Credible Theories Sign in
Shared stories · Floods and lost lands

Lost Lands Under the Sea: Atlantis, Dvaraka and Ys

Share

A rich city, a proud people and one terrible day when the sea comes in and never leaves. Greece, India, Egypt, Wales, Cornwall and Brittany all tell of a land that now lies under the waves.

9 tellings · 4 parts of the world · written down c. 1900-1800 BCE to 1864

Plato tells of Atlantis, an island empire that sank in a single day and night. Long before him, an Egyptian sailor heard a giant serpent say that its island would be changed into waves. The Mahabharata tells how the sea poured into Krishna's city of Dvaraka as its last people walked away. Old Tamil poems remember a river and a mountain south of India's tip, taken by the raging sea.

On the Atlantic coast of Europe the same story turns up again and again. A Welsh poem blames a maiden who let a well overflow and drowned a whole plain. In Brittany a princess steals her father's silver key and opens the sluice gates of Ys. In Cornwall, fishermen say 140 churches lie between Land's End and the Scilly Isles. In the 1800s scientists even drew a lost continent, Lemuria, on the map. Below, each version is quoted from a public-domain translation, with a link so you can read it in full.

The open question: Do these stories keep real memories of lost coastlines, or is a drowned city simply a story people tell to warn against pride? Join the debate

Follow the story through time

  1. Ancient EgyptianEgypt · c. 1900-1800 BCE · Ancient text
  2. Hindu (Sanskrit epic)Dvaraka · c. 400 BCE · Ancient text
  3. Greek, retold in a Roman-era geographyHelike, on the Gulf of Corinth, Greece · 373 BCE · Ancient text
  4. GreekAthens · c. 360 BCE · Ancient text
  5. Tamil (South India)Tamil Nadu, southern tip of India · c. 5th-6th century CE · Ancient text
  6. WelshCardigan Bay, Wales · c. 1250 CE · Medieval text
  7. BretonBay of Douarnenez, Brittany, France · 15th century · Retold in English
  8. CornishBetween Land's End and the Isles of Scilly, Cornwall, England · c. 1478 · Medieval text
  9. Modern science (19th-century Europe)Germany and Britain · 1864 · Modern book

The versions, quoted side by side

1 of 9 · Ancient Egyptian

The Tale of the Shipwrecked Sailor (the serpent's island)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 1900-1800 BCE
Where
Egypt; the papyrus is now in the Hermitage Museum, St Petersburg
When
Middle Kingdom, c. 1900-1800 BCE (12th Dynasty papyrus)
From the text
But, when thou shalt depart from this place, thou shalt never more see this isle; it shall be changed into waves.
The serpent's farewell to the sailor (Petrie, First Series, 'The Shipwrecked Sailor') · Translation: W. M. Flinders Petrie (ed.), Egyptian Tales, First Series, 1895

Same and different: Same idea of a rich, far-off island that will vanish under the sea; different: no one is punished, the island belongs to a kindly serpent prince of Punt, and its sinking is foretold, not seen.

2 of 9 · Hindu (Sanskrit epic)

Mahabharata, Mausala Parva (the end of Dvaraka)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 400 BCE
Where
Dvaraka (Dwarka), Gujarat coast, western India
When
Epic composed c. 400 BCE to 400 CE; oldest manuscripts are much later
From the text
After all the people had set out, the ocean, that home of sharks and alligators, flooded Dwaraka, which still teemed with wealth of every kind, with its waters. Whatever portion of the ground was passed over, ocean immediately flooded over with his waters.
Mausala Parva, Section 7 · Translation: Kisari Mohan Ganguli, The Mahabharata, Book 16: Mausala Parva, 1883-1896

Same and different: Same rich city taken by the sea at the end of an age; different: the people are led out first by Arjuna, and the sea follows right behind them, swallowing each step of ground they leave.

3 of 9 · Greek, retold in a Roman-era geography

Strabo, Geography (the sinking of Helike)

Documented · Ancient text, 373 BCE
Where
Helike, on the Gulf of Corinth, Greece
When
The city sank in 373 BCE; Strabo wrote c. 7 BCE to 23 CE
From the text
Helice was submerged by the sea two years before the battle at Leuctra. And Eratosthenes says that he himself saw the place, and that the ferrymen say that there was a bronze Poseidon in the strait, standing erect, holding a hippo-campus in his hand, which was perilous for those who fished with nets.
Strabo, Geography 8.7.2 · Translation: Horace Leonard Jones, The Geography of Strabo (Loeb), 1917-1932; Book 8 in vol. IV, 1927

Same and different: Same anger of a god (Poseidon) and a city swallowed in one night; different: this is a real, dated event, and since 2001 archaeologists have found its remains buried under coastal mud rather than open sea.

4 of 9 · Greek

Plato, Timaeus (Atlantis)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 360 BCE
Where
Athens; the story is said to come from priests at Sais in Egypt
When
Written c. 360 BCE
From the text
But afterwards there occurred violent earthquakes and floods; and in a single day and night of misfortune all your warlike men in a body sank into the earth, and the island of Atlantis in like manner disappeared in the depths of the sea.
Timaeus 25c-d · Translation: Benjamin Jowett, Timaeus, 1871 (Project Gutenberg text)

Same and different: The model for many later stories: a great power, an earthquake and flood, and a land gone in a day; different: Plato places it beyond the Pillars of Heracles 9,000 years before Solon, and it is Athens, not a god, that first defeats Atlantis.

5 of 9 · Tamil (South India)

Silappatikaram, canto 11 (the land south of Kumari)

Documented · Ancient text, c. 5th-6th century CE
Where
Tamil Nadu, southern tip of India
When
Epic usually dated c. 5th-6th century CE (some scholars say earlier)
From the text
The river Pahruli, and the mountain Kumari, surrounded by many hills, were submerged by the raging sea.
Silappatikaram 11, as quoted in Kanakasabhai, chapter 2, p. 20 note · Translation: V. Kanakasabhai, The Tamils Eighteen Hundred Years Ago, 1904 (his translation, in a footnote)

Same and different: Same memory of a whole country lost to the sea; different: it is told as plain history of the Pandyan kingdom, with no sin or punishment. Later writers named this land Kumari Kandam and joined it to the European idea of Lemuria.

6 of 9 · Welsh

Black Book of Carmarthen, the Seithenhin poem (Cantre'r Gwaelod)

Documented · Medieval text, c. 1250 CE
Where
Cardigan Bay, Wales
When
Manuscript written c. 1250 CE; the poem may be older
From the text
Seithennin, stand thou forth / And see the vanguard of the main: / Gwydno's plain has it covered. / Accursed be the maiden / Who let it loose after supping, / Well cup-bearer of the mighty main.
Black Book of Carmarthen, the Seithenhin verses, first two triplets (Rhys, chapter VI) · Translation: John Rhys, Celtic Folklore: Welsh and Manx, vol. 1, 1901

Same and different: Same fertile plain and a single careless act that lets the sea in; different: in this oldest form a maiden lets a well overflow. The later, better-known version blames Seithennin, a drunken prince who forgot to close the sea gates.

7 of 9 · Breton

The Legend of Ys (King Gradlon and Dahut)

Documented · Retold in English, 15th century
Where
Bay of Douarnenez, Brittany, France
When
In Breton chronicles from the 15th century; told in full by Albert Le Grand, 1636; retold here in 1917
From the text
Stealing noiselessly into her sleeping father's chamber she detached from his girdle the key he guarded so jealously and opened the gate. The water immediately rushed in and submerged the entire city.
Chapter VII, 'The Legend of Ys' · Translation: Lewis Spence, Legends and Romances of Brittany, 1917 (an English retelling, not a translation of one text)

Same and different: Same city protected from the sea, a secret gate and one person who opens it; very close to the Welsh well-maiden. Different: the king escapes on horseback, and his daughter becomes a mermaid who sings over the drowned city.

8 of 9 · Cornish

The Tradition of the Lyonesse (Lethowsow)

Documented · Medieval text, c. 1478
Where
Between Land's End and the Isles of Scilly, Cornwall, England
When
William of Worcester noted the lost churches c. 1478; Richard Carew 1602; collected by Hunt in 1865
From the text
No less than 140 churches stood over that region, which is now a waste of waters; and the rocks called the Seven Stones are said to mark the place of a large city.
'The Tradition of the Lyonesse or Lethowsow', pp. 208-209 · Translation: Robert Hunt, Popular Romances of the West of England, First Series, 1865

Same and different: Same rich, pious land drowned in one great flood; different: one man, an ancestor of the Trevelyan family, outruns the sea on horseback, and the Seven Stones reef is pointed out as the city's grave.

9 of 9 · Modern science (19th-century Europe)

Ernst Haeckel, The History of Creation (Lemuria)

Documented · Modern book, 1864
Where
Germany and Britain; the lost land placed in the Indian Ocean
When
Named by Philip Sclater in 1864; Haeckel's book 1868, English translation 1876
From the text
there are a number of circumstances (especially chorological facts) which suggest that the primæval home of man was a continent now sunk below the surface of the Indian Ocean, which extended along the south of Asia
Vol. II, chapter XXIII · Translation: Ernst Haeckel, The History of Creation, vol. II, English translation revised by E. Ray Lankester (1880 printing)

Same and different: Same picture of a whole land sunk under the ocean; different: this was a scientist's answer to a puzzle (lemur fossils in Madagascar and India), not a story of sin. Plate tectonics later explained the puzzle without a sunken continent.

Why are these stories so alike?

Scholars offer several explanations, and they often apply to different stories. Many see Plato's Atlantis as a story he made to teach a lesson about pride and the ideal city, since no earlier Greek writer mentions it. Others look for a real event behind it, such as the eruption of Thera (Santorini) around 1600 BCE, which wrecked the Minoan world. Some versions do rest on real losses. Helike sank in 373 BCE, and since 2001 archaeologists have found remains of it under coastal mud. Divers off the Gujarat coast have found stone structures near modern Dwarka, though their age and meaning are debated. Geologists also point out that sea levels rose about 120 meters after the last Ice Age, drowning coastal plains like Doggerland in the North Sea and the land bridges around India and Sri Lanka, so many coastlines really did lose land. The Celtic stories of Wales, Brittany, Cornwall and Ireland are so alike (a city, a sea gate or well, a careless woman or drunk prince) that folklorists like John Rhys saw them as one shared story told along the Atlantic coast, perhaps kept alive by drowned forests that show at low tide. Lemuria is different: it was a 19th-century scientific guess, later dropped once plate tectonics explained why similar animals live on far-apart lands.

Where do you land?

Do these stories keep real memories of lost coastlines, or is a drowned city simply a story people tell to warn against pride?

Tap one to see how other readers voted.

Connected stories

These stories share people, places or books with this one.

Next shared story: Cinderella Around the World: Rhodopis, Cenerentola and Aschenputtel → All shared stories

Where this comes from

EvidenceDocumented

Comes from Plato, Timaeus and Critias, trans. Benjamin Jowett. Plato's Timaeus: A dialogue written by the Greek philosopher Plato in Athens around 360 BC. It opens with the story of Atlantis, said to come from Egyptian priests by way of the Athenian lawmaker Solon, then explains how the world was made. It is the oldest source for Atlantis; no earlier writer mentions it.

What this means

Every text quoted here exists and is linked. Helike's sinking is a documented event and remains of it have been found. Rising seas after the Ice Age really did drown coastlines. No evidence has been found for Atlantis or a sunken Lemurian continent.

Primary records exist: an original document, a published text, an official file or a dated report. We link to them. This level says the record exists and what it says, not that every claim in it is true.

See all five labels

Sources

  1. Plato's TimaeusA dialogue written by the Greek philosopher Plato in Athens around 360 BC. It opens with the story of Atlantis, said to come from Egyptian priests by way of the Athenian lawmaker Solon, then explains how the world was made. It is the oldest source for Atlantis; no earlier writer mentions it.Plato, Timaeus and Critias, trans. Benjamin JowettPrimary text Archived copy, 2026-08-17
  2. Project GutenbergThe oldest digital library, started in 1971, with more than 70,000 free e-books whose copyright has run out. Volunteers type and check the texts against printed editions.John Rhys, Celtic Folklore: Welsh and Manx, vol. 1, chapter VI (1901)Reference
  3. WikipediaA free online encyclopedia written and edited by volunteers. It is a good starting point and usually lists its own sources, but anyone can change it, so we treat it as a guide to better sources, not the final word.Wikipedia, 'Atlantis' (Plato's account and the main theories, with citations)Reference Archived copy, 2026-10-03
  4. WikipediaWikipedia, 'Lemuria' (Sclater, Haeckel, the Theosophists and Kumari Kandam, with citations)Reference
  5. WikipediaWikipedia, 'Helike' (the 373 BCE sinking and the 2001 excavations, with citations)Reference Archived copy, 2026-09-21

Updated

Discussion