand, and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live for ever… Cherubims, and a flaming sword which turned every way.
Adapa · summaryEnki tells Adapa to refuse the food of heaven; it was the food of life.
Popol Vuh · summaryThe first people see too far, so the gods blur their eyes.
Apocryphon of John · summaryThe archons, jealous of Adam, bind him in a material body.

The files behind this chapter

Where this comes from

EvidenceSpeculation

Comes from Genesis 3:22, 24 · KJV and 3 more passages. The first book of the Bible, telling of Creation, Adam and Eve, Noah's Flood and the families of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. Scholars think it was written and edited over several centuries and finished by roughly 500 to 400 BC. The oldest surviving copies are pieces of the Dead Sea Scrolls.

What this means

A reading that treats the old texts as one record. It is an interpretation, not established history.

An idea or reading that goes beyond what the evidence shows. We include it because people ask about it, and we mark it so it never gets mixed in with the record.

See all five labels

A story, not a record

This series asks what history looks like if the old texts are records, not myths. Each claim rests on a quoted text. It is a reading, not an established fact. The files linked above say what the record shows.

Sources in this chapter

  1. The Book of GenesisThe first book of the Bible: Creation, the Flood and the first familiesGenesis 3:22, 24 · KJV · full passage
  2. The Story of AdapaA Babylonian myth of a wise man who turned down eternal lifeAdapa · summary
  3. The Popol VuhThe sacred book of the K'iche' Maya of GuatemalaPopol Vuh · summary · full passage
  4. The Secret Book of John (Apocryphon of John)A Gnostic creation story, found buried in Egypt in 1945Apocryphon of John · summary

Questions people ask about The limits

Why did God guard the tree of life?

Genesis 3:22 gives the reason: 'lest he put forth his hand, and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live for ever.' Verse 24 places cherubim and 'a flaming sword which turned every way' at the gate of Eden.

Who was Adapa?

Adapa is a Babylonian sage who is offered the bread and water of life in heaven and refuses it, because his own patron god, Enki, told him it was poison. This chapter pairs him with Genesis as a second story of lost long life.

What does the Popol Vuh say about the first humans?

In the Maya Popol Vuh, the first people could see too far, through the sky to the edge of the world, so the gods clouded their eyes 'like breath on a mirror'. The Gnostic Apocryphon of John has the archons bind Adam in a material body.

Updated

Discussion