How the rabbit hole works. Start with anything that grabs you, say UFOs. Every person, place and document a page mentions links to its own page, so a UFO file leads to a witness, the witness leads to the people who investigated the case, and it keeps going.
The path you take shows in the bar under the top menu on every page, so you can step back any time or climb out and start again.
A god kneels in the mud, shapes a body with his hands and breathes it into life. That scene is told in Iraq, Israel, Egypt, Greece, China, Arabia, Guatemala, Sudan and New Zealand.
9 tellings · 6 parts of the world · written down c. 1700 BCE to 1911
Ask where the first people came from and an amazing number of old books give the same answer: from the ground. In Genesis God forms Adam from dust and breathes into his nose. On Babylonian tablets a mother goddess spits on her clay and pinches off fourteen pieces. In Egypt the ram-headed god Khnum shapes people like a potter at his wheel. In GreecePrometheus moulds men from earth and water, and in China the goddess Nuwa shapes people from yellow earth.
The details are where it gets strange. In Guatemala the gods' first clay man is a soggy failure that cannot turn its head, so they wash him away and try wood instead. In Sudan a creator walks the world and makes each people from the local soil. In New Zealand the clay figure comes alive with a sneeze. Below, each version is quoted from a public-domain translation, with a link so you can read it in full.
The open question: Did one old story about a potter god travel from people to people, or does anyone who works with clay end up imagining that we were made from it? Join the debate
Mesopotamia (Iraq); this copy from Ashurbanipal's library at Nineveh
When
Story known from Old Babylonian tablets of c. 1700 BCE; this late Assyrian copy, 7th century BCE
From the text
[She sp]at upon her clay. [Fourteen pieces] she pinched off; seven pieces she laid on the right. [Seven] pieces she laid on the left; between them she placed a brick. ... The figures of people, Mami formed.
Same and different: Same clay and same divine potter as the other versions; different: a goddess, Mami, does the shaping with Ea's help, seven boys and seven girls are made at once, and in the fuller story a slain god's flesh and blood are mixed into the clay so people can do the gods' work.
The Tale of the Two Brothers (Khnum makes a wife for Bata)
Documented · Ancient text, c. 1215 BCE
Where
Egypt; Papyrus D'Orbiney, now in the British Museum
When
Papyrus written c. 1215 BCE (19th Dynasty)
From the text
And Ra Harakhti said to Khnumu, "Behold, frame thou a woman for Bata, that he may not remain alive alone." And Khnumu made for him a mate to dwell with him.
Same and different: Same craftsman god who builds a person to order, and the same worry that a man should not live alone (compare Genesis 2:18); different: Khnum, the ram-headed potter god who in temple scenes shapes babies on his wheel, makes a wife for one hero rather than the first humans.
Same and different: Same picture of a body shaped from the ground and then given life; different: one God works alone, the life comes as breath into the nose, and the Hebrew name Adam is a pun on adamah, the ground.
Same and different: Same earth mixed with water and shaped by a god's hands; different: the maker is a Titan who then steals fire for his creatures and is punished for it. In the older poet Hesiod it is Hephaestus who mixes earth and water to make Pandora, the first woman.
Fengsu Tongyi of Ying Shao (Nuwa shapes people), as retold by E. T. C. Werner
Documented · Retold in English, c. 195 CE
Where
China
When
Fengsu Tongyi written c. 195 CE; the story survives in later quotations
From the text
Nü Kua Shih (also called Nü Wa and Nü Hsi) ... as having been the creator of human beings when the earth first emerged from Chaos. She (or he, for the sex seems uncertain), who had the "body of a serpent and head of an ox" ... "moulded yellow earth and made man."
Same and different: Same act of shaping people by hand from earth; different: the maker is a serpent-bodied goddess, and in the full Fengsu Tongyi story she tires of the slow work and drags a rope through mud, so the handmade people become nobles and the mud-drops become commoners.
Same and different: Same first man shaped from clay and then given God's spirit (15:29), as in Genesis; different: the clay is named as dark potter's mud, and the jinn are made from fire, which sets up Iblis's refusal to bow to a creature of clay.
Popol Vuh (the man of clay), as summarized by H. H. Bancroft
Documented · Retold in English, c. 1554-1558
Where
Highland Guatemala
When
Written in K'iche' c. 1554-1558; the only surviving copy was made by Francisco Ximenez c. 1701
From the text
Again the gods took counsel together; they determined to make man. So they made a man of clay; and when they had made him, they saw that it was not good. He was without cohesion, without consistence, motionless, strengthless, inept, watery; he could not move his head, his face looked but one way
Same and different: Same gods trying to shape people from earth; different: the clay man fails. He melts in the water, wooden people come next, and only the third try, people made from maize dough, works.
Maori account of the first man (Tu, Tiki or Tane), reported by J. G. Frazer
Documented · Retold in English, 19th century
Where
Aotearoa (New Zealand)
When
Oral tradition, written down by missionaries and officials in the 19th century (Richard Taylor 1870, W. E. Gudgeon 1905)
From the text
The Maoris of New Zealand say that a certain god, variously named Tu, Tiki, and Tane, took red riverside clay, kneaded it with his own blood into a likeness or image of himself, with eyes, legs, arms, and all complete, in fact, an exact copy of the deity; and having perfected the model, he animated it by breathing into its mouth and nostrils, whereupon the clay effigy at once came to life and sneezed.
Same and different: Same clay, same image of the maker and same breath into the nostrils as Genesis; different: the clay is red and mixed with the god's own blood (as in Atrahasis), and the new man's first act is a sneeze, which is why Maori said a blessing when someone sneezed.
9 of 9 · Shilluk (South Sudan)
Shilluk creation story (Juok makes people from local soil), reported by J. G. Frazer
Documented · Retold in English, 1911
Where
White Nile, South Sudan
When
Oral tradition, written down by the missionary Wilhelm Hofmayr in 1911
From the text
They say that the creator Juok moulded all men out of earth, and that while he was engaged in the work of creation he wandered about the world. In the land of the whites he found a pure white earth or sand, and out of it he shaped white men. Then he came to the land of Egypt and out of the mud of the Nile he made red or brown men.
Same and different: Same god shaping people from soil; different: the soil's color explains why peoples look different, and Juok adds legs, arms, eyes, mouth, tongue and ears one by one, each for a practical reason such as hoeing millet.
Scholars offer several explanations, and they often apply different ones to different versions. Many see a shared Near Eastern picture behind the oldest texts. Babylonian, Hebrew and Egyptian writers all lived among potters and brickmakers, and the image of a god working clay was common across the region for centuries before Genesis was written down. Some scholars think Genesis 2 knowingly echoes Mesopotamian creation stories such as Atrahasis, where clay is mixed with a god's blood; others stress how differently Genesis tells it, with one God and the breath of life. The Quran's account is usually read alongside the Bible's, since it names Adam and repeats the clay and the breath. Farther away the debate gets sharper. One view, held by James Frazer and many folklorists, is that the idea arises on its own wherever people make pots and bury their dead in the earth, since clay is the most obvious stuff for a body. Another view notes that many African, Pacific and American versions were written down by missionaries, and some may have picked up Bible details from them. Frazer himself warned that one Tahitian story, with a woman made from a rib, looked like a retelling of Genesis. Others answer that stories like Nuwa's yellow earth (written c. 195 CE) and the Popol Vuh's failed clay man (whose makers knew no Bible) are too old or too different to be copies.
Where do you land?
Did one old story about a potter god travel from people to people, or does anyone who works with clay end up imagining that we were made from it?
Tap one to see how other readers voted.
Connected stories
These stories share people, places or books with this one.
Comes fromAlbert T. Clay, A Hebrew Deluge Story in Cuneiform (1922), with the Atrahasis fragments. The Atrahasis Epic: A Babylonian poem in which the gods make humans to do their work, then try to wipe them out with a great flood; the wise Atrahasis survives in a boat. The best copy was written about 1640 BC. W. G. Lambert and A. R. Millard published the standard English edition in 1969.
What this means
Every text quoted here exists and is linked. The Atrahasis tablet and the Egyptian papyrus are older than any written copy of Genesis. The Shilluk and Maori versions were written down only in the 19th and 20th centuries, so their age before that is not known.
Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.
Folk-lore in the Old Testament (1918)A three-volume study by James George Frazer, a Scottish scholar of myth and religion, published in 1918. Its chapter on the Great Flood gathers flood stories from around the world and compares them with Noah's. Some of its ideas are dated, but its collection of stories is still useful.James George Frazer, Folk-lore in the Old Testament, vol. 1, chapter 1, 'The Creation of Man' (1918)Reference
The Atrahasis EpicA Babylonian poem in which the gods make humans to do their work, then try to wipe them out with a great flood; the wise Atrahasis survives in a boat. The best copy was written about 1640 BC. W. G. Lambert and A. R. Millard published the standard English edition in 1969.Albert T. Clay, A Hebrew Deluge Story in Cuneiform (1922), with the Atrahasis fragmentsPrimary text
Encyclopaedia BritannicaAn encyclopedia first published in Scotland in 1768 and now online. Its articles are written and checked by named experts and editors, which makes it a reliable source for basic facts.Encyclopaedia Britannica, 'Khnum'Reference